Sierra Nevada Mixed-conifer Forest Research Articles

Fire history in northern Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forests across a distinct gradient in productivity

BackgroundUnderstanding the role of fire in forested landscapes is fundamental to fire reintroduction efforts, yet few studies have examined how fire dynamics vary in response to interactions between local conditions, such as soil productivity, and more broadscale changes in climate. In this study, we examined historical fire frequency, seasonality, and spatial patterning in mixed conifer forests across a distinct gradient of soil productivity in the northern Sierra Nevada. We cross-dated 46 different wood samples containing 377 fire scars from 6 paired sites, located on and off of ultramafic serpentine soils. Forests on serpentine-derived soils have slower growth rates, lower biomass accumulation, and patchier vegetation than adjacent, non-serpentine sites. Due to these differences, we hypothesized that historical fire frequency and spatial extent would be reduced in mixed conifer forests growing on serpentine soils.ResultsFire scars revealed a history of frequent fire at all of our sites (median composite interval: 6–22.5 years) despite clear differences in soil productivity. Fire frequency was slightly shorter in more productive non-serpentine sites, but this difference was not consistently significant within our sample pairs. While fires were frequent, both on and off of serpentine, they were also highly asynchronous, and this was largely driven by differing climate–fire relationships. Fires in more productive sites were strongly associated with drought conditions in the year of the fire, while fires in less productive serpentine sites appeared to be more dependent on a cycle of wet and dry conditions in the years preceding the fire. Widespread fires that crossed the boundary between serpentine and non-serpentine were associated with drier than normal years.ConclusionsIn our study, fine-scale variation in historical fire regime attributes was linked to both bottom-up and top-down controls. Understanding how these factors interact to create variation in fire frequency, timing, and spatial extent can help managers more effectively define desired conditions, develop management objectives, and identify management strategies for fire reintroduction and forest restoration projects.

Threats to the persistence of sugar pine (Pinus lambertiana) in the western USA

This study assesses how numerous stressors shape the vital rates (survival, growth, and fecundity) of sugar pine across the vast majority of its range. Sugar pine (Pinus lambertiana Dougl.) is the largest Pinus species, an important timber species, and a component of several dry conifer forest types of western North America, in particular the extensive Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forest. The species faces several challenges in the Anthropocene, including a disrupted fire regime, an invasive pathogen, forest structure changes, and drought with ensuing bark beetle epidemics. Managers are concerned about the conservation outlook for sugar pine, but it is unclear where and how to best invest conservation resources. Using data from the US Forest Service’s Forest Inventory and Analysis program, we estimate the parameters for the vital rate functions and use these to construct an integral projection model which predicts the effects of various stressors on the asymptotic population growth rate. The asymptotic population growth rate is near or slightly below one even under reference conditions, and the actual abundance (in terms of both stem density and basal area) slightly declined over the duration of the study (2001–2019). The analysis reveals that wildfire, white pine blister rust, and forest density are key drivers of the demographic rates of sugar pine across its range. Drought and site dryness had lesser, but still meaningful, effects. Fire has strong negative effects on survival, resulting in a strongly negative population trajectory on burned sites. Conversely, lower than average forest density (plot-level basal area) results in a positive population growth rate via beneficial effects on individual growth. These results highlight the value of fire hazard mitigation, particularly where it also reduces forest density, in the conservation of this important species.

Snag dynamics and surface fuel loads in the Sierra Nevada: Predicting the impact of the 2012–2016 drought

