The formation of highly stable water-in-oil emulsions results in complications in both upstream and downstream processing. Emulsion stability in these systems has been connected to the adsorption of surface-active asphaltenes that are assumed to form a rigidified film at the oil/water (o/w) interface. Full characterization of this behavior is needed to allow for engineered solutions for enhanced oil recovery. Interfacial properties, such as surface pressure and interfacial elasticity, are implicated in the stabilizing mechanism for these observed films. Asphaltenes are known to be interfacially active in both good solvents (aromatics) and poor solvents (high ratio of aliphatic to aromatic). However, due to inherent complexities present in asphaltene studies, the details of the mechanical properties of the interface remain poorly understood. Despite the widely accepted perception that asphaltenes form persistent rigid films at fluid-fluid interfaces, the connection between bulk solution properties and interfacial mechanics has not been resolved. Here, the effects of solvent quality on the interfacial properties of asphaltene dispersions are determined by using a well-defined asphaltene/solvent system. Interfacial rigidity is observed only under poor solvent conditions, while the good solvent system remains fluid-like. The interfacial rheology under good and poor solvent conditions is measured simultaneously with surface pressure measurements to track interfacial development. It is shown that surface pressure and dilatational modulus measurements are not indicators of whether an interface demonstrates rigid behavior under large compressions. Finally, conditions required for asphaltene-coated interfaces to exhibit the mechanical behavior associated with a rigidified interface are defined. This work provides a framework for quantifying the impact of the aggregation state of asphaltenes on the stability and mechanics at the o/w interface.