Sensory Characteristics Research Articles

Perception and Attitude of Consumer Patronage of Ghana-Grown Rice: Evidence from Kumasi, Ghana

Increasing human population, urbanization, and changing consumer trends have contributed to the emergence of rice as the leading staple food in Ghana. Despite its importance in the Ghanaian diet, patronage and consumption of locally grown rice are not yet widespread. This study investigates consumer patronage of locally grown rice in the Kumasi Metropolis, Ghana, and fills a critical gap in understanding the specific factors that influence consumer preferences in urban settings. Data were collected through a cross-sectional survey of 120 respondents across different income categories using a multistage sampling technique and analyzed using descriptive statistics, a Probit model, and Kendall's coefficient of concordance. The study found that cooking quality, palatability, colour, and fragrance were the primary attributes that influenced consumer preferences. Probit analysis revealed that income and the frequency of rice consumption significantly influenced the likelihood of purchasing locally grown rice. Specifically, a higher income decreases, while frequent rice consumption increases the likelihood of choosing local rice. Key constraints identified include perceived high cost, limited availability, and concerns about the quality of rice. This study recommends that local rice producers, agricultural organizations, and government bodies should make efforts to improve the sensory and culinary qualities of locally grown rice through improved processing techniques, increased promotion, and campaigns to ensure the commodity is readily available to consumers. These strategies aim to boost local rice consumption and support agricultural sustainability and food security in Ghana.

Explaining wine scores through stochastic frontier analysis. An intent to measure sensory non-observable attributes

ABSTRACT Experts give scores to wines, which are quality proxies for marketers and buyers. The production of scores proxying wine quality is explained by a set of observable objective attributes, plus another set of unobservable and subjective (sensory) features, and randomness. Is it possible to use a Stochastic Frontier Approach (SFA) to understand whether objective and subjective (sensory) characteristics of wines explain the differences in ‘producing’ wine scores? We estimate a wine quality stochastic frontier production function, using a database of 1800 top-scored wines, in 18 years-window encompassing objective determinants that largely explain the scores (price, production, year, grape, country, etcetera), being aware that sensory aspects related to wine grading are unobservable. We find that the observable variables explain part of the ‘efficiency’ in attaining scores and suggest that ‘inefficiency’ in score generation can be attributed to unobservable (sensory) variables.

Supplementation of Chlorella vulgaris Extracts During Brewing: The Effects on Fermentation Properties, Phytochemical Activity and the Abundance of Volatile Organic Compounds

Chlorella vulgaris, a microalga rich in secondary metabolites and nutrients, offers a promising alternative for promoting microbial growth in food fermentation processes. This study aimed to evaluate the effects of C. vulgaris extracts on fermentation kinetics, sensory characteristics, phytochemical composition, antioxidant activity, and the abundance of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in treated versus control beers. The bioactive compounds from C. vulgaris were extracted using an ultrasound-assisted method with water as the solvent. A German Pilsner-style lager beer (GPB) was brewed and supplemented with 0.5, 1, and 5 g/L of C. vulgaris extracts prior to primary fermentation. Yeast viability, °Brix, and pH levels were monitored to assess fermentation progress. Phytochemical composition was analyzed by quantifying total polyphenols and flavonoids. The antioxidant activity of the beer was evaluated using both the 2,2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl (DPPH●) and hydrogen peroxide assays. The addition of C. vulgaris extracts resulted in increased yeast viability and slight variations in gravity during the 7-day fermentation period. Moreover, the beers supplemented with C. vulgaris extracts demonstrated higher levels of total polyphenols, flavonoids, and antioxidant activity compared to the GPB. Specific volatile organic compounds, including 2-methyl-1-propanol, 1-hexanol, isopentyl hexanoate, 2-methylpropyl octanoate, β-myrcene, and geranyl acetate, were significantly more abundant (p < 0.05) in the treated beers than in the control. Sensory evaluations revealed a favorable impact of the treatment on aroma scores compared to the GPB. Overall, the findings indicate that C. vulgaris extracts could be a valuable ingredient for developing functional beers with enhanced health benefits, particularly regarding antioxidant activity. Additionally, the results underscore the importance of exploring innovative approaches that utilize natural sources like Chlorella to enrich the nutritional profile and sensory qualities of fermented products.

