Conventional plastic mulch brings agronomic and economic benefits to crop production, but a large amount of plastic waste amasses when the mulch is removed from the fields after harvest. Soil-biodegradable plastic mulch (BDM) has emerged as a promising alternative to conventional plastic mulch as it can be tilled into the soil after harvest, thereby alleviating disposal problems. However, direct evidence on complete degradation of biodegradable mulch under natural conditions is still lacking. We quantified the dynamics of macro- (>5 mm) and microplastics (0.1–5 mm in size) in four years after a one-time application of mulch in a field with monoculture maize. The BDM feedstock was polybutyleneadipate-co-terephthalate (PBAT) and polylactic acid (PLA)-based, and both a clear and black BDM were tested. The BDM plastic mulch films degraded into macro- and micoplastics. Macroplastics disappeared 2.5 years after mulch incorporation. We developed a new extraction method for biodegradable microplastics using a sequential density fractionation approach with a H2O and a ZnCl2 solution. Microplastic concentrations in the soil ranged from 350 to 525 particles/kg after 2.5 years, 175 to 250 particles/kg after 3 years, and 50 to 125 particles/kg after 3.5 year following mulch incorporation. This continuous decrease of detectable plastic particle concentrations in soil suggests that BDMs fragment degrade into smaller and smaller particles, which eventually may biodegrade completely. While we cannot ascertain whether persistent and undetectable nanoplastics may form, macro- and microplastics formed from BDM seem to disappear with time.