Forest die-backs linked to extreme droughts are expected to increase as the climate dries and warms. An example is the 2012–2016 hotter drought in California that induced widespread tree mortality in the Sierra Nevada, California. The sudden increase in snags (i.e., standing dead trees) raised immediate concerns about their impact on wildfire hazard and longer-term questions about their effect on ecosystem structure and function. We quantified the likely progression of snag fall and fuel succession following the recent extensive mortality event in the southern Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forest. Our results used data from a long-term demography study to project trends in surface fuel loads at three study sites in Yosemite, Sequoia and Kings Canyon national parks. In the short term (2017–2021), fine woody debris and litter + duff significantly increased across all three sites (>145 % and >55 %, respectively); coarse woody debris increased significantly at one site (48.6 %); and total fuel loads increased significantly at two of the three sites (38 % and 69 %). Snag longevity increased with size, with the relationship varying by species. Yellow pine was a notable outlier: size played a small role in influencing its fall rates. Overall, species-specific snag fall rates in the southern Sierra Nevada were 20 % to 40 % slower than previously reported. By 2040, projected median cumulative inputs of biomass from future snag fall range from 49.4 Mg ha−1 to 136.1 Mg ha-1across our three sites, which exceeds the amounts currently present (47.17–89.97 Mg ha−1) and is well above estimates of historical coarse woody debris amounts in the Sierra Nevada (17.7 Mg ha -1). These results provide a robust empirical basis to refine the snag fall algorithm in vegetation simulation models. Options to manage the impact of extreme number of snags and their large surface combustible biomass include salvage operations and prescribed burning, with both methods having operational, financial, and legal limitations that need to be considered.

Spatial patterns of reproduction suggest marginal habitat limits continued range expansion of black bears at a forest-desert ecotone.

Investigating spatial patterns of animal occupancy and reproduction in peripheral populations can provide insight into factors that form species range boundaries. Following historical extirpation, American black bears (Ursus americanus) recolonized the western Great Basin in Nevada from the Sierra Nevada during the late 1900s. This range expansion, however, has not continued further into the Great Basin despite the presence of additional habitat. We aimed to quantify whether reduced reproduction toward the range edge contributes to this range boundary. We analyzed black bear detections from 100 camera traps deployed across black bear distribution in western Nevada using a multistate occupancy model that quantified the probability of occupancy and reproduction (i.e., female bears with cubs occupancy) in relation to changes in habitat type and habitat amount toward the range boundary. We detected a strong effect of habitat amount and habitat type on the probability of black bear occupancy and reproduction. At similar levels of landscape-scale habitat amount (e.g., 50%), estimated probability of occupancy for adult bears in piñon-juniper woodlands near the range boundary was 0.39, compared to ~1.0 in Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest (i.e., core habitat). Furthermore, estimated probability of cub occupancy, conditional on adult bear occupancy, in landscapes with 50% habitat was 0.32 in Great Basin piñon-juniper woodlands, compared to 0.92 in Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest. Black bear range in the western Great Basin conforms to the center-periphery hypothesis, with piñon-juniper woodland at the range edge supporting ecologically marginal habitat for the species compared to habitat in the Sierra Nevada. Further geographic expansion of black bears in the Great Basin may be limited by lower occupancy of reproducing females in piñon-juniper woodland. Center-periphery range dynamics may be common in large carnivore species, as their dispersal ability allows them to colonize low-quality habitat near range edges.

Prescribed fire lessens bark beetle impacts despite varied effects on fuels 13 years after mastication and fire in a Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest

Mastication, thinning, and prescribed fire can help shift fire-prone forests to a structure and composition more resilient to wildfire, but the ability to evaluate treatment effectiveness requires monitoring forest response to disturbances over time after treatment. In this study, we investigated fuel loadings, forest structure, and tree growth to assess treatment legacies thirteen years after mastication, prescribed fire, and surface fuel pull-back from tree boles in Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest. An outbreak of bark beetles between 2011 and 2018 impacted all plots but burned treatments had lower overstory mortality relative to unburned treatments which experienced an 80 % decline in live tree biomass. Tree diameter, canopy density, and surface fuel loadings became similar across all treatments during the 13 year time period. Height to live crown remained elevated in burned treatments relative to the control but had lowered by an average of 1.9 ± 0.3 (SE) m across all treatments. Radial tree growth did not have a sustained response to treatment and was greater in burned treatments for only a single year, 2011, several years post-treatment. Prescribed fire decreased duff mass by 56 % relative to unburned treatments but did not affect forest floor bulk density. Downed woody fuel loadings (1-h – 1000-h) were similar across treatments. The invasive Bromus tectorum (cheatgrass) had uniformly high cover across treatments. Whereas treatments were largely ineffective at producing long-term reductions in surface fuel loadings, the enduring reductions in duff loadings and reduced overstory mortality support the long-term utility of prescribed fire. Cumulatively, our results highlight the potential for prescribed fire to reduce overstory mortality and duff loadings in dry mixed-conifer forests, thereby contributing more effectively to fire-resilient characteristics relative to other fuel reduction treatments.

