Small Pool PCR Research Articles

Genomic context drives SCA7 CAG repeat instability, while expressed SCA7 cDNAs are intergenerationally and somatically stable in transgenic mice.

Spinocerebellar ataxia type 7 (SCA7) is an autosomal dominant cerebellar ataxia caused by a CAG repeat expansion in the ataxin-7 gene. In humans, SCA7 is characterized by marked anticipation due to intergenerational repeat instability with a bias toward expansion, and is thus regarded as the most unstable of the polyglutamine diseases. To study the molecular basis of CAG/CTG repeat instability and its pathological significance, we generated lines of transgenic mice carrying either a SCA7 cDNA construct or a 13.5 kb SCA7 genomic fragment with 92 CAG repeats. While the cDNA transgenic mice showed little intergenerational repeat instability, the genomic fragment transgenic mice displayed marked intergenerational instability with an obvious expansion bias. We then went on to generate additional lines of genomic fragment transgenic mice, and observed that deletion of the 3' genomic region significantly stabilized intergenerational transmission of the SCA7 CAG92 repeat. These results suggest that cis-information present on the genomic fragment is driving the instability process. As the SCA7 genomic fragment contains a large number of replication-associated motifs, the presence of such sequence elements may make the SCA7 CAG repeat region more susceptible to instability. Small-pool and standard PCR analysis of tissues from genomic fragment mice revealed large repeat expansions in their brains and livers, but no such changes were found in any tissues from cDNA transgenic mice that have been shown to undergo neurodegeneration. As large somatic repeat expansions are absent from the brains of SCA7 cDNA mice, our results indicate that neurodegeneration can occur without marked somatic mosaicism, at least in these mice.

The GAA triplet-repeat sequence in Friedreich ataxia shows a high level of somatic instability in vivo, with a significant predilection for large contractions.

Friedreich ataxia is commonly caused by large expansions of a GAA triplet-repeat (GAA-TR) sequence in the first intron of the FRDA gene. We used small-pool PCR to analyze somatic variability among 7190 individual FRDA molecules from peripheral blood DNA of subjects carrying 12 different expanded alleles, ranging in size from 241 to 1105 triplets. Expanded alleles showed a length-dependent increase in somatic variability, with mutation loads ranging from 47% to 78%. We noted a strong contraction bias among long alleles (>500 triplets), which showed a 4-fold higher frequency of large contractions versus expansions. Some contractions were very large; of all somatic mutations scored, approximately 5% involved contractions of >50% of the original allele length, and 0.29% involved complete reversion to the normal/premutation length (< or =60 triplets). These observations contrast sharply with the strong expansion bias seen in expanded CTG triplet repeats in myotonic dystrophy. No somatic variability was detected in >6000 individual FRDA molecules analyzed from 15 normal alleles (8-25 triplets). A premutation allele with 44 uninterrupted GAA repeats was found to be unstable, ranging in size from 6 to 113 triplets, thus establishing the threshold for somatic instability between 26 and 44 GAA triplets. Analysis of an additional 7850 FRDA molecules from serially passaged lymphoblastoid cell lines carrying nine expanded alleles (132-933 triplets) showed very low mutation loads, ranging from 0% to 6.2%. Our data indicate that expanded GAA-TR alleles in Friedreich ataxia are highly mutable and have a natural tendency to contract in vivo, and that these properties depend on multiple factors, including DNA sequence, triplet-repeat length and unknown cell-type-specific factors.

Minisatellite instability at the Adh locus reveals somatic polymorphism in amphioxus.

Amphioxus (subphylum Cephalochordata) is the closest living relative to vertebrates and widely used for phylogenetic analyses of vertebrate gene evolution. Amphioxus genes are highly polymorphic, but the origin and nature of this variability is unknown. We have analyzed the alcohol dehydrogenase locus (Adh3) in two amphioxus species (Branchiostoma lanceolatum and Branchiostoma floridae) and found that genetic variation is related to repetitive DNA sequences, mainly minisatellites. Small pool-PCR assays indicated that allelic variants are generated by minisatellite instability. We conclude that the generation of new forms was not preferentially linked to germline processes but rather to somatic events leading to mosaic adult animals. Furthermore, most Adh minisatellites belong to a novel class, which we have named mirages. Their distinctive feature is that the repeat subunit spans the exon-intron boundaries and generates potential duplications of the splice sites. However, splicing may not be compromised as no aberrant mRNA variants were detected.

