Shine-Dalgarno Region Research Articles

RNA Thermometer-coordinated Assembly of the Yersinia Injectisome

The type III secretion system (T3SS) is indispensable for successful host cell infection by many Gram-negative pathogens. The molecular syringe delivers effector proteins that suppress the host immune response. Synthesis of T3SS components in Yersinia pseudotuberculosis relies on host body temperature, which induces the RNA thermometer (RNAT)-controlled translation of lcrF coding for a virulence master regulator that activates transcription of the T3SS regulon. The assembly of the secretion machinery follows a strict coordinated succession referred to as outside-in assembly, in which the membrane ring complex and the export apparatus represent the nucleation points. Two components essential for the initial assembly are YscJ and YscT. While YscJ connects the membrane ring complex with the export apparatus in the inner membrane, YscT is required for a functional export apparatus. Previous transcriptome-wide RNA structuromics data suggested the presence of unique intercistronic RNATs upstream of yscJ and yscT. Here, we show by reporter gene fusions that both upstream regions confer translational control. Moreover, we demonstrate the temperature-induced opening of the Shine-Dalgarno region, which facilitates ribosome binding, by in vitro structure probing and toeprinting methods. Rationally designed thermostable RNAT variants of the yscJ and yscT thermometers confirmed their physiological relevance with respect to T3SS assembly and host infection. Since we have shown in a recent study that YopN, the gatekeeper of type III secretion, also is under RNAT control, it appears that the synthesis, assembly and functionality of the Yersinia T3S machinery is coordinated by RNA-based temperature sensors at multiple levels.

Low Prevalence of mcr-1 Among Clinical Enterobacteriaceae Isolates and Co-transfer of mcr-1 and blaNDM-1 from Separate Donors.

Aims: mcr-1 and blaNDM-1 co-harboring isolates have been reported, usually reside on different plasmids, suggesting co-transfer possibility of the two genes from separate donors to the same recipient strain. This study aims at screening and characterization of mcr-1 carrying Enterobacteriaceae in Northern China, and studying the transfer ability of mcr-1 alone and in company with blaNDM-1 from a second donor. Results: Three Escherichia coli strains and one Klebsiella pneumoniae strain carrying mcr-1 gene were screened out from 1992 isolates in our study. Co-existence of multiple resistance genes was found in the mcr-1-carrying strains, but none of them carried blaNDM-1. One E. coli demonstrated an single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) (A-G) at -10 region of mcr-1, and one E. coli showed 2 SNPs (G-T and G-A) in the Shine-Dalgarno sequence-like region of mcr-1. The mcr-1 gene was located on plasmids of about 33-276 kb, and capable of transferring alone in three out of four mcr-1-positive isolates by conjugation. Co-transfer ability analysis demonstrated that mcr-1 from E. coli 13-68, which could not be transferred alone to E. coli C600, was successfully transferred in company with blaNDM-1 from K. pneumoniae ATCC BAA-2146. Conclusions: mcr-1 showed low incidence in our Enterobacteriaceae isolates. Co-transfer ability of mcr-1 and blaNDM-1 from separate donors provides direct evidence for the emergence of the mcr-1 and blaNDM-1 co-harboring isolates.

The σB-dependent regulatory sRNA Rli47 represses isoleucine biosynthesis in Listeria monocytogenes through a direct interaction with the ilvA transcript

ABSTRACT The facultative intracellular pathogen Listeria monocytogenes can persist and grow in a diverse range of environmental conditions, both outside and within its mammalian host. The alternative sigma factor Sigma B (σB) plays an important role in this adaptability and is critical for the transition into the host. While some of the functions of the σB regulon in facilitating this transition are understood the role of σB-dependent small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) remain poorly characterized. In this study, we focused on elucidating the function of Rli47, a σB-dependent sRNA that is highly induced in the intestine and in macrophages. Using a combination of in silico and in vivo approaches, a binding interaction was predicted with the Shine-Dalgarno region of the ilvA mRNA, which encodes threonine deaminase, an enzyme required for branched-chain amino acid biosynthesis. Both ilvA transcript levels and threonine deaminase activity were increased in a deletion mutant lacking the rli47 gene. The Δrli47 mutant displayed a shorter growth lag in isoleucine-depleted growth media relative to the wild-type, and a similar phenotype was also observed in a mutant lacking σB. The impact of the Δrli47 on the global transcription profile of the cell was investigated using RNA-seq, and a significant role for Rli47 in modulating amino acid metabolism was uncovered. Taken together, the data point to a model where Rli47 is responsible for specifically repressing isoleucine biosynthesis as a way to restrict growth under harsh conditions, potentially contributing to the survival of L. monocytogenes in niches both outside and within the mammalian host.