Growth and spatial patterns of natural regeneration in Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forests with a restored fire regime

Many dry conifer forests in the western United States were historically adapted to frequent low-to-moderate severity fires, but are increasingly susceptible to large, stand-replacing wildfires due to dramatically altered stand conditions and changing climate. The historic tree spatial patterns of mature stands in fire-adapted forests – individual trees, clumps of trees, and openings (ICO) – are associated with heightened resistance and resilience to fire. How this pattern develops over time, however, is not well understood and could help inform reforestation practices better designed to increase fire resistance in developing stands. We investigated growth rates and spatial patterns among regenerating trees in mixed-conifer forests with restored fire regimes in California’s Sierra Nevada. We compared average stocking densities across tree species, size classes, shrub cover, and fire histories. We also examined the effects of microsite topography on spatial patterning of these juvenile trees, and the effects of clump patterning, local stem density and adjacent shrubs on tree growth rates. We found that the majority (75%) of sampled stems were found in clumps. Our mixed-effect models indicated that for trees growing within clumps, increased crowding slowed tree growth, as expected. Surprisingly, however, compared with individual trees growing outside clumps, trees growing within clumps grew significantly faster. Shrub cover in proximity to juvenile trees did not have a consistent impact across our models, but was associated with increased annual height growth. Additionally, plots with high shrub cover had higher stocking rates among the tallest regenerating stems (height > 137 cm). Our findings indicate that clumped spatial patterns of natural tree recruitment may favor the establishment and early growth of regenerating conifers in active-fire forests. While our study focused only on the early stages (<30 years old) of regeneration, our results contrast with common reforestation strategies favoring regular, widely-spaced plantings and aggressive shrub reduction. Our research suggests we need a better understanding of how heterogeneity in the spatial patterns of juvenile trees and shrubs may enhance the resilience of regenerating stands as they mature.

Ancient trees and modern wildfires: Declining resilience to wildfire in the highly fire-adapted giant sequoia

Ancient giant sequoias Sequoiadendron giganteum (Lindl.) J. Buchholz are highly valued trees with limited distribution. They are the most massive trees on earth, and they have exceptional longevity (>3,000 years). Given their extraordinary resilience to wildfire, insects, and disease, most managers hoped giant sequoias would be resistant to anthropogenic change. However, the warming climate and fire exclusion-caused fuel build-up has dramatically increased the amount of high-intensity wildfire in giant sequoia groves since 2015. To better understand recent wildfire effects on large, legacy giant sequoia trees, we surveyed high- and moderate-severity fire areas in groves that burned in three wildfires between 2015 and 2017. Within areas classified as high severity via remote sensing, ∼84% of the 162 large sequoias (>1.2 m diameter at breast height) were killed; in moderate severity, ∼28% of the 239 large sequoias were killed. These rates varied between fires but overall were at the lower end of the mortality range that has been documented in Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forests. Across all three fire areas, we found large sequoia mortality was linked with presence of significant prior fire damage to the lower tree bole (i.e., fire scars or “catfaces”), lower crown ratios, and lower elevations. At Black Mountain Grove, we tracked trees through time and found total crown damage and the presence of fire scars were the best predictors of mortality by year three, where large sequoias sustained up to ∼ 85% crown damage before succumbing to injury. There, 52 of 204 trees were dead one-year postfire, with 71 dead by year three. Overall, these fires caused significant and concerning mortality levels of these ancient trees, and yet the impact on sequoia groves between 2015 and 2017 was dwarfed in comparison to the more recent 2020 Castle Fire, 2021 Windy Fire and 2021 KNP Complex Fire. With the push to increase forest and fuel treatments to reduce catastrophic fire risk across the Western U.S., more immediate triage to protect irreplaceable resources is needed as fire activity rapidly increases. Our study suggests that prioritizing management action that creates fire resilience in unburned groves, and maintains the fuel reduction benefits accrued by past treatments and lower severity wildfires, will be critical to avoid continued losses of these exceptional, irreplaceable old growth forests.