Minisatellites Show Rare and Simple Intra-allelic Instability in the Mouse Germ Line

Minisatellites provide very informative systems for analyzing processes of tandem repeat DNA turnover in humans. The mouse genome also contains authentic minisatellites, but none has yet been found to show high levels of instability. Indirect evidence using minisatellite variant repeat mapping by PCR in Mus musculus subspecies suggested that mouse minisatellites mutate at a rate below 10−3 per gamete and mainly by intra-allelic events. This is in sharp contrast to the complex interallelic mutations observed at high frequency at some human loci. To define more directly the turnover mechanisms and rates of instability at one of the most variable mouse minisatellites (MMS80), we used size-enrichment small-pool PCR (SESP-PCR) to recover de novo mutant alleles from sperm DNA from homozygous BALB/cJ mice and from strain DHA heterozygotes. The sperm mutation rate at MMS80 was extremely low, at or below 5×10−6 per sperm. Comparison of progenitor and mutant allele structures showed that these rare mutants had arisen by simple and primarily, if not exclusively, intra-allelic mutation events. These results suggest a fundamental difference in turnover mechanisms at minisatellites between mice and human.

Mutation frequency in coding and non-coding repeat sequences in mismatch repair deficient cells derived from normal human tissue.

Repetitive tracts within the coding regions of TGFBR2 and BAX are frequently mutated in mismatch repair deficient tumours and are implicated in tumour progression. However, there has been little study of the balance between selection pressure and inherent instability at sequences within these genes. To determine whether TGFBR2 and BAX are inherently prone to mutations in the presence of MMR defects, we studied MMR deficient cells derived from B-lymphocytes. By analysing cells derived from normal tissue we aimed to minimize the effects of selection pressures that bias the apparent frequency of mutation. We definitively show that certain sequences, usually repaired by MMR, are inherently unstable. Using a small pool PCR technique we confirmed these cells exhibit microsatellite instability. Additionally, we demonstrate that MMR deficiency results in an excess of mutations, specifically at the poly(A)(10) tract compared to other regions of the TGFBR2 gene (P<0.001). Conversely, an excess of mutations does not appear to arise at the poly(G)(8) tract of the BAX gene. These studies provide insight into the mechanism by which TGFBR2 and BAX genes become mutated during tumorigenesis. These findings invoke the notion of "unmasking" specific hypermutable sequences in particular genes adding further complexity to the concept of the mutator phenotype.

Hypermutability at a poly(A/T) tract in the human germline.

Poly(A/T) tracts are abundant simple sequence repeats (SSRs) within the human genome. They constitute part of the coding sequence of a variety of genes, encoding polylysine stretches that are important for protein function. Assessment of poly(A/T) tract stability is also used to identify microsatellite unstable colorectal cancers, which are characteristic of tumours defective in DNA mismatch repair. Despite their importance, little is known about the stability of poly(A/T) SSRs in the human germline. We have determined the stability of a paradigm poly(A/T) tract, BAT-40, by study of population allele frequencies, mutation frequency in families and mutation frequency in sperm DNA. We show that the locus is polymorphic, with a level of heterozygosity of 59.7%. Germline mutation was observed in 13 of 187 germline transmissions (7.0%) in 10 families suggesting BAT-40 is unstable in the germline. Further evidence for germline instability at BAT-40 was provided by small pool PCR analysis of matched blood and sperm DNA templates, revealing a significantly elevated frequency of mutation in the germline (P < 0.001). These findings provide insight into poly(A/T) tract stability in the germline. They also have relevance to the study of gene expression and to determination of microsatellite instability in tumours.

Mutation rates at two human Y-chromosomal microsatellite loci using small pool PCR techniques.

