Study of the Lower Devonian Manlius Formation along 250 miles of outcrop in New York State indicates that, by analogy with Recent carbonate environments, it was deposited in an environment very near mean sea-level, and having great lateral extent with very low relief. Three facies can be recognized within the Manlius: supratidal, intertidal, and subtidal, representing carbonate environments slightly above, at, and just below, mean sea-level, respectively. Small fluctuations in water level, caused by lunar tides, storms, or seasonal climatic variations, as well as local differences in sediment accumulation and erosion, resulted in sharp lateral and vertical facies changes with the result that the Manlius today has a complex internal stratigraphy and fossil distribution.The supratidal facies is characterized by non-fossiliferous, laminated, mudcracked, dolomitic, pelletal carbonate mudstone. Mudcracks and spar-filled vugs (bird's-eye structure) indicate frequent subaerial exposure; thin bituminous films separating individual carbonate laminae suggest the presence of algal mats. Dolomitization was penecontemporaneous and is inferred to have been similar to present-day supratidal dolomite formation in Florida and the Bahamas. The intertidal facies is composed of alternating thin beds of sparsely fossiliferous, pelletal, carbonate mudstone and skeletal calcarenite; individual beds commonly lie uncomformably on those below. Many primary structures are evident, especially scour-and-fill, cross-stratification, and limestone-pebble conglomerate. Many fossil occurrences have abundant individuals but only a few taxa are represented. Algal stromatolites and oncolites also are common. A few mudcracks and minor erosional relief on carbonate mudstone beds indicate intermittent subaerial exposure. The subtidal facies is a skeletal, pelletal, carbonate mudstone commonly with well-developed, tabular masses of stromatoporoids. The relatively diverse biota of this facies required continuous marine submergence; its close association and juxtaposition with rocks that clearly indicate periodic subaerial emergence further suggest that water depths were very shallow. The stromatoporoids are interpreted as having grown either as encrusting masses within tidal creeks or channels, or else as closely crowded, individual heads in front of the tidal flats of the intertidal facies. The three facies of the Manlius existed contemporaneously, retreating and advancing continuously with the result that, today, they form a complex facies mosaic. Manlius deposition as a whole took place within and marginal to a broad and shallow, though somewhat restricted, lagoon that developed on the landward side of a wide belt of crinoid meadows, represented by the laterally equivalent Coeymans Formation, which is a brachiopod-rich crinoidal calcarenite. During the Early Devonian marine transgression in the northern part of the Appalachian basin, these environments represented by the Manlius and Coeymans migrated westward with time across New York State.
Read full abstract