Negative Control of RpoS Synthesis by the sRNA ReaL in Pseudomonas aeruginosa.

Pseudomonas aeruginosa (Pae) is an opportunistic human pathogen, able to resist host defense mechanisms and antibiotic treatment. In Pae, the master regulator of stress responses RpoS (σS) is involved in the regulation of quorum sensing and several virulence genes. Here, we report that the sRNA ReaL translationally silences rpoS mRNA, which results in a decrease of the RpoS levels. Our studies indicated that ReaL base-pairs with the Shine-Dalgarno region of rpoS mRNA. These studies are underlined by a highly similar transcription profile of a rpoS deletion mutant and a reaL over-expressing strain.

The Small Regulatory RNAs LhrC1-5 Contribute to the Response of Listeria monocytogenes to Heme Toxicity.

The LhrC family of small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) is known to be induced when the foodborne pathogen Listeria monocytogenes is exposed to infection-relevant conditions, such as human blood. Here we demonstrate that excess heme, the core component of hemoglobin in blood, leads to a strong induction of the LhrC family members LhrC1–5. The heme-dependent activation of lhrC1–5 relies on the response regulator LisR, which is known to play a role in virulence and stress tolerance. Importantly, our studies revealed that LhrC1–5 and LisR contribute to the adaptation of L. monocytogenes to excess heme. Regarding the regulatory function of the sRNAs, we demonstrate that LhrC1–5 act to down-regulate the expression of known LhrC target genes under heme-rich conditions: oppA, tcsA, and lapB, encoding surface exposed proteins with virulence functions. These genes were originally identified as targets for LhrC-mediated control under cell envelope stress conditions, suggesting a link between the response to heme toxicity and cell envelope stress in L. monocytogenes. We also investigated the role of LhrC1–5 in controlling the expression of genes involved in heme uptake and utilization: lmo2186 and lmo2185, encoding the heme-binding proteins Hbp1 and Hbp2, respectively, and lmo0484, encoding a heme oxygenase-like protein. Using in vitro binding assays, we demonstrated that the LhrC family member LhrC4 interacts with mRNAs encoded from lmo2186, lmo2185, and lmo0484. For lmo0484, we furthermore show that LhrC4 uses a CU-rich loop for basepairing to the AG-rich Shine–Dalgarno region of the mRNA. The presence of a link between the response to heme toxicity and cell envelope stress was further underlined by the observation that LhrC1–5 down-regulate the expression of lmo0484 in response to the cell wall-acting antibiotic cefuroxime. Collectively, this study suggests a role for the LisR-regulated sRNAs LhrC1–5 in a coordinated response to excess heme and cell envelope stress in L. monocytogenes.

Mutational Analysis of sRNA-mRNA Base Pairing by Electrophoretic Mobility Shift Assay.

Small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) in bacteria often act by base pairing to mRNAs. Direct interactions between an sRNA and its target mRNA can be investigated by electrophoretic mobility shift assay. In this assay, regions engaged in base pairing are analyzed by introducing mutations in one of the RNAs that prevent sRNA-mRNA complex formation, followed by the introduction of complementary mutations in its partner RNA that restore base pairing. Here, we describe the design of a mutational strategy used to analyze the base pairing between two CU-rich regions of the sRNA Rli22 and the AG-rich Shine-Dalgarno region of the mRNA oppA in Listeria monocytogenes. The protocol can be employed for mutational studies of base pairing between any sRNA and its mRNA target(s).

The 95ΔG mutation in the 5'untranslated region of the norA gene increases efflux activity in Staphylococcus epidermidis isolates.