Polymorphic Y-chromosomal short tandem repeats (Y-STRs) are being employed for phylogenetic and evolutionary studies as well as for forensic applications. Precise knowledge of mutation types and rates is essential and has hitherto been obtained from computer simulation or small-sized father/son pairs, or derived from the more intensively studied autosomal STRs, respectively. To establish more accurate values we analysed about 18 000 DNA sequences isolated from sperm cells of three donors, representing highly validated offspring. Two loci were examined, i.e. DYS19 and DYS390. The methodology applied was small pool PCR with automated laser-induced fluorescence detection. The mutation rates for single repeat gains were determined as 0.18% [95% confidence interval (CI) 0.11--0.31%] for DYS390 and 0.21% (95% CI 0.13--0.33%) for DYS19, and two-repeat changes occurred in the order of 0.01%. Assuming a similar rate for the loss of repeats, which could not be detected with our approach, we predict an overall mutation rate of approximately 0.4% per gamete per generation for both Y tetranucleotide loci. Moreover, these results support the stepwise mutation mechanism based on replication slippage. We expect this approach to be useful for individual mutation risk determination, as well as for studies concerning male history.

Limited somatic mosaicism for Friedreich's ataxia GAA triplet repeat expansions identified by small pool PCR in blood leukocytes.

Friedreich's ataxia (FRDA), the most common inherited ataxia, is associated with an unstable expansion of GAA repeats in the first intron of the frataxin gene on chromosome 9. We investigated the mosaicism of expanded alleles to elucidate the basis for genotype phenotype correlations. We studied the instability of the GAA repeat in blood leukocytes from 45 individuals including 20 FRDA patients and 20 non-affected controls using small pool PCR combined with Southern blotting and hybridization. Expanded GAA repeats could be resolved into distinct alleles showing differences in length up to 1,000 triplets for an individual genome. We found a significant correlation between the size of the largest allele and the range of mosaicism. The somatic mosaicism for expanded repeats observed in FRDA patients rendered the precise measurement of allele sizes more difficult and may influence the results of studies correlating the clinical spectrum with the genotype. Following, a confidential prediction of the prognosis deduced from the repeat length is hardly possible for an individual FRDA patient.

Factors involved in the initial mutation of the fragile X CGG repeat as determined by sperm small pool PCR.

The fragile X syndrome is one of more than a dozen genetic diseases attributed to the amplification of a trinucleotide repeat. Despite the number of these disease loci, relatively little is known about the mechanism(s) that cause a stable allele to become unstable. Population and family studies of the fragile X CGG repeat have identified a number of factors that may play a role in repeat instability including the number of AGG interruptions, purity of the 3' and 5' end of the repeat and cis-acting factors as related to haplotype background. However, studies that assess whether these factors have an impact on the rate and magnitude of change of the repeat are lacking, mainly due to the lack of an appropriate model system. Therefore, in order to dissect the factors involved in the initial mutations of the CGG repeat, small pool (SP)-PCR was performed on DNA derived from sperm and blood from seven unaffected males whose repeat sizes range from 20 to 33. Using the SP-PCR-derived data, regression analyses suggested that components of the repeat structure such as the number of interruptions and purity of the 3' end of the repeat are important determinants of germline repeat instability. In contrast, elements other than repeat structure, such as haplotype background, seemed to have an impact on somatic repeat instability. The factors identified for either cell type, however, explained only a small portion of the variance, suggesting that other factors may be involved in this process.

Sequence interruptions confer differential stability at microsatellite alleles in mismatch repair-deficient cells.