Effect of fruit pulp and sugar concentration on the physicochemical, phytochemical and sensory characteristics of star fruit (Averrhoa carambola) leather

Starfruit is an underutilized fruit and is rich in vitamin C. Fruit leather from starfruit was prepared in this study and analyses of its physicochemical, phytochemical, and sensory characteristics were performed. Five samples named A, B, C, D and E were prepared with different proportions of fruit pulp:sugar of 70:30, 75:25, 80:20, 85:15 and 90:10, respectively. All the prepared samples were subjected to analyses. Phytochemical contents were found to increase with increasing fruit pulp proportion, thus sample E (90:10) was found to be the best in terms of phytochemical content. Similarly, product sample C (80:20) was scored the highest by the panelist in terms of sensory aspect. The best product sample C had total soluble solids (TSS) of 31 ± 2 °Bx, total ash content of 2.482 ± 0.001 %, acid insoluble ash of 1.0013 ± 0.002 %, crude protein of 0.5902 ± 0.004 %, crude fat of 0.3514 ± 0.003 %, crude fiber of 0.8991 ± 0.003 %, carbohydrate of 95.67 ± 0.04 %, vitamin C of 24.24 ± 0.1 mg/100g, total energy of 338.11 ± 0.04 Kcal/100 g, total phenolic content (TPC) of 6.105 ± 0.001 mg GAE/g of dry extract, total flavonoid content (TFC) of 1.125 ± 0.002 mg QE/g of dry extract and DPPH scavenging activity of 27.268 ± 0.001 %. Panelists responded favorably to the prepared product samples.

Non-Conventional Brewers’ Spent Grains, an Alternative Raw Material in Bread-Making

The main objective of this experiment was to investigate the technological potential of upcycling unsparged non-conventional brewers’ spent grains (BSGs) in bread-making and assess the comparative quality of bread enriched with non-fermented and lactic acid-fermented BSGs obtained from mashes brewed with starch adjuncts of buckwheat and oats. After the runoff of the first wort, unsparged non-conventional BSGs with approximately 75% moisture, acidic pH, and yield in the soluble extract above 56.6% (w/w d.m.) were used in substituting wheat flour with 5 and 15% (w/w d.m.) in bread-making recipes. The highest loaf volume value (318.68 cm3/100 g) was observed for 5% fermented buckwheat-BSG addition. Except for the samples with 5% fermented BSGs, specific volumes decreased. Crumb moisture was reduced by up to 22% for all samples, with this parameter related to bread weight. Bread porosity, elasticity, acidity, and overall sensory acceptability were better for fermented than non-fermented BSGs. The results proved that non-conventional BSGs with buckwheat and oats addition have the potential to be valorized in new bread assortments, and lactic acid fermentation applied to the BSGs is beneficial, even for overall sensory acceptability and quality of baked end-products. Technological, buckwheat-BSG was more convenient than oats-BSG. Further research continues to optimize and upscale Technology Readiness Levels.

Wine Phenolic Compounds: Chemistry, Functionality and Health Benefits

Wine phenolic compounds, often known as polyphenols, are a diverse group of secondary bioactive compounds derived from grapes. They play a crucial role in defining the sensory characteristics, functionality, and health benefits of wine. This review explores the complex chemistry of these compounds, focusing on key classes such as flavonoids, which include flavanones, flavonols, anthocyanins, and flavan-3-ols, and non-flavonoids, such as hydroxycinnamic acids, hydroxybenzoic acids, and stilbenes. The health benefits of wine phenolics, particularly their antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties, are also discussed in relation to preventing and reducing the risk of non-communicable diseases (NCDs) such as cardiovascular diseases, cancers, and neurodegenerative conditions. Furthermore, this review summarized the most current data from human population-based research that investigated the bioactivity of these red wine phytochemicals with relevant health benefits for NCDs. Finally, this review proposes some perspectives for future research to better understand the bioavailability, metabolism, and long-term health effects of these compounds.

