Semmes-Weinstein Test Research Articles

Results of treatment of severe carpal-tunnel syndrome without internal neurolysis of the median nerve.

Thirty-three hands (twenty-nine patients) had a release of the carpal tunnel without internal neurolysis for severe carpal-tunnel syndrome. All of the hands had increased values for two-point discrimination or thenar atrophy, or both. Twenty-three (89 per cent) of the twenty-six hands that had increased values for two-point discrimination and twenty-six (87 per cent) of the thirty hands that had an elevated result on Semmes-Weinstein testing had normal values at follow-up. Nine (90 per cent) of the ten hands that had weakness of the thenar muscles (grade-3 strength or less) regained grade-4 or 5 strength. Thirteen (65 per cent) of the twenty hands that had thenar atrophy regained normal muscle bulk. Eighteen (62 per cent) of the twenty-nine patients had complete resolution of symptoms and signs of compression of the median nerve. No significant difference was found between the results in this series of patients and those in a previously reported similar group of patients who were treated by release of the carpal tunnel combined with internal neurolysis of the median nerve.

Evaluation of sensibility after sensory reconstruction of the thumb.

We have studied the restoration of sensation in 24 patients after operations involving the digital nerves of the thumb. These comprised 10 neurorrhaphies, two nerve graftings, five replantations, one toe-to-thumb transfer and six neurovascular island flaps. The average follow-up period was 46 months. Greater sensitivity was found in the moving two-point discrimination (2PD) test than in the static 2PD test. The results of the Semmes-Weinstein test showed good correlation with the static 2PD test. Porter's letter test showed correlations with both 2PD tests, and the pulp-writing test showed good correlation with the moving 2PD test. The neurorrhaphy cases had the best results using the static 2PD and Semmes-Weinstein test, and had good restoration of sensation; the replantation cases were next best. After neurovascular island flaps, patients exhibited hypersensitivity, double sensation and distorted images on the pulp-writing test. Using this same test the nerve grafting cases had distorted touch perception and perceived a straight line as a curve. The pulp-writing test, using moving touch, is one method of examining mechanoreceptors and shows to what extent the patient perceives what touches the finger pulp; it gives a better indication of higher functions than the 2PD test.