Determinants of instability at a given microsatellite repeat merits investigation in view of relevance to understanding evolution of mutations at such sequences in human populations. The microsatellite D2S123 was studied as a paradigm CA repeat marker. Furthermore, this marker is one of a recommended panel used in molecular screening for hereditary non-polyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC). In this investigation we show that the mutation rate at the D2S123 locus is markedly influenced by intra-allelic sequence variation within the repetitive tract itself. We employed a novel approach to characterize the nature of instability at D2S123, by utilizing cells derived from a non-tumour lineage, which harbour a dominant negative mismatch repair (MMR) mutation and a mutator phenotype. Individual alleles were typed using a semi-quantitative small pool PCR technique and this demonstrated substantial allele-these specific bias in susceptibility to mutation at the D2S123 locus. In support of these in vitro data, bias in allele mutation rate was also observed in tumours from 41 HNPCC patients, which was dependent on constitutional genotype. Sequencing of cell line and patient DNAs revealed that short alleles are significantly more susceptible to mutation due to the presence of uninterrupted CA repeats. Long D2S123 alleles are intrinsically more stable because of a TA interspersion within the repetitive tract. In addition to extending understanding of mutation at CA repeat dinucleotide tracts, these findings have considerable relevance both to screening programmes and to correlation of microsatellite instability (MSI) with colon cancer survival. The manifestation of tumour MSI may be substantially influenced by constitutional genotype.

Direct analysis by small-pool PCR of MS205 minisatellite mutation rates in sperm after mutagenic therapies

We have used small-pool PCR to analyse mutation in samples of sperm taken from men after mutagenic therapy. Small-pool PCR uses direct analysis of germline DNA at a highly unstable tandem-repeated “minisatellite” locus to measure rates of length-change mutation in individual sperm samples. The advantages of this approach are that the normal mutation rate is extremely high (about 0.4% per gamete at the locus analysed here), so that relatively small increases in mutation rate can be detectable in individual samples. It is known from work on sperm from untreated individuals that different alleles at this locus have different mutation rates. For this reason, we have analysed the germline mutation rates in sperm samples from two men, in each case comparing a post-treatment sample with a pre-treatment sample from the same individual. We find no evidence for altered mutation in the post-treatment sample, suggesting that the repopulation of the germ-cell compartment after treatment may be subject to stringent mechanisms for the detection and elimination of germ-cell damage.

Extremely complex repeat shuffling during germline mutation at human minisatellite B6.7.

Human minisatellite B6.7 is a highly variable locus showing extensive heterozygosity with alleles ranging from six to >500 repeat units. Paternal and maternal mutation rates to new length alleles were estimated from pedigrees at 7.0 and 3.9% per gamete, respectively, indicating that B6.7 is one of the most unstable minisatellites isolated to date. Mutation at this locus was also analysed by small pool PCR of sperm and blood DNA. Male germline instability varied from <0.8 to 14% per allele and increased with tandem array size. In contrast, the frequency of mutants in somatic (blood) DNA was far lower (<0.5%), consistent with a meiotic origin of germline mutants. Sperm mutants were further characterized by minisatellite variant repeat mapping using four major polymorphic sites within the B6.7 repeats. This highly informative system revealed a wide variety of changes in allele structure, including simple intra-allelic duplications and deletions and more complicated inter- and intra-allelic transfers of repeat blocks, as seen at other human minisatellites. The main mode of sperm mutation, however, resulted in extremely complex allele reorganization with evidence of inter-allelic transfer plus the generation of novel repeats by rearrangement at the sub-repeat level, suggesting that recombinational instability at B6.7 is a complex multistep process.

Somatic instability of the CTG repeat in mice transgenic for the myotonic dystrophy region is age dependent but not correlated to the relative intertissue transcription levels and proliferative capacities.

A (CTG)nexpansion in the 3'-untranslated region (UTR) of the DM protein kinase gene ( DMPK ) is responsible for causing myotonic dystrophy (DM). Major instability, with very large expansions between generations and high levels of somatic mosaicism, is observed in patients. There is a good correlation between repeat size (at least in leucocytes), clinical severity and age of onset. The trinucleotide repeat instability mechanisms involved in DM and other human genetic diseases are unknown. We studied somatic instability by measuring the CTG repeat length at several ages in various tissues of transgenic mice carrying a (CTG)55expansion surrounded by 45 kb of the human DM region, using small-pool PCR. These mice have been shown to reproduce the intergenerational and somatic instability of the 55 CTG repeat suggesting that surrounding sequences and the chromatin environment are involved in instability mechanisms. As observed in some of the tissues of DM patients, there is a tendency for repeat length and somatic mosaicism to increase with the age of the mouse. Furthermore, we observed no correlation between the somatic mutation rate and tissue proliferation capacity. The somatic mutation rates in different tissues were also not correlated to the relative inter-tissue difference in transcriptional levels of the three genes (DMAHP , DMPK and 59) surrounding the repeat.

