In Response: We appreciate the comments made by Dr. Mulroy. However, we have a different interpretation of the existing evidence. Although there may be initial evidence to suggest that a total regional technique has advantages over general anesthesia in outpatient shoulder arthroscopy, there has never been a well designed prospective study to support this conclusion. Both Brown et al.'s [1] and D'Alessio et al.'s [2] studies are retrospective reviews. Interscalene block could be used as the only anesthetic technique in shoulder surgery. However, the success rate of interscalene block is variable. Even with the supplementation of the superficial cervical block [3] or upper thoracic paravertebral block [4], the failure rates range from 3.4% [4] to 18% [3]. The failure rate is 16% in Brown et al.'s study [1] and 8.7% in D'Alessio et al.'s study [2]. In Brown et al.'s [1] study, the reasons for failures were inadequate block when 30 mL or less local anesthetics were used, local anesthetic toxicity, dyspnea, and inability to swallow, reflecting vagus nerve involvement [1]. The block was also complicated by Horner's syndrome and hoarseness [1]. We agree with Dr. Mulroy's suggestion that the addition of suprascapular block with a long-acting local anesthetic would provide prolonged analgesia, outlasting the usual duration of interscalene block with Lidocaine. This combined approach would also probably prove useful in outpatient shoulder arthroscopy. Since the completion of our study, we have modified our technique for the suprascapular block. Dangoisse et al. [5] described a vertical approach to the suprascapular nerve, in which paresthesia and the use of a nerve stimulator were not required. The distribution of the local anesthetic in the supraspinatous fossa was confirmed by the magnetic resonance imaging, and all patients reported good pain relief [5]. This approach is much simpler and has allowed us to perform the suprascapular block in less than 5 min. In summary, the failure rate of interscalene block as the sole anesthetic technique is variable outside major centers for regional anesthesia. The suprascapular block offers an effective alternative for prolonged perioperative analgesia and has a much more user-friendly profile. Doris Tong, MD, FRCPC Frances Chung, MD, FRCPC Ewan Ritchie, MBChB The Toronto Hospital, Western Division; Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Read full abstract