A striking example of convergence, the evolution of similar structures from different antecedent body plans by unrelated organisms, is provided by the comparison of the lower jaws of the Cretaceous toothed bird, Hesperornis, and those of the giant marine lizards known as mosasaurs, whose skeletons are entombed within the same strata. 0. C. Marsh, the discoverer of Hesperornis, himself briefly noted the presence of an intramandibular joint in its jaw (1880, p. 11), but his interest in the retention of teeth and the supposedly primitive brain (cf., Edinger, 1951) of this bird led him to neglect further consideration of this feature. Elsewhere among tetrapods a splenio-angular articulation is known only in the mosasaurs in which it has been described in detail by Williston (1898, pp. 130-134). The structural similarities of the mandibles of mosasaurs and Hesperornis are so great that it is hard to realize that they have arisen independently from rather dissimilar types of reptilian jaws. Yet such is clearly the case, for Hesperornis was a bird, derived from the reptilian Subclass Archosauria, whereas mosasaurs (fig. 6) are modified lizards [Subclass Lepidosauria] close to the living Varanus in their basic structure and undoubtedly derived either from the early Varanidae or their immediate precursors. Besides the distinctive mandibular joint the mosasaurs and Hesperornis show similarities in several other features, all of which may be related to their aquatic habitat and presumably piscivorous diet. Their convergence is thus adaptive and typical of that phenomenon. This discussion is a by-product of an investigation of the jaws which Marsh attributed to another Cretaceous bird, Ichthyornis. Evidence is presented elsewhere which shows that these jaws probably did not belong with that bird skeleton but are actually young mosasaur jaws which were washed into the, same deposit with bird bones of similar size. Routine comparison with Hesperornis, the only other Cretaceous bird sufficiently well known for comparison, brought the convergent condition mentioned above to light. The present report is based upon detailed study of the lower jaws of Hesperornis regalis Marsh, Yale Peabody Museum No. 1206, and of Hesperornis gracilis' Marsh, Kansas University Museum of Natural History No. 2287, which to the best of my knowledge are the only extant specimens of these birds in which skull and mandible are preserved. In the course of this study I have received valued advice and much encouragement from many colleagues, particularly Dr. Tilly Edinger, Dr. Hildegarde Howard, Dr. S. Dillon Ripley, and Dr. Alexander Wetmore. The illustrations were prepared by Miss Shirley Glaser.
Read full abstract