In the Staphylococcus aureus ATCC25923 strain, the flqB mutation in the 5'untranslated region (5'UTR) of the norA gene causes increased norA mRNA expression and high efflux activity (HEA). The involvement of the norA gene 5'UTR in HEA has not been explored in S.epidermidis; therefore, we examined the function of this region in S.epidermidis clinical isolates. The selection of isolates with HEA was performed based on ethidium bromide (EtBr) MIC values and efflux efficiency (EF) using the semi-automated fluorometric method. The function of the 5'UTR was studied by quantifying the levels of norA expression (RT-qPCR) and by identifying 5'UTR mutations by sequence analysis. Only 10 isolates from a total of 165 (6.1%) had HEA (EtBr MIC=300μg/ml and EF ranged from 48.4 to 97.2%). Eight of 10 isolates with HEA had the 5'UTR 95ΔG mutation. Isolates carrying the 95ΔG mutation had higher levels of norA expression compared with those that did not. To corroborate that the 95ΔG mutation is involved in HEA, a strain adapted to EtBr was obtained invitro. This strain also presented the 95ΔG mutation and had a high level of norA expression and EF, indicating that the 95ΔG mutation is important for the HEA phenotype. The 95ΔG mutation produces a different structure in the Shine-Dalgarno region, which may promote better translation of norA mRNA. To our knowledge, this is the first report to demonstrate the participation of the 5'UTR 95ΔG mutation of the norA gene in the HEA phenotype of S.epidermidis isolates. Here, we propose that the efflux of EtBr is caused by an increment in the transcription and/or translation of the norA gene.

Two novel members of the LhrC family of small RNAs in Listeria monocytogenes with overlapping regulatory functions but distinctive expression profiles

ABSTRACTMulticopy small RNAs (sRNAs) have gained recognition as an important feature of bacterial gene regulation. In the human pathogen Listeria monocytogenes, 5 homologous sRNAs, called LhrC1-5, control gene expression by base pairing to target mRNAs though 3 conserved UCCC motifs common to all 5 LhrCs. We show here that the sRNAs Rli22 and Rli33-1 are structurally and functionally related to LhrC1-5, expanding the LhrC family to 7 members, which makes it the largest multicopy sRNA family reported so far. Rli22 and Rli33-1 both contain 2 UCCC motifs important for post-transcriptional repression of 3 LhrC target genes. One such target, oppA, encodes a virulence-associated oligo-peptide binding protein. Like LhrC1-5, Rli22 and Rli33-1 employ their UCCC motifs to recognize the Shine-Dalgarno region of oppA mRNA and prevent formation of the ribosomal complex, demonstrating that the 7 sRNAs act in a functionally redundant manner. However, differential expression profiles of the sRNAs under infection-relevant conditions suggest that they might also possess non-overlapping functions. Collectively, this makes the LhrC family a unique case for studying the purpose of sRNA multiplicity in the context of bacterial virulence.

A high-throughput screening method for identifying lycopene-overproducing E. coli strain based on an antioxidant capacity assay

A straightforward, high-throughput screening method for identifying recombinant Escherichia coli strains that yield high levels of lycopene was developed based on the antioxidative properties of lycopene. Twenty-four recombinant E. coli strains were constructed using plasmids with various orderings of lycopene biosynthesis genes, Shine-Dalgarno regions, and aligned spacing regions. The high-throughput screening was based on antioxidant capacity measurements; we assessed the 2,2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl method, reducing activity method, and hydroxyl free radical scavenging method; the hydroxyl free radical scavenging method was determined to be the most suitable for use with our lycopene-overproducing system. The accuracy of this method was comparable to that of assay by high-performance liquid chromatography. The strain E. coli IEB11, which had the strongest antioxidant capacity and the highest lycopene-accumulating capacity, was selected and investigated for its ability to produce lycopene at different temperatures, glycerol concentrations, and fermentation times. In the optimal conditions in a 5-L fermenter, lycopene content of 1288mg/L and a mean productivity of 53.7mg/L/h were obtained after 24h.

Translational Inhibition of CTX-M Extended Spectrum β-Lactamase in Clinical Strains of Escherichia coli by Synthetic Antisense Oligonucleotides Partially Restores Sensitivity to Cefotaxime.

