Central nervous system virus infections are a major cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide and a significant global public health concern. As in many tissues, inflammation and immune responses in the brain, despite their protective roles, can also be harmful. Control of brain inflammation is important in many neurological diseases from encephalitis to multiple sclerosis and neurogenerative disease. The suppressors of cytokine signaling (SOCS) proteins are a key mechanism controlling inflammatory and immune responses across all tissues including the brain. Using a mouse model system, we demonstrate that lack of SOCS4 results in changes in the pathogenesis and clinical outcome of a neurotropic virus infection. Relative to wild-type mice, SOCS4-deficient mice showed accelerated clearance of virus from the brain, lower levels of persisting viral RNA in the brain, increased neuroinflammation and more severe neuropathology. We conclude that, in the mouse brain, SOCS4 is a vital regulator of antiviral immunity that mediates the critical balance between immunopathology and virus persistence.