Nutritional, physicochemical, and sensorial characterisation of quinoa-millet enriched gluten-free functional cookies

AbstractThe demand for gluten-free food products is expected to grow in the coming years. Quinoa's versatility allows it to replace traditional grains and adds high nutritional value to grain blends and processed food items. The present study was designed to prepare and evaluate gluten-free cookies by substituting rice with quinoa and keeping pearl and foxtail millet constant. A significant increase in protein (8.0–13.2 g/100 g), crude fibre (2.9–6.2%), ash (0.5–1.7%), and hardness (928.9–1736.9 g) was observed with increasing quinoa supplementation. A positive correlation of crude fibre with protein, hardness, and fracturability was observed at P ≤ 5%. Organoleptic evaluation indicated that cookies with 30% quinoa were overall accepted by the consumer. Also, these cookies had lower acid and peroxide values, thus, had longer shelf-lives. This is the first report for the use of quinoa with the mixture of rice and millet, which could be a decent alternative ingredient for gluten-free cookies formulations.

Exploring the Presence of Cannabinoids in Hemp-Infused Fermented Milk Drinks: An Analysis of Pre- and Post-Fermentation Levels

Yoghurts are the most popular fermented dairy products. Consumer attention is directed towards products containing inputs that enrich the product with bioactive substances. The growing interest in the Cannabis sativa L. plant has resulted in the development of a market for hemp products. The main aim of this research work was to determine the effect of the lactic fermentation process on the stability of cannabinoids in fermented milk beverages containing hemp inputs (hemp oil, dried hemp, ethanolic hemp extract) at 0.5, 1 and 2% (w/v). The effect of the type of hemp input on the technological process (i.e., pH value, viability of LAB during 28 days of storage) was also checked and the sensory quality of the prepared samples was evaluated. It was shown that the choice of type/form and amount of hemp addition influenced the final cannabinoid content of the product after fermentation and post-fermentation, but no effect on the survival of yoghurt bacteria or pH changes during storage was confirmed. Fermented milk drinks containing hemp oil had the highest cannabinoid content. The QDA results of the sensory evaluation of the yoghurts show that the most acceptable product in terms of overall quality is the yoghurt containing 0.5% hemp extract and 2% hemp oil.

Evaluation of moisture migration and microstructure of quick-frozen wet rice flour after freeze-thaw cycles and changes in texture, cooking, and sensory properties.

This study investigated the quality changes of quick-frozen wet rice flour before and after freeze-thaw cycles. As the freeze-thaw cycle was prolonged, the water mobility of quick-frozen wet rice flour decreased and the pore size and porosity of the microstructure increased. As a result, the hardness, cooking loss, water absorption, and water precipitation of the rice flour increased, while the sensory score and viscosity decreased. Correlation analysis showed that porosity was positively correlated with the hardness and water absorption of rice flour, and negatively correlated with structural properties such as shearing work and resilience. Water absorption and water precipitation rate were positively related to cooking loss. Thus, moisture migration in rice flour induced microstructural changes to cause alterations in texture, cooking, and sensory properties. Interestingly, quick-frozen wet rice flour still possessed good texture, cooking, and sensory qualities after two freeze-thaw cycles. This study laid the foundation for the development of high-quality quick-frozen wet rice flour.

Improvement of Storage Quality of Broccoli Using a Cold-Shock Precooling Way and the Related Molecular Mechanisms

This research was performed to ascertain the impact of cold shock precooling and the underlying mechanism on broccoli storage quality. After being harvested and placed at 0 ± 2 °C, the broccoli was sealed in polyethylene bags and stored at 4 ± 2 °C. Cold-shock precooling showed superior qualities in terms of higher hardness, titratable acidity, moisture content, soluble protein, and chlorophyll, as well as more abundant volatile compounds, better sensory quality, antioxidant capacity, and decreased weight loss in comparison to without cold shock. The regulation of important metabolic enzymes such as peroxidase, catalase, pheophytinase, and magnesium-dechelatase was credited with these beneficial effects. It was found that a 90 min duration of cold shock was the ideal treatment. Results showed that cold shock precooling was a useful, economical, and environmentally responsible way to reduce postharvest loss and postpone broccoli senescence during storage.