Tree growth responses to extreme drought after mechanical thinning and prescribed fire in a Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest, USA

An estimated 128 M trees died during the 2012–2016 California drought, largely in the southern Sierra Nevada Range. Prescribed burning and mechanical thinning are widely used to reduce fuels and restore ecosystem properties, but it is unclear if these treatments improve tree growth and vigor during extreme drought. This study examined tree growth responses after thinning, prescribed burning, and extreme drought at the Teakettle Experimental Forest, a historically frequent fire mixed-conifer forest in the southern Sierra Nevada of California, USA. Mechanical thinning (no thin, understory thin, and overstory thin) and prescribed burning (unburned, fall burning) were implemented in 2000–2001. Using annual growth data from increment cores, over 10,000 mapped and measured trees, and lidar-derived metrics of solar radiation and topographic wetness, we had two primary questions. First, what were the growth responses to thinning and prescribed burning treatments, and did these responses persist during the 2012–2016 drought? Second, what tree-level attributes and environmental conditions influenced growth responses to treatments and drought?Thinning increased residual tree growth and that response persisted through extreme drought 10–15 years after treatments. Growth responses were higher in overstory versus understory thinning, with differences between thinning types more pronounced during drought. Species-specific growth responses were strongest with overstory thinning, with sugar pine (Pinus lambertiana) and incense-cedar (Calocedrus decurrens) having higher growth responses compared to white fir (Abies concolor) and Jeffery pine (Pinus jeffreyi). For individual trees, factors associated with higher growth responses were declining pretreatment growth trend, smaller tree size, and post-treatment low neighborhood basal area. Growth responses were initially not influenced by topography, but topographic wetness became important during extreme drought. Mechanical thinning resulted in durable increases in residual tree growth rates during extreme drought over a decade after thinning occurred, indicating treatment longevity in mitigating drought stress. In contrast, tree growth did not improve after prescribed burning, likely due to fire effects that reduced surface fuels, but had little effect on reducing tree density. Thinning treatments promoted durable growth responses, but focusing on stand-level metrics may ignore important tree-level attributes such as localized competition and topography associated with higher water availability. Mechanical thinning was effective at improving growth in trees that had been experiencing declining growth trends, but was less effective in improving growth responses in large old trees of higher ecological importance.

Persistent composition legacy and rapid structural change following successive fires in Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forests

Mixed conifer forests in the Sierra Nevada, California, USA, face threats from frequent high-severity reburns caused by fuel accumulation and increasingly dry, hot conditions associated with climate change. Stand replacing fire and establishment of expansive shrub patches may result in positive feedbacks causing landscapes to convert to persistent shrubland or grassland. Our objective was to examine changes in mixed conifer forest density and species composition after successive fires across a range of initial and reburn severities. We resampled 134 field plots 5–6 years after the Chips Fire reburned stands initially burned by the Storrie and Rich fires on the Lassen and Plumas National Forests. Generalized Linear Models and post-hoc margins analyses were used to examine the interaction effects of initial and reburn fire severities on changes in conifer tree and seedling densities, percent cover of shrubs, and changes in species composition evaluated using fire tolerance index. We found that successive fires with severities less than high-severity significantly reduced tree densities to values within or close to the natural range of variation for mixed conifer stands. Despite these changes in density, species composition did not shift toward increasing dominance of fire tolerant species; mature trees and seedlings of true firs and other fire intolerant species remained dominant after successive low and moderate severity fires. Seedling establishment pulses were associated with sampling years with abundant precipitation, and unburned, unchanged, and low-severity plots in the reburn sample had significant increases in seedling densities across the range of initial burn severities. Shrub cover increased significantly with only a few reburn severity interactions, but declined significantly with repeated high-severity fire. Although two low- to moderate-severity fires may reduce tree densities to within the natural range of variation, they may not shift species composition towards historical patterns. Selective thinning in areas that burned at low- to moderate-severity may be necessary to restore historical species composition in Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forests.