Mutation rate heterogeneity and the generation of allele diversity at the human minisatellite MS205 (D16S309).

Many tandemly repeated minisatellite loci display extreme levels of length variation as a consequence of high rates of spontaneous germline mutation altering repeat copy number. Direct screening for new allele lengths by small-pool PCR has shown that instability at the human minisatellite locus MS205 (D16S309) is largely germline specific and usually results in the gain or loss of just a few repeat units. Structural analysis of the order of variant repeats has shown that these events occur preferentially at one end of the tandem array and can result in complex rearrangements including the inter-allelic transfer of repeat units. In contrast, putative mutants recovered from somatic DNA occur at a substantially lower rate and are simple and non-polar in nature. Germline mutation rates vary considerably between alleles, consistent with regulation occurring in cis. Although examination of DNA sequence polymorphisms immediately flanking the minisatellite reveals no definitive associations with germline mutation rate variation, differences in rate may be paralleled by changes in mutation spectrum. These findings help to explain the diversity of MS205 allele structures in modern humans and suggest a common mutation pathway with some other minisatellites.

Instability of the Expanded (CTG)nRepeats in the Myotonin Protein Kinase Gene in Cultured Lymphoblastoid Cell Lines from Patients with Myotonic Dystrophy

The mutation associated with myotonic dystrophy (DM) is the expansion of an unstable trinucleotide repeat, (CTG)n, in the 3′-untranslated region of the myotonin protein kinase gene. Although expanded repeats show both germline and somatic instability, the mechanisms of the instability are poorly understood. To establish a model system in which somatic instability of the DM repeat could be studied in more detail, we established lymphoblastoid cell lines (LBCL) from DM patients. Analysis of the DNA from DM LBCL using Southern blotting showed that the (CTG)nrepeats were apparently stable up to 29 passages in culture. To study infrequent repeat size mutations that are undetectable due to the size heterogeneity, we established LBCL of single-cell origins by cloning using multiple steps of limiting dilution. After expansion to approximately 106cells (equivalent to approximately 20 cell cycles), the DNAs of these cell lines were analyzed by the small pool PCR technique using primers flanking the (CTG)nrepeat region. Two types of mutations of the expanded (CTG)nrepeat alleles were detected: (1) frequent mutations that show small changes of the (CTG)nrepeat size, resulting in alleles in a normal distribution around the progenitor allele, and (2) relatively rare mutations with large changes of the (CTG)nrepeat size, with a bias toward contraction. The former may represent the mechanism responsible for the somatic heterogeneity of the (CTG)nrepeat size observed in blood cells of DM patients. Thisin vitroexperimental system will be useful for further studies on mechanisms involved in the regulation of the somatic stability of the (CTG)nrepeats in DM.

Analysis of germline variation at the FMR1 CGG repeat shows variation in the normal-premutated borderline range.

In order to characterize the dynamics of CGG repeat instability at the fragile X syndrome locus (FMR1 gene), we have used small pool PCR to estimate the mutation rate within germline (sperm) and somatic tissue (leukocytes) of two normal males, one carrying the most common 29 CGG repeats allele, the other carrying a borderline normal-premutated allele of 55 repeats. Large contractions and moderate expansions of the repeat were found in sperm and blood for the 55 repeat allele while almost no variation was found in sperm or blood with the 29 repeat allele. Somatic blood DNA exhibited fewer expansions and contractions than sperm. Contractions were more frequent than expansions, and all the expansions were found in the +4 to +10 repeats range, while most of the contractions were found in the -10 to -30 range, suggesting that a subset of contractions results from a distinct mechanism. These results also suggest that the dynamics of the CGG repeat could be partly due to germline instability within the high normal or premutated ranges.