lUR H EDITORIAL Editorial: the philosophy of trade union rights It journal organisations isa fairly would safe and agree bet that that that trade most trade union ifnot unions rights allreaders are areimportant important ofthis journal would agreethat trade unions areimportant organisations andthat trade union rights areimportant rights. But itisby nomeans certain that allreaders would agree astowhy trade union rights areimportant. Itistothis seemingly straightforward question that weturn our attention for the current edition ofIUR. Wehave encouraged our contributors totake us right back tophilosophical basics, examining how a number oflines ofphilosophical reasoning might beapplied tothe question. Wedonot suggest that the philosophers inquestion supported trade union rights. Rather that the ideas they put forward canserve asjustifications orrationales for trade unionism and /or for the protection of trade union rights. Most of thephilosophical theories weconsider inthis edition are concerned with the articulation of human rights orsocial justice .Our contributors were asked toreflect onthe extent to which these diverse theoretical positions could besaidto support arguments infavour of trade union rights. Early thinkers took their cuesastowhat wasmorally right from principles handed down bythechurch orfrom the emerging theory ofnatural innate rights ofman. Academic lawyer Filip Dorrsemont examines the evolution of the official teaching of the Catholic Church ontrade unionism and concludes that the Church offers a timid andrestricted vision of trade union rights, but notes that ithasconsistently emphasised its support for these rights. Tonla Novltz, alsoa legal academic, examines the more secular side ofnatural rights thinking inorder toexamine how a novel aspect ofLocke's 17thCentury natural rights framework, property rights, might serve workers' interests. The18th Century German thinker Immanuel Kant was concerned with the'good'.Hethought that morally right principles could beascertained by abstract reasoning by a disinterested person, and that a person could live a moral life by reflecting onwhat these principles were and by respecting them intheir conduct. Contemporary philosopher Nina Power takes usthrough some of these ideas inanoverview ofoneofthetrue giants ofthehistory ofphilosophical thought. Kant, asPower tells us,'clears the ground for trying toimagine what equality anduniversality would look like inpractice'. 20th Century American liberal philosopher John Rawls alsorelied onthis ideaofdisinterested metaphysical reflection, employing a radical 'thought experiment' toask the question astowhat principles of justice individuals would agree towhen designing society if they hadnoideawhat their placewould be within that society. Contemporary philosopher Stuart White talks usthrough thedemocratic, liberal concept ofsociety that Rawls believed his'original position' thought-experiment entailed. Materialists, suchas 19th Century German thinker Karl Marx, reject theideathat quiet, disinterested metaphysical reflection canalone provide solutions tomoral andpolitical problems. Rather, materialists argue that moral and political problems arerooted clearly in the material world, in the relations ofthesocial classes, andaround themeans ofproduction . John Kelly, professor ofindustrial relations, argues that 'diffuse notions offairness' probably influence unions more than serious Marxist analysis. From a democratic position professor Steven Friedman takes upa materialist mode ofargument andtells usthat unions are'essential' engines ofengagement that facilitate participation bythe poor Inpolitics anddecision-making. German philosopher andlegal critic Jürgen Habermas alsocited much of his early work ina Marxist context though inlater years histhinking became rather more complex. Legal academic Ruth Dukes explains Habermas' communitarian views. Contemporary American philosopher Michael Sandel is another communitarian, butonewhose ideas evolved from Rawlsian liberalism rather than Marxism. Alan Bogg argues that Sandel's ideashave direct relevance to trade unionists. Heargues that the participation ofcitizens inpublic life, facilitated by trade unions, canhelp toproduce a more just world. Inclosing, egalitarian thinker andco-author of TheSpirit Level Richard Wilkinson outlines how heseetrade unions fitting within a framework of social equality. Crucially for trade union internationalists heshows how the Cold War period of ideological confrontation influenced social conditions and thinking onequality inthe 20th Century. Looking around us today Wilkinson reminds usthat internationally there isa correlation between countries with strong trade union movements andgreater equality. Daniel Blackburn andElizabeth Molinari INTERNATIONAL union rights Page 2Volume 18Issue 42012 Next issue of IUR Articles between 850and1,900words should besentbyemail (mail@ictur.org) andaccompanied bya photograph andshort biographical note oftheauthor. Photographs illustrating thetheme ofarticles arealways welcome. Allitems must bewith usby20March 2012if they are tobeconsidered for publication inthenext issueofIUR. Subscribe toIUR: tosubscribe, complete theboxbelow. I/we would like tosubscribe toInternational Union Rights andenclose£20/US$30/€25. Name/Organisation Address PostCode Four issues£20/US$30...