Drivers of understory plant communities in Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forests with pyrodiversity

BackgroundFire suppression in western North America increased and homogenized overstory cover in conifer forests, which likely affected understory plant communities. We sought to characterize understory plant communities and their drivers using plot-based observations from two contemporary reference sites in the Sierra Nevada, USA. These sites had long-established natural fire programs, which have resulted in restored natural fire regimes. In this study, we investigated how pyrodiversity—the diversity of fire size, severity, season, and frequency—and other environment factors influenced species composition and cover of forest understory plant communities.ResultsUnderstory plant communities were influenced by a combination of environmental, plot-scale recent fire history, and plot-neighborhood pyrodiversity within 50 m. Canopy cover was inversely proportional to understory plant cover, Simpson’s diversity, and evenness. Species richness was strongly influenced by the interaction of plot-based fire experience and plot-neighborhood pyrodiversity within 50 m.ConclusionsPyrodiversity appears to contribute both directly and indirectly to diverse understory plant communities in Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forests. The indirect influence is mediated through variability in tree canopy cover, which is partially related to variation in fire severity, while direct influence is an interaction between local and neighborhood fire activity.

Plant community response to thinning and repeated fire in Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest understories

Fire suppression in the western United States has significantly altered forest composition and structure, resulting in a higher risk of stand-replacing fire, large-scale drought mortality, and bark beetle outbreaks. Mechanical thinning and prescribed fire are common treatments designed to reduce high-severity fire risk, but few studies have tracked long-term understory plant community response to these treatments with repeated fire application that emulates historic fire regimes. We evaluate changes in understory plant diversity and composition, as well as light availability, soil moisture, and litter depth over two decades following a factorial field experiment crossing thinning and two applications of prescribed fire at the Teakettle Experimental Forest (TEF) in the southern Sierra Nevada. We compare responses in experimental fuels treatments against those in nearby old-growth, mixed-conifer forests with restored low-severity fire regimes in Yosemite and Kings Canyon National Parks. We hypothesized that 1) understory plant richness, evenness, and beta diversity would increase with each burn event; 2) repeated fire after initial thinning would produce the highest understory plant diversity; 3) the second burn would reduce shrub cover, especially in the initially thinned treatments that demonstrated vigorous Ceanothus cordulatus growth after initial treatments; 4) the second burn would increase light availability and bare ground while reducing litter depth; and 5) treatments with initial thinning followed by multiple prescribed burns would show the greatest similarities to reference forests in diversity metrics, shrub cover, and environmental conditions. Although initially local (10 m2-scale) understory plant richness and diversity increased most following thinning combined with prescribed fire, this treatment did not generate understory conditions similar to those in nearby reference forests over the long term. Vigorous shrub growth resulted in low understory evenness and beta diversity over time, which a secondary burn treatment did not alter. Burning without thinning retained a more heterogeneous understory following initial treatment. Two years after the second burn treatment, this burning without thinning resulted in high understory richness and evenness similar to reference forest understories. Our results suggest management treatments may need to focus on creating heterogeneity in burn effects to limit shrub cover and foster more diverse understory communities.

Prescribed fire shrub consumption in a Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest

Live shrubs in forest understories pose a challenge for mitigating wildfire risk with prescribed fire. Factors driving shrub consumption in prescribed fires are variable and difficult to explain. This study investigated spatial patterns and drivers of Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest shrub consumption in prescribed fires through analysis of high-resolution imagery taken before and after prescribed fire. We applied a spatially explicit, generalized additive model to assess tree cover and coarse woody material as potential drivers of shrub consumption. Shrub cover in two experimental stands prior to burning was 38% and 59% and was 36% and 45% one-year post-burn. In both stands shrub patch density increased, while area-weighted mean patch size and largest patch index decreased. Increased local percent cover of coarse woody material was associated with increased shrub consumption. These findings provide information for prescribed fire managers to help better anticipate shrub consumption and patchiness outcomes under similar conditions.

Recent bark beetle outbreaks influence wildfire severity in mixed-conifer forests of the Sierra Nevada, California, USA.