Synthetic antisense oligomers are DNA mimics that can specifically inhibit gene expression at the translational level by ribosomal steric hindrance. They bind to their mRNA targets by Watson-Crick base pairing and are resistant to degradation by both nucleases and proteases. A 25-mer phosphorodiamidate morpholino oligomer (PMO) and a 13-mer polyamide (peptide) nucleic acid (PNA) were designed to target mRNA (positions -4 to +21, and –17 to –5, respectively) close to the translational initiation site of the extended-spectrum β-lactamase resistance genes of CTX-M group 1. These antisense oligonucleotides were found to inhibit β-lactamase activity by up to 96% in a cell-free translation-transcription coupled system using an expression vector carrying a blaCTX-M-15 gene cloned from a clinical isolate. Despite evidence for up-regulation of CTX-M gene expression, they were both found to significantly restore sensitivity to cefotaxime (CTX) in E. coli AS19, an atypical cell wall permeable mutant, in a dose dependant manner (0-40 nM). The PMO and PNA were covalently bound to the cell penetrating peptide (CPP; (KFF)3K) and both significantly (P < 0.05) increased sensitivity to CTX in a dose dependent manner (0-40 nM) in field and clinical isolates harboring CTX-M group 1 β-lactamases. Antisense oligonucleotides targeted to the translational initiation site and Shine-Dalgarno region of blaCTX-M-15 inhibited gene expression, and when conjugated to a cell penetrating delivery vehicle, partially restored antibiotic sensitivity to both field and clinical isolates.

Dual role of RsmA in the coordinated regulation of expression of virulence genes in Pectobacterium wasabiae strain SCC3193.

The CsrA/RsmA family of post-transcriptional regulators in bacteria is involved in regulating many cellular processes, including pathogenesis. Using a bioinformatics approach, we identified an RsmA binding motif, A(N)GGA, in the Shine-Dalgarno regions of 901 genes. Among these genes with the predicted RsmA binding motif, 358 were regulated by RsmA according to our previously published gene expression profiling analysis (WT vs rsmA negative mutant; Kõiv et al., 2013). A small subset of the predicted targets known to be important as virulence factors was selected for experimental validation. RNA footprint analyses demonstrated that RsmA binds specifically to the ANGGA motif in the 5'UTR sequences of celV1, pehA, pelB, pel2 and prtW. RsmA-dependent regulation of these five genes was examined in vivo using plasmid-borne translational and transcriptional fusions with a reporter gusA gene. They were all affected negatively by RsmA. However, we demonstrated that whereas the overall effect of RsmA on celV1 and prtW was determined on both the translational and transcriptional level, expression of pectinolytic enzyme genes (pehA, pel2 and pelB) was affected mainly on the level of transcription in tested conditions. In summary, these data indicate that RsmA controls virulence by integration of its regulatory activities at various levels.

Putative carotenoid genes expressed under the regulation of Shine-Dalgarno regions in Escherichia coli for efficient lycopene production.

Putative genes crtE, crtB, and crtI from Deinococcus wulumiqiensis R12, a novel species, were identified by genome mining and were co-expressed using the optimized Shine-Dalgarno (SD) regions to improve lycopene yield. A lycopene biosynthesis pathway was constructed by co-expressing these three genes in Escherichia coli. After optimizing the upstream SD regions and the culture medium, the recombinant strain EDW11 produced 88mg lycopene g(-1) dry cell wt (780mg lycopene l(-1)) after 40h fermentation without IPTG induction, while the strain EDW without optimized SD regions only produced 49mg lycopene g(-1) dry cell wt (417mg lycopene l(-1)). Based on the optimization of the upstream SD regions and culture medium, the yield of the strain EDW11 reached a high level during microbial lycopene production until now.

Disrupting protein expression with Peptide Nucleic Acids reduces infection by obligate intracellular Rickettsia.

Peptide Nucleic Acids (PNAs) are single-stranded synthetic nucleic acids with a pseudopeptide backbone in lieu of the phosphodiester linked sugar and phosphate found in traditional oligos. PNA designed complementary to the bacterial Shine-Dalgarno or start codon regions of mRNA disrupts translation resulting in the transient reduction in protein expression. This study examines the use of PNA technology to interrupt protein expression in obligate intracellular Rickettsia sp. Their historically intractable genetic system limits characterization of protein function. We designed PNA targeting mRNA for rOmpB from Rickettsia typhi and rickA from Rickettsia montanensis, ubiquitous factors important for infection. Using an in vitro translation system and competitive binding assays, we determined that our PNAs bind target regions. Electroporation of R. typhi and R. montanensis with PNA specific to rOmpB and rickA, respectively, reduced the bacteria’s ability to infect host cells. These studies open the possibility of using PNA to suppress protein synthesis in obligate intracellular bacteria.

