Abstract Introduction In a recent analysis of PSG studies with six, nine and twelve human scorers, we showed that sleep stage ambiguity is the rule rather than the exception, and that sleep stage probabilities (SSPs) calculated with artificial intelligence provide an excellent estimate of this ambiguity. Here we investigate clinical and demographic factors driving this ambiguity and evaluate potential benefits of using hypnodensity in addition to the traditional hypnogram for sleep assessment. Methods SSPs were determined in 195 healthy subjects aged 20–95 years and in 49 apnea patients aged 29–73 years (AHI: 5.8–105.5 events/hour). In addition to the recommended sleep parameters, we derived the percentage of ambiguous sleep stages (SSP ≤ 0.95), the mean amount of ambiguity per sleep stage (1-SSP), sleep stage continuity (absolute difference in SSP between two epochs) and sleep stage stability (two adjacent epochs belonging to the same sleep stage with SSP > 0.95 each) as well as NREM sleep depth (weighted average of NREM SSPs). Results The percentages of ambiguous NREM epochs (±SD) increased significantly with age (Pearson’s r=0.72; p< 0.01) from 40±9% in young healthy subjects (20-39 years, n=61) to 50±9% in middle-aged healthy subjects (40-59 years, n=59) and to 62±11% in older healthy subjects (≥ 60 years, n=75). The percentages of ambiguous REM epochs did not change significantly across age (r=0.1). Apnea patients showed an increased NREM ambiguity (77±15% compared to 53±10% in age- and sex-matched healthy controls; p< 0.01), while REM ambiguity was only slightly increased (p< 0.05). Furthermore, sleep stage continuity, stability, and NREM sleep depth decrease significantly with age and are significantly lower in apnea patients than in healthy controls (p< 0.01). Conclusion Artificial intelligence-based autoscoring shows ambiguity in 40% of NREM epochs in young healthy subjects, increasing to 77% in apnea patients. Assigning a single sleep stage to each epoch and presenting sleep architecture as a traditional hypnogram may be misleading, especially for older subjects and patients with sleep-disordered breathing. A hypnodensity chart representing sleep stage probabilities reflects this sleep staging ambiguity, provides all the information contained in a hypnogram, and offers insights into sleep ambiguity, continuity, stability, and sleep depth. Support (if any)
Read full abstract