The Choosing Wisely campaign suggests an individualized approach to cancer screening among patients receiving dialysis. We aimed to evaluate breast and prostate cancer screening among patients receiving maintenance hemodialysis (HD) by kidney transplant waitlist status and five-year survival probability. We conducted a retrospective cohort study using a nationally representative population of HD patients. Patients receiving HD each calendar year from 2003-2018, ≥1 year of Medicare as the Primary Payer, and age 50-69 years were included. The cohort was split into prognosis and cancer screening sets. Models of five-year survival were built in the prognosis set using logistic regression. Five-year survival probabilities were generated in the cancer screening set, excluding patients with prior breast or prostate cancer, and screening over the next year was assessed. 160,537 patients contributed 356,165 person-years to the cancer screening set (59% of the person-years were contributed by males, median age was 60 years). Compared to a benchmark rate of 50% (e.g., mammography every other year), 42% of waitlisted female-years were screened by mammography. Overall, 17% of non-waitlisted female-years were screened (20% among those with >50% probability of five-year survival and 8% among those with <10% probability of five-year survival). Compared to a benchmark rate of 20% [e.g., serum prostate-specific antigen (PSA) screening up to five years apart], 24% of waitlisted male-years were screened with serum PSA. Overall 15% of non-waitlisted male-years were screened (13% among those with >50% probability of five-year survival and 1% among those with <10% probability of five-year survival). Patterns were similar after age-standardization. Patients with higher predicted survival have higher rates of cancer screening, suggesting providers consider life expectancy. However, non-waitlisted patients with high probability of five-year survival were less likely to be screened compared to waitlisted patients. Interventions may be needed to close this screening gap.