The conserved GTPase LepA contributes mainly to translation initiation in Escherichia coli.

LepA is a paralog of EF-G found in all bacteria. Deletion of lepA confers no obvious growth defect in Escherichia coli, and the physiological role of LepA remains unknown. Here, we identify nine strains (ΔdksA, ΔmolR1, ΔrsgA, ΔtatB, ΔtonB, ΔtolR, ΔubiF, ΔubiG or ΔubiH) in which ΔlepA confers a synthetic growth phenotype. These strains are compromised for gene regulation, ribosome assembly, transport and/or respiration, indicating that LepA contributes to these functions in some way. We also use ribosome profiling to deduce the effects of LepA on translation. We find that loss of LepA alters the average ribosome density (ARD) for hundreds of mRNA coding regions in the cell, substantially reducing ARD in many cases. By contrast, only subtle and codon-specific changes in ribosome distribution along mRNA are seen. These data suggest that LepA contributes mainly to the initiation phase of translation. Consistent with this interpretation, the effect of LepA on ARD is related to the sequence of the Shine–Dalgarno region. Global perturbation of gene expression in the ΔlepA mutant likely explains most of its phenotypes.

Structural determinants for ligand capture by a class II preQ 1 riboswitch

Prequeuosine (preQ1) riboswitches are RNA regulatory elements located in the 5' UTR of genes involved in the biosynthesis and transport of preQ1, a precursor of the modified base queuosine universally found in four tRNAs. The preQ1 class II (preQ1-II) riboswitch regulates preQ1 biosynthesis at the translational level. We present the solution NMR structure and conformational dynamics of the 59 nucleotide Streptococcus pneumoniae preQ1-II riboswitch bound to preQ1. Unlike in the preQ1 class I (preQ1-I) riboswitch, divalent cations are required for high-affinity binding. The solution structure is an unusual H-type pseudoknot featuring a P4 hairpin embedded in loop 3, which forms a three-way junction with the other two stems. (13)C relaxation and residual dipolar coupling experiments revealed interhelical flexibility of P4. We found that the P4 helix and flanking adenine residues play crucial and unexpected roles in controlling pseudoknot formation and, in turn, sequestering the Shine-Dalgarno sequence. Aided by divalent cations, P4 is poised to act as a "screw cap" on preQ1 recognition to block ligand exit and stabilize the binding pocket. Comparison of preQ1-I and preQ1-II riboswitch structures reveals that whereas both form H-type pseudoknots and recognize preQ1 using one A, C, or U nucleotide from each of three loops, these nucleotides interact with preQ1 differently, with preQ1 inserting into different grooves. Our studies show that the preQ1-II riboswitch uses an unusual mechanism to harness exquisite control over queuosine metabolism.

Base Pairing Interaction between 5′- and 3′-UTRs Controls icaR mRNA Translation in Staphylococcus aureus

The presence of regulatory sequences in the 3′ untranslated region (3′-UTR) of eukaryotic mRNAs controlling RNA stability and translation efficiency is widely recognized. In contrast, the relevance of 3′-UTRs in bacterial mRNA functionality has been disregarded. Here, we report evidences showing that around one-third of the mapped mRNAs of the major human pathogen Staphylococcus aureus carry 3′-UTRs longer than 100-nt and thus, potential regulatory functions. We selected the long 3′-UTR of icaR, which codes for the repressor of the main exopolysaccharidic compound of the S. aureus biofilm matrix, to evaluate the role that 3′-UTRs may play in controlling mRNA expression. We showed that base pairing between the 3′-UTR and the Shine-Dalgarno (SD) region of icaR mRNA interferes with the translation initiation complex and generates a double-stranded substrate for RNase III. Deletion or substitution of the motif (UCCCCUG) within icaR 3′-UTR was sufficient to abolish this interaction and resulted in the accumulation of IcaR repressor and inhibition of biofilm development. Our findings provide a singular example of a new potential post-transcriptional regulatory mechanism to modulate bacterial gene expression through the interaction of a 3′-UTR with the 5′-UTR of the same mRNA.