In temperate forests, elevated frequency of drought related disturbances will likely increase the incidence of interactions between disturbances such as bark beetle epidemics and wildfires. Our understanding of the influence of recent drought and insect-induced tree mortality on wildfire severity has largely lacked information from forests adapted to frequent fire. A recent unprecedented tree mortality event in California's Sierra Nevada provides an opportunity to examine this disturbance interaction in historically frequent-fire forests. Using field data collected within areas of recent tree mortality that subsequently burned in wildfire, we examined whether and under what conditions wildfire severity relates to severity of prefire tree mortality in Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forests. We collected data on 180 plots within the 2015 Rough Fire and 2016 Cedar Fire footprints (California, USA). Our analyses identified prefire tree mortality as influential on all measures of wildfire severity (basal area killed by fire, RdNBR, and canopy torch) on the Cedar Fire, although it was less influential than fire weather (relative humidity). Prefire tree mortality was influential on two of three fire-severity measures on the Rough Fire, and was the most important predictor of basal area killed by fire; topographic position was influential on two metrics. On the Cedar Fire, the influence of prefire mortality on basal area killed by fire was greater under milder weather conditions. All measures of fire severity increased as prefire mortality increased up to prefire mortality levels of approximately 30-40%; further increases did not result in greater fire severity. The interacting disturbances shifted a pine-dominated system (Rough Fire) to a cedar-pine-fir system, while the pre-disturbance fir-cedar system (Cedar Fire) saw its dominant species unchanged. Managers of historically frequent-fire forests will benefit from utilizing this information when prioritizing fuels reduction treatments in areas of recent tree mortality, as it is the first empirical study to document a relationship between prefire mortality and subsequent wildfire severity in these systems. This study contributes to a growing body of evidence that the influence of prefire tree mortality on wildfire severity in temperate coniferous forests may depend on other conditions capable of driving extreme wildfire behavior, such as weather.

The Post-Fire Assembly Processes of Tree Communities Based on Spatial Analysis of a Sierra Nevada Mixed-Conifer Forest

Understanding the mechanisms underlying tree spatial arrangements may provide significant insights into the processes in the maintenance of species coexistence. We examined the potential role of habitat heterogeneity, dispersal limitation, negative density dependence, fire history, and unilateral intraspecific and interspecific interactions of adults on juveniles in shaping the spatial patterns of four dominant tree species (Abies concolor, Pinus lambertiana, Calocedrus decurrens, and Quercus kelloggii) after fire in the Yosemite Forest Dynamic Plot, California, USA. We used the univariate pair correlation function and implemented three point pattern processes (homogeneous Poisson process, inhomogeneous Poisson process, and homogeneous Thomas process) to evaluate the potential contributions of habitat filtering and dispersal limitation. We used a bivariate null model to evaluate unilateral intraspecific and interspecific interactions of adults on juveniles. We also used the pairwise correlation function to investigate the spatial patterns of density dependence. To understand the effect of fire, we used the univariate pair correlation function to investigate pattern changes during the six years following fire. We compared spatial pattern changes in both sprouting species (Quercus kelloggii) and seeding species (Abies concolor), and also examined the changes in patterns of large-diameter individuals of Abies concolor, Pinus lambertiana, and Calocedrus decurrens in 2013 (pre-fire), 2016 (two years post-fire), and 2019. Comparing the contributions of the homogeneous Thomas process and the inhomogeneous Poisson process at different spatial scales showed the importance of dispersal limitation and habitat heterogeneity at finer scales (0 m to 5 m) and coarser scales (5 m to 60 m), respectively, which suggests that the joint effects of dispersal limitation and habitat heterogeneity contribute to the spatial patterns of these three dominant tree species. Furthermore, the results showed that the young individuals of Abies concolor and Pinus lambertiana were more commonly found around the conspecific adults. Juvenile regeneration to the 1 cm diameter threshold was highly aggregated following the fire. Large-diameter trees of Abies concolor, Pinus lambertiana, and Calocedrus decurrens generally did not exhibit patterns different from complete spatial randomness (Calocedrus decurrens), or displayed only slight aggregation (Abies concolor and Pinus lambertiana). In addition, Abies concolor and Pinus lambertiana showed positive and negative conspecific density dependence in the immediate post-fire period, respectively.

Longer-term impacts of fuel reduction treatments on forest structure, fuels, and drought resistance in the Lake Tahoe Basin

Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forests have undergone significant changes in structure and composition and are increasingly vulnerable to altered disturbance regimes and climate-related extreme events. Fuel reduction treatments, including thinning and follow-up surface fuel treatments, can reduce this vulnerability by creating forest structural and woody fuel conditions that not only allow forest stands to mitigate wildfire, but also alleviate individual tree stress. However, direct observations that quantify these longer-term effects are lacking. This study compares observed changes in forest structure, tree species composition, and downed woody fuel loads across three distinct time periods: pre-treatment, 1 yr post-treatment, and 10 yr post-treatment. Additionally, using tree ring data, we assessed whether treatments affected individual tree resistance to a severe statewide drought (2012–2015). Thinning treatments were able to effectively reduce tree density and basal area, increase the retention of both larger-sized and shade-intolerant trees, and mitigate tree mortality. Treatments were also associated with significantly lower coarse woody fuel and snag basal area. Snag basal area and time since treatment were related to the accumulation of fine and coarse woody surface fuel loads. Tree ring information indicated that treatments improved drought resistance as well, especially in units with lower residual live basal area. This study complements previous studies on fuel reduction thinning by demonstrating that these treatments have lasting effects on forest structure, which also confers a degree of drought resistance.

