Seismostratigraphic Model Research Articles

Geologic causatives of the stratigraphic and structural heterogeneties of Baharyia formation, based on their seismic interpretation, Razzak field, Western Desert, Egypt

Evaluation of seismic attributes and seismic reflection characteristics analysis of Razzak Field was undertaken by subdividing the study area rock units. There are four seismo-facies units of varying parameters from top to bottom. These units are comparable to the Apollonia and Khoman Formations; the Abu-Roash Formation; Baharyia Formation and Alamein Formation. The seismo-facies unit 1 of the Apollonia and Khoman Formations reveal parallel to sub-parallel layering, with thickness increases northwards. The lithological distribution consists of limestone with minor clay intercalations with facies varying from middle neritic graded to outer neritic. Unit 2 of the Abu-Roash Formation shows divergent layering, with a thickness increasing gradually northwards and eastwards. The lithological distribution shows predominance of carbonate, sandstone occurring in minor portions and laterally graded into shale with littoral facies ranging to inner and middle neritic facies. Unit 3 of the Baharyia Formation reveals chaotic and oblique layering with a time thickness increases towards northeast and southwest parts, the lithological distribution exhibited sand and shale with minor limestone streaks, with facies varied changed from continental to inner-middle neritic, unit 4 of the Alamein Formation shows variation from parallel-subparallel orientation to oblique and chaotic with thickness increasing towards northwards and eastwards, the lithological distribution exhibited dolomitic limestone with minor streaks of limestone with facies varied from middle neritic facies to outer neritic and bathyal. Finally, the results are integrated to build up a seismo-stratigraphic model of the evaluated area of the northwestern Desert of Egypt. Seismic interpretation involves the construction of structure contour maps, in terms of time and depth, on the tops of the Apollonia, Abu-Roash, Baharyia and Alamein Formations. These maps show three structural closures, due to folding, that are dissected by NW–SE faults, analysis of relevant structural and stratigraphic seismic attributes such as root-mean-square amplitude, local structural dip, variance, ISO frequency component, sweetness and acoustic impedance average energy applied on reservoir tops, to enhance the visibility of faults, geological interpretation and the physical parameters of the subsurface related to lithology and stratigraphy for reservoir characterization. Finally, the results obtained are used to construct a seismic structural model. Integration of seismic and stratigraphic data is used to build a geological model of the northwestern Desert of Egypt.

Seismo-Stratigraphic Model for the Urban Area of Milan (Italy) by Ambient-Vibration Monitoring and Implications for Seismic Site Effects Assessment

In this paper, we present the work carried out to characterize the spatial variability of seismic site response related to local soil conditions in the city of Milan and its surroundings, an area with ∼3 million inhabitants and a high density of industrial facilities. The area is located at the northwestern end of the Po Plain, a large and deep sedimentary basin in northern Italy. An urban-scale seismo-stratigraphic model is developed based on new passive and active seismic data, supported by the available geological data and stratigraphic information from shallow and deep vertical wells. In particular, 33 single-station and 4 ambient-vibration array measurements are acquired, together with 4 active multichannel analyses of surface waves (MAWS). To estimate the resonant frequencies of the sediments, the horizontal to vertical spectral ratio technique (HVSR) is applied to the ambient-vibration recordings, whereas to determine the Rayleigh-wave dispersion curves from the passive array, the data are analysed using the conventional frequency-wavenumber, the modified spatial autocorrelation and the extended spatial autocorrelation (ESAC) techniques. The array data are used to determine the local shear wave velocity profiles, VS, via joint inversion of the Rayleigh-wave dispersion and ellipticity curves deduced from the HVSR. The results from HVSR show three main bands of amplified frequencies, the first in the range 0.17–0.23 Hz, the second from 0.45 to 0.65 Hz and the third from 3 to 8 Hz. A decreasing trend of the main peaks is observed from the northern to the southern part of the city, allowing us to hypothesize a progressive deepening of the relative regional chrono-stratigraphic unconformities. The passive ambient noise array and MASW highlight the dispersion of the fundamental mode of the Rayleigh-wave in the range 0.4–30 Hz, enabling to obtain detailed Vs. profiles with depth down to about 1.8 km. The seismo-stratigraphic model is used as input for 1D numerical modelling assuming linear soil conditions. The theoretical 1D transfer functions are compared to the HVSR curves evaluated from both ambient noise signals and earthquake waveforms recorded by the IV. MILN station in the last 10 years.

Assessing the Accuracy of a Borehole-Controlled P-Wave Velocity Model of Yucca Flat, Nevada Using Large-N Seismic Data

ABSTRACT With geologic data from over 950 boreholes, Yucca Flat basin, residing on the Nevada National Security Site, has excellent borehole control on stratigraphy. These data were used to create a Geologic Framework Model (GFM) of the basin. Of these boreholes, 188 have corresponding downhole seismic survey data, which were used to determine average P-wave velocities of the geologic units and create a GFM seismostratigraphic model (GFM-SS). With the acquisition of six new active-source large-N datasets in Yucca Flat, we can now quantitatively assess the accuracy of the GFM-SS previously controlled only by borehole data. For each of the six datasets, we subset the GFM to the region of interest and create a forward model of P-wave travel times for the GFM-SS given the large-N source-receiver geometries. We first made trial-and-error adjustments to the unit velocities (while keeping the layer geometry intact) to improve the travel-time residuals. We then implemented a simulated annealing approach to find the optimal velocity model for each dataset. Our results indicate that the borehole-controlled model overestimates alluvium velocities across Yucca Flat. This result persists even when we make smaller GFM-SS models that are local to individual large-N experiments. We hypothesize that this result is a combination of shorter ray paths and the resulting lack of interaction with large-scale features (such as faults), as well as less attenuation of high frequencies in the borehole data. Both the current GFM-SS and the updated model based on median velocities that we present here overgeneralize local unit velocities, which can be quite heterogeneous in Yucca Flat.