Oven-Dried Cupuaçu and Bacuri Fruit Pulps as Amazonian Food Resources

The Amazon is one of the largest and most diverse biomes on the planet. Cupuaçu (Theobroma grandiflorum (Willd. ex Spreng.) Schum) and bacuri (Platonia insignis Mart.) are Amazonian fruit species appreciated for their sensory characteristics and promising availability of bioactive compounds. However, high moisture levels (>80%) make these pulps susceptible to deterioration during storage. In this study, the oven-drying process was monitored to produce dry and more stable pulps. The process was monitored at 40 °C, 55 °C and 70 °C, and the bioactive compounds and antioxidant capacity were determined as quality indicators. In general, drying at 70 °C for 340 min produced dried cupuaçu and bacuri pulps with high levels of total phenolic compounds: 288 and 652 mg gallic acid equivalents/100 g, respectively. The hygroscopic evaluation suggested that both of the dried pulps should be stored at a relative humidity of <40% to avoid rapid water adsorption and it is advised to carry out the oven-drying process until up to 12% moisture is reached for cupuaçu and 9% for bacuri to avoid unnecessary energy consumption. Thus, this study expands the potential of bacuri and cupuaçu pulps for application in food industries, contributing to the economic and social development of the Amazon region.

Effect of Different Chemical Pretreatments and Packaging Systems on Quality Characteristics of Fresh-Cut Pomegranate Arils (Punica granatum, L.)

Aims: Pomegranate (Punica granatum) is considered as challenging to consume due to its hard structure, hence used for fresh-cut production. Extending the shelf life of fresh-cut pomegranate arils would improve their marketability, transport efficiency, and reduce post-harvest losses. Study Design: Completely Randomized Design by using GRAPES (General R based Analysis Platform Empowered by Statistics). Place and Duration of Study: College of Agriculture, Kerala Agricultural University, February 2022-July 2024. Methodology: Pomegranate arils were extracted and treated with different pre-treatment solutions viz., 0.5% ascorbic acid, 0.5% citric acid, 1% calcium chloride and 1% calcium ascorbate for 4 minutes. The best pre-treatment solution was selected and arils were packaged in different packaging systems viz., shrink wrapping in 15µ polyolefin film, vacuum packaging in laminated pouches, MAP with N2 flushing in laminated pouches, aluminium tray wrapped with cling film and stored under two different storage conditions, after treating with 1% calcium ascorbate. Results: 1% calcium ascorbate was selected as the best pre-treatment solution and pre-treated arils kept in MAP with N2 flushing in laminated pouches stored under low temperature condition was found to be the best packaging and storage system. 1% calcium ascorbate treated arils in MAP with N2 flushing in laminated pouches stored under low temperature condition (10±5oC) had a shelf life of 6 days with superior physiological (PLW, percent leakage), chemical (acidity, vitamin C, phenol) and sensory characters (color, flavour, texture, appearance, taste and overall acceptability) as compared to control (2.00 days). Maximum vitamin C content of 23.02 mg 100g-1 and least phenol content of 214.16 mg 100g-1 were recorded on 6th day of storage. Conclusion: Pomegranate arils pre-treated with 1% calcium ascorbate for 4 minutes, kept in MAP with N2 flushing in laminated pouches stored under low temperature condition (10±5oC) can be considered as a protocol for shelf life extension of pomegranate arils.

Addition of commercial lactic acid bacteria as starter cultures in anaerobic fermentations of Coffea arabica L., in cherry or raisin stages

The objective of this research was to verify the efficiency of adding commercial lactic acid bacteria (LAB) on anaerobic fermentation of (cherry and raisin) arabica Yellow Catuaí coffees, studying the microbiological succession and its influence in modulating sensorial characteristics on their beverages. The study took place in a rural property in Marília region, Sao Paulo State, Brasil, and was performed according to three different treatments: 1) FNC = spontaneous fermentation of cherry coffees; 2) FCBAL = cherry coffee fermentation using Sacco Lyofast SYAB1 BAL; 3) FPBAL = raisin coffee fermentation using Sacco Lyofast SYAB1 BAL. Fermentations occurred in individual (60 liters) high density polyethylene containers, properly sealed to guarantee anaerobic conditions. After a 48-hour fermentation, all the coffee fruits were washed, beans were depulped and dried on suspended terrace until a 12% humidity was observed. Physical, chemical, microbiological and sensory analysis were performed in samples collected from each fermented batch. Fermentation processes of raisin coffees occurred more slowly than fermentations using cherry coffees and resulted in a lesser consumption of soluble solids and in a slower acidification. Fermentation treatments FNC, FCBAL and FPBAL reached the necessary reduction of Enterobateriaceae and molds. The addition of BAL stimulated the growth of yeasts, which are responsible for the inclusion of the most desired flavor. The fermentations conducted in this experiment resulted in coffee beverages that reached notes of specialty coffees (> 80 points). Even though the raisin coffee achieved a lower note than cherry, the LAB inclusion raised it from 77 (non-fermented raisins) to 80 (FPBAL) points. In cherry fruits, FCBAL got 2 points on final comparation to non-fermented cherries. Thus, the inclusion of LAB presented itself beneficial to anaerobic fermentations of cherry or raisin coffees.