An RpoS-dependent sRNA regulates the expression of a chaperone involved in protein folding

Small noncoding RNAs (sRNAs) are usually expressed in the cell to face a variety of stresses. In this report we disclose the first target for SraL (also known as RyjA), a sRNA present in many bacteria, which is highly induced in stationary phase. We also demonstrate that this sRNA is directly transcribed by the major stress σ factor σ(S) (RpoS) in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium. We show that SraL sRNA down-regulates the expression of the chaperone Trigger Factor (TF), encoded by the tig gene. TF is one of the three major chaperones that cooperate in the folding of the newly synthesized cytosolic proteins and is the only ribosome-associated chaperone known in bacteria. By use of bioinformatic tools and mutagenesis experiments, SraL was shown to directly interact with the 5' UTR of the tig mRNA a few nucleotides upstream of the Shine-Dalgarno region. Namely, point mutations in the sRNA (SraL*) abolished the repression of tig mRNA and could only down-regulate a tig transcript target with the respective compensatory mutations. We have also validated in vitro that SraL forms a stable duplex with the tig mRNA. This work constitutes the first report of a small RNA affecting protein folding. Taking into account that both SraL and TF are very well conserved in enterobacteria, this work will have important repercussions in the field.

Importance and Determinants of Induction of Cold-Induced DEAD RNA Helicase in the Hyperthermophilic Archaeon Thermococcus kodakarensis

Thermococcus kodakarensis, which grows optimally at 85°C, expresses cold stress-inducible DEAD box RNA helicase (Tk-deaD) when shifted to 60°C. A DDA1 deletion (ΔTk-deaD) mutant exhibited decreased cell growth, and cells underwent lysis at 60°C in nutrient broth in the absence of elemental sulfur. In contrast, cells in medium containing elemental sulfur at 60°C did not undergo lysis, suggesting that Tk-deaD is necessary for cell growth in sulfur-free medium. To identify the element responsible for the cold response, a pTKR expression probe plasmid was constructed using thermostable catalase from Pyrobaculum calidifontis as a reporter. The plasmid pTKRD, which contained the transcription factor B recognition element, TATA region, and Shine-Dalgarno (SD) region, including the initiation codon of the Tk-deaD gene, exhibited cold inducibility. We also constructed a series of deletion and chimeric constructs with the glutamate dehydrogenase (gdh) promoter, whose expression is constitutive independent of culture temperatures and catalase expression. Reporter assay experiments indicated that the regulatory element is located in the region between the SD region and the initiation codon (ATG). Nucleotide sequences in the upstream regions of Tk-deaD and gdh were compared and revealed a five-adenosine (AAAAA) sequence between SD and ATG of Tk-deaD that was not present in gdh. Replacement of the repeated adenosine sequence with other sequences revealed that the AAAAA sequence is important for cold induction. This sequence-specific mechanism is unique and is one that has not been identified in other known cold-inducible genes.

A novel coding method for gene mutation correction during protein translation process

In gene expression, gene mutations often lead to negative effect of protein translation in prokaryotic organisms. With consideration of the influences produced by gene mutation, a novel method based on error-correction coding theory is proposed for modeling and detection of translation initiation in this paper. In the proposed method, combined with a one-dimensional codebook from block coding, a decoding method based on the minimum hamming distance is designed for analysis of translation efficiency. The results show that the proposed method can recognize the biologically significant regions such as Shine–Dalgarno region within the mRNA leader sequences effectively. Also, a global analysis of single base and multiple bases mutations of the Shine–Dalgarno sequences are established. Compared with other published experimental methods for mutation analysis, the translation initiation can not be disturbed by multiple bases mutations using the proposed method, which shows the effectiveness of this method in improving the translation efficiency and its biological relevance for genetic regulatory system.

Introduction to the Thematic Minireview Series on Protein Synthesis

For many, the genetic code was to provide the key to understanding protein synthesis. For those with a bit more sophistication, it was the Shine-Dalgarno region (in prokaryotes) or scanning and the Kozak consensus sequence (in eukaryotes). In all of these, the answer was in the nucleic acid sequence of the mRNA and was based on the assumption of a single mechanism to explain translation initiation. However, like all of the macromolecular synthetic pathways, there have been two repetitive observations.