How do soil microbial communities respond to fire in the intermediate term? Investigating direct and indirect effects associated with fire occurrence and burn severity

Fires transform soil microbial communities directly via heat-induced mortality and indirectly by altering plant and soil characteristics. Emerging evidence suggests the magnitude of changes to some plant and soil properties increases with burn severity, but the persistence of changes varies among plant and soil characteristics, ranging from months to years post-fire. Thus, which environmental attributes shape microbial communities at intermediate time points during ecosystem recovery, and how these characteristics vary with severity, remains poorly understood. We identified the network of properties that influence microbial communities three years after fire, along a burn severity gradient in Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest. We used phospholipid fatty acid (PLFA) analysis and bacterial 16S-rDNA amplicon sequencing to characterize the microbial community in mineral soil. Using structural equation modelling, we applied a systems approach to identifying the interconnected relationships among severity, vegetation, soil, and microbial communities. Dead tree basal area, soil pH, and extractable phosphorus increased with severity, whereas live tree basal area, forest floor mass, and the proportion of the ≥53 μm soil fraction decreased. Forest floor loss was associated with decreased soil moisture across the severity gradient, decreased live tree basal area was associated with increased shrub coverage, and increased dead tree basal area was associated with increases in total and inorganic soil nitrogen. Soil fungal abundance decreased across the severity gradient, despite a slightly positive response of fungi to lower soil moisture in high severity areas. Bacterial phylogenetic diversity was negatively related to severity and was driven by differences in nutrients and soil texture. The abundance of Bacteroidetes increased and the abundance of Acidobacteria decreased across the severity gradient due to differences in soil pH. Overall, we found that the effects of burn severity on vegetation and soil physicochemical characteristics interact to shape microbial communities at an intermediate time point in ecosystem recovery.

Topographic variation in tree group and gap structure in Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forests with active fire regimes

In Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forests, heterogeneity in overstory tree spatial patterns is an important ecological characteristic associated with resilience to frequent fires. Regional managers often emphasize this heterogeneity as a key component of forest treatments. There is a lack of information about how the dimensions of fire-resilient tree spatial patterns might vary with topography, which is an important influence on forest structure. We mapped, analyzed, and compared overstory tree spatial patterns across three topographic slope positions (ridges, mid-slopes, and valleys) in unlogged stands with multiple recent lower/mixed-severity burns. Using analysis of Individual trees, Clumps of trees, and Openings (ICO), we found significant differences in a number of spatial pattern metrics, including stand-level tree density and maximum clump size (highest in valleys), forest opening size (largest on ridges), and species composition (percent shade-intolerant stems highest on ridges). We found notably non-significant differences in within-clump tree densities at all spatial scales. Additionally, stand-level averages for forest structure across topography did not consistently capture spatial patterns for individual trees or smaller clump sizes, but often matched trends for clumps and openings in the largest size classes. As “megafires” become more common, prescribed fire and thinning treatments will be used more often to increase forest resilience. By quantifying variable tree spatial patterns across topographic positions in frequent-fire forests, we provide general guidelines for marking prescriptions that may increase resilience of treated forests to increasing fire intensity.