Assessment of Physicochemical and Sensory Characteristics of Commercial Sparkling Wines Obtained Through Ancestral and Traditional Methods

Sparkling wines produced using the ancestral method, also known as Pét-Nats, are gaining more and more market share these days. However, scientific information on these wines is very scarce. The aim of this study was therefore to compare the physicochemical composition and sensory characteristics of a representative selection of commercial sparkling wines produced using the ancestral and traditional methods. Ancestral sparkling wines were more heterogeneous than traditional sparkling wines, as some of them showed lower internal pressure, higher turbidity, higher color intensity and lower effervescence. These differences are probably due to the fact that the protocol for making sparkling wines using the ancestral method is not as well defined as that for traditional sparkling wines. However, the ancestral method has the advantage of being able to work with riper grapes and a lower sulfur dioxide dosage.

Incorporation of Chokeberry Pomace into Baked Products: Influence on the Quality of the Dough and the Muffins

The use of pomace in bakery products opens up new possibilities for the management of waste products from the fruit industry. Such activities are integral to the concept of sustainable development and the circular economy. In this research, the quality of dough and final products was analyzed by replacing 10–50% of the typical flour (wheat, rice, and corn) with chokeberry pomace flour. The instrumental color measurements and the sensory analysis showed that the dough and the muffins made with the fruit flour were significantly different from the control samples. Flour substitutions of over 10%, while enriching muffins with chokeberry flour, led to a decrease in product quality (texture, dough rise, sensory quality), especially for muffins with gluten. The sensory study showed that a substitution of 10% of typical flour resulted in products acceptable to potential consumers, but a higher substitution reduced the overall quality. It was found that the use of chokeberry pomace in making muffins was limited and more feasible for gluten-free products.

Assessment of Whole Grain Ancient Wheat Sourdough in Lyophilised and Native Forms for Cookie Formulation

This study explored the potential of two forms of sourdough—native and lyophilised—obtained through the spontaneous fermentation of whole grain flours from ancient wheat varieties, for cookie production. The research involved evaluated the dough’s rheological properties through creep and recovery measurements and Mixolab analysis, assessing proximate composition, physical attributes, texture, colour, and sensory characteristics using the Rate-all-that-apply (RATA) method. The rheological analysis revealed that native sourdough significantly impacted dough behaviour, making it more challenging to process. Although differences were observed in the proximate composition, colour, and texture, these factors did not influence the samples as much as the rheological parameters. Sensory evaluation identified Khorasan lyophilised sourdough, along with its control sample, as the most promising, while modern wheat, spelt, and emmer exhibited potentially undesirable attributes. Based on these findings, it was concluded that lyophilised Khorasan sourdough was very favourable for cookie production and should be considered for further in-depth research and development. This suggests that the lyophilised forms of ancient wheats could offer valuable alternatives for cookie formulation, with implications for both the processing and sensory attributes of the final product.

Development of antioxidant‐rich curd fortified with encapsulated beetroot (Beta vulgaris L.) peel extract powder

AbstractA curd with enhanced antioxidants was developed adding nanoencapsulated Beetroot Peel Extract Powder (BPEM) @ 1.0 % w/v of milk. Beetroot peel extract‐based powder was produced by the spray drying technique using maltodextrin and guar gum as coating agents. The prepared samples were tested for sensory characteristics, textural properties, antioxidant content, and proximate characteristics. The results show that the sensorial characteristics of the fortified curd were improved as compared to the control one. The incorporation of nanoencapsulated BPEM resulted in a softer and more delicate texture of the fortified curd (Hardness [N]: 195 ± 10.6) as compared to control (Hardness [N]: 335 ± 3.53). The physicochemical properties of antioxidant‐enhanced curd resulted in 87.4 ± 0.7% moisture, 2.2 ± 0.35% fat, 4.76 ± 0.04% protein, 14.6 ± 0.35% total solids, and 6.59 ± 0.10% carbohydrate. Furthermore, the addition of beetroot peel extract‐based powder showed a higher antioxidant (76.6 ± 0.72% DPPH inhibition) and phenolic content (85.7 ± 0.25 μg Gallic acid equivalent [GAE]/mL) in the developed curd as compared to the control (54 ± 0.66% DPPH inhibition and 59.9 ± 0.75 μg GAE/mL total phenolic content).

