We consider a shape optimization problem related to the persistence threshold for a biological species, the unknown shape corresponding to the zone of the habitat which is favorable to the population. Analytically, this translates in the minimization of a weighted eigenvalue of the Dirichlet Laplacian, with respect to a bang-bang indefinite weight. For such problem, we provide a full description of the singularly perturbed regime in which the volume of the favorable zone vanishes, with particular attention to the interplay between its location and shape.First, we show that the optimal favorable zone shrinks to a connected, nearly spherical set, in C1,1 sense, which aims at maximizing its distance from the lethal boundary. Secondly, we show that the spherical asymmetry of the optimal favorable zone decays exponentially, with respect to a negative power of its volume, in the C1,α sense, for every α<1. This latter property is based on sharp quantitative asymmetry estimates for the optimization of a weighted eigenvalue problem on the full space, of independent interest.