The quality of the SCF description of the interactions in a small set of H-bonded adducts (OH 2 … F −, HOH … F −, the water dimer, HF … HF) produced by Slater basis functions is examined, paying particular attention to the basis set superposition error (BSSE), affecting equilibrium distances and interaction energies, and to the effect of counterpoise corrections (CP) on those values. Interaction energies and equilibrium distances are then compared to the results previously obtained using a variety of common gaussian basis sets (STO-3G, MINI-1, 6-31G * *), besides a basis set especially designed to be practically free from BSSE. The Slater basis sets employed are both minimal (best atom zeta (BAZ)) and extended (double zetas with polarization functions added (DZP)). The performance of the BAZ basis set for the neutral dimers is disappointing, since it is analogous to that exhibited by the STO-3G basis set, both at the SCF and CP corrected levels. For the anionic adducts, the BAZ behavior is comparable to that obtained with the use of the MINI-1 basis set, especially at the CP corrected level. On the contrary, the DZP description of the neutral dimers is better than that produced by the extended gaussian basis sets with polarization functions (6-31G * *) at the SCF level and, moreover, when CP corrected, it is able to hold the comparison with the basis set especially designed to be practically free from BSSE, even though each heavy atom is described with ten basis functions less in the outer shells and only one more in the inner shell. For the anionic systems the DZP basis set is slightly worse than for the neutral dimers, in particular for the linear adduct.
Read full abstract