Utilization of artichoke (Cynara scolymus L.) by-products for enhancing nutritional value and phytochemical content of cookies

This study was conducted to make functional cookies using powdered artichoke stems and bracts, which are rich in phytochemicals. The chemical composition and phytochemicals in wheat flour, artichoke bract powder, artichoke stem powder and the produced cookies were determined. Physical properties, color and sensory characteristics were determined in wheat flour cookies, artichoke bract powder cookies and artichoke stem powder cookies. The results showed that artichoke bract powder cookies (15%) contained the highest levels of ash and protein being 2.07% and 9.65%, respectively. The cookies with powdered artichoke stems (15%) had the greatest overall lipid content (14.65%). Furthermore, the highest total phenolic content, total flavonoid content, and antioxidant activity were found in artichoke by-products (stems and bracts). The panelists approved of up to 15% artichoke by-product powder added to wheat flour. It can be seen from the results that the artichoke by-products are a good source of phytochemicals, minerals, total protein and total lipids, which improves the quality of cookies. Therefore, it can be concluded that using artichoke by-products up to 15% enhanced the antioxidant properties and nutritional value of the baked cookies.

Postharvest application of sodium nitroprusside improves the quality of ‘Umran’ ber fruit under cold storage conditions by regulating enzyme activities

ABSTRACT Ber fruit is highly perishable, with a storage life of only 3–5 days under ambient conditions, which makes it difficult to transport the fruit even to domestic markets. An experiment was conducted to study the effect of postharvest treatment with sodium nitroprusside (50, 100 and 150 µM) on the storage life, quality attributes, bioactive composition and antioxidant enzyme contents of ‘Umran’ ber fruit. The treated fruit were stored for 28 days to investigate the effects of sodium nitroprusside after 7 days of cold storage at 7.5°C and 90–95% RH. It was found that fruit treated with 100 μM sodium nitroprusside experienced lower fruit weight loss and spoilage, maintained fruit firmness, and had a higher sensory quality, phenolic content, carotenoid content, soluble solids content, sugar content, ascorbic acid and antioxidant activity than the control. Furthermore, the activities of the cell wall degrading enzymes polygalacturonase, polyphenol oxidase, pectin methyl esterase and catalase were lower, while the activities of superoxide dismutase and peroxidase enzymes were higher in the treated fruit. Therefore, treatment with 100 μM sodium nitroprusside shows high potential for improving the storage life and maintaining the quality attributes of ber fruit for up to 21 days under cold storage.

Effect of Litsea cubeba and Cinnamon Essential Oil Nanoemulsion Coatings on the Preservation of Plant-Based Meat Analogs

Plant-based meat analogs (PBMAs) are promising sustainable food sources. However, their high moisture and protein contents make them prone to microbial deterioration, limiting their shelf life and sensory appeal. This study explored enhancing PBMAs’ shelf life using nanoemulsions of Litsea cubeba and cinnamon essential oils, emulsified with chitosan and Tween 80. The composite nanoemulsion, produced through high-pressure homogenization, exhibited a droplet size of 4.99 ± 0.03 nm, a polydispersity index (PDI) of 0.221 ± 0.008, and a zeta potential of 95.13 ± 2.67 mV, indicating remarkable stability (p < 0.05). Applied to PBMAs stored at 4 °C, it significantly improved color and pH balance and reduced thiobarbituric acid reactive substances and cooking loss. Most notably, it inhibited the growth of Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus, curbing spoilage and protein oxidation, thereby extending the products’ shelf life and preserving sensory quality. As shown above, the encapsulation of LCEO/CEO in nanoemulsions effectively inhibits spoilage and deterioration in PBMAs, improving flavor and quality more than direct addition. Future studies should explore using various essential oils and emulsifiers, as well as alternative encapsulation techniques like microcapsules and nanoparticles, to further prevent PBMA deterioration.