Land ownership impacts post-wildfire forest regeneration in Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forests

Understanding forest regeneration in the wake of large-scale wildfire events is critically important because these disturbances are expected to occur more frequently given future climate projections. While the impacts of individual management prescriptions on prevention, mitigation, and response to severe fire events have been studied, the influence of property ownership on their implementation and success has received less attention. The objective of this study was to compare how the management practices of two common US forestland owners- public (U.S. Forest Service) and a private forest resource company- influenced forest regeneration following a 26,000 ha wildfire in the northern Sierra Nevada. Spectral unmixing was used to track revegetation for 11 years following a 2007 wildfire. Classified vegetation maps were field validated and generated using remotely sensed imagery for the 2007 (pre-fire) and 2018 timepoints to track landcover transitions. Public ownership within the fire perimeter was the majority at 18,760 ha, while private ownership accounted for 7617 ha. Significant differences in forest regeneration were found with vegetation establishment on publicly owned lands occurring at twice the rate of their privately owned counterpart. However, by 2018 over half (10,062 ha) of publicly owned lands converted from forest (pre-fire) to a shrub-dominated land-cover type while only 2.2% (122 ha) of privately owned lands did so. Additionally, only 1% (249 ha) of publicly owned lands were characterized by young regenerating conifer forests, whereas approximately 70% (3875 ha) of privately owned lands were characterized as such. These results demonstrate a strong contrast in post-fire vegetation regeneration that will likely persist for many decades into the future. The implications of this contrast significantly impact the ecosystem services these forests provide, as well as future disturbance potential.

Silvicultural implications from analyzing light induced height growth development of eight North American juvenile tree species in mixed-conifer forests

Abstract Modern silviculture is based on simulating natural disturbance regimes on the one side and reducing their impact on the other side. Disturbances modify light regimes of forests along complex spatial patterns, and species participating in the ecosystem tend to have unique adaptations to the multitude of light conditions found in forests. We studied the height growth reaction of saplings from eight native North American tree species to different light availabilities in a Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forest. Large height growth differences occurred between species. Height growth increased for most species with increasing light availability. However, black oak but also incense cedar and tanoak reached an optimal value or saturation point of light availability at intermediate light levels, above which their growth stayed the same or slightly declined on average. A variety of stand conditions, representing the range from early to late successional stages, are beneficial to maintain tree species diversity across stands. Such a gradient of conditions can be achieved by diversifying silvicultural regimes and using regeneration approaches that mimic a range of disturbance intensities. The results add to knowledge on the species’ ecology by specifying their height growth in dependence of a quantified light environment. The quantification of the light environment can directly be linked to % canopy cover and a range of regeneration methods, respectively. With this, the results may help achieve a more precise and target-oriented management of Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forests.

Fuel dynamics after reintroduced fire in an old-growth Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest

BackgroundSurface fuel loadings are some of the most important factors contributing to fire intensity and fire spread. In old-growth forests where fire has been long excluded, surface fuel loadings can be high and can include woody debris ≥100 cm in diameter. We assessed surface fuel loadings in a long-unburned old-growth mixed-conifer forest in Yosemite National Park, California, USA, and assessed fuel consumption from a management-ignited fire set to control the progression of the 2013 Rim Fire. Specifically, we characterized the distribution and heterogeneity of pre-fire fuel loadings, both along transects and contained in duff mounds around large trees. We compared surface fuel consumption to that predicted by the standard First Order Fire Effects Model (FOFEM) based on pre-fire fuel loadings and fuel moistures. We also assessed the relationship between tree basal area—calculated for two different spatial neighborhood scales—and pre-fire fuel loadings.ResultsPre-fire total surface fuel loading averaged 192 Mg ha−1 and was reduced by 79% by the fire to 41 Mg ha−1 immediately after fire. Most fuel components were reduced by 87% to 90% by the fire, with the exception of coarse woody debris (CWD), which was reduced by 60%. Litter depth in duff mounds were within 1 SD of plot means, but duff biomass for the largest trees (>150 cm diameter at breast height [DBH]) exceeded plot background levels. Overstory basal area generally had significant positive relationships with pre-fire fuel loadings of litter, duff, 1-hour, and 10-hour fuels, but the strength of the relationships differed between overstory components (live, dead, all [live and dead], species), and negative relationships were observed between live Pinus lambertiana Douglas basal area and CWD. FOFEM over-predicted rotten CWD consumption and under-predicted duff consumption.ConclusionsSurface fuel loadings were characterized by heterogeneity and the presence of large pieces. This heterogeneity likely contributed to differential fire behavior at small scales and heterogeneity in the post-fire environment. The reductions in fuel loadings at our research site were in line with ecological restoration objectives; thus, ecologically restorative burning during fire suppression is possible.