New Insights into Long-Period (>1 s) Seismic Amplification Effects in Deep Sedimentary Basins: A Case of the Po Plain Basin of Northern Italy

ABSTRACTThis study investigates and quantifies the influence of the shallower deposits (down to few hundreds of meters) of the Po Plain sedimentary basin (northern Italy) on the long-period component (i.e., 1 s<T<3 s) of seismic ground motion, in which amplification effects due to the soft sediments above seismic bedrock were observed.A new seismostratigraphic model of the shallow deposits of the entire basin is provided with an unprecedented detail by taking advantage of recently acquired geophysical data. The seismostratigraphic model is used to simulate the ground motion amplification in the Po Plain by means of extensive 1D ground response analysis. Results are compared with seismic observations available at a number of sites equipped with borehole seismic stations, where earthquakes have been recorded both at the surface and at the seismic bedrock depth. Despite the general agreement with observations concerning the seismic resonance frequencies, our model may fail in capturing the amplitude of the actual seismic amplification of the basin in the long-period range. We observe that 3D basin effects related to surface waves generated at the edge of the basin may play a significant role in those zones where seismic hazard is controlled by distant sources. In these cases, 1D modeling leads to average underestimations of 30%, up to a maximum of 60%. The amplification functions need to be corrected for a basin-effects correction term, which in this case is provided by the ground-motion prediction equation of the study area. The corrected amplification functions agree with the empirical observations, overcoming the uneven distribution of the recording stations in strong-motion datasets.These results should be taken into account in future seismic microzonation studies in the Po Plain area, where the 1D approach is commonly adopted in ground response analyses, and in site-specific seismic hazard assessments aimed at the design of structures that are sensitive to the long-period component of seismic ground motion (e.g., long-span bridges and tall buildings).

A Seismostratigraphic Model of the Aldan–Maya Sedimentary Basin of the Southeastern Siberian Platform

Using the generalized data of the seismic exploration studies carried out in the Aldan-Maya sedimentary basin, the choice of the seismostratigraphic model has been validated and the transversal and longitudinal sections have been constructed that allow understanding the features of the structure of the sedimentary cover and refining the basin boundaries. Based on the seismic sections and the geological map at a scale of 1 : 2 500 000, a scheme is constructed showing the structures formed in the Riphean. These constructions aim at more purposeful planning of oil-and-gas exploration, as well as estimating the thickness and the area of the parent strata. The results of conducted studies can be used to refine the structure of the southeastern Siberian Platform.

An inter-disciplinary and multi-scale approach to assess the spatial variability of ground motion for seismic microzonation: the case study of Cavezzo municipality in Northern Italy

Seismic microzonation represents a basic tool for prevention activity planning and land management. An extensive and detailed microzonation study was performed with reference to the territory of the Municipality of Cavezzo, damaged during the seismic sequence hitting Emilia-Romagna Region, Northern Italy, in 2012. In this paper, we discuss the work carried out to characterize the spatial variability of ground motion amplification due to local soil conditions in the municipality area.An inter- and multi-disciplinary approach is presented, involving geotechnical engineers, geophysicists, geologists and seismologists from different institutions, to thoroughly characterize the territory using complementary techniques with different level of resolution and confidence. A considerable amount of geomorphological, geological, hydrogeological, seismological, geotechnical and geophysical investigations was collected and processed for the purpose. A GIS-based (Geographic Information System) platform was initially setup to manage the gathered data, which now includes the results of about 1000 geotechnical and geophysical tests. Such an extended dataset was then used as a primary constraint for the creation of a comprehensive pseudo-3D geotechnical and seismo-stratigraphic model of the territory, consisting of a dense grid of one-dimensional vertical profiles to depict the variability of the soil properties over the area. The model was finally used as input for linear-equivalent ground response analysis. For the calculation of the amplification factors, special emphasis was given to the treatment and propagation of the uncertainties of the model parameters, whose different realizations have been accounted through a logic tree approach.

СЕЙСМОСТРАТИГРАФИЧЕСКАЯ МОДЕЛЬ АЛДАНО-МАЙСКОГО ОСАДОЧНОГО БАССЕЙНА (ЮГО-ВОСТОК СИБИРСКОЙ ПЛАТФОРМЫ)

Generations of the materials of the seismic exploratory works conducted in the Aldan-Maya sedimentary basin substantiated the seismostratigraphic model and construction of the lateral and longitudinal sections allowed an understanding of the specific features of the sedimentary cover structure and specifying the basin boundaries. Based on the seismic sections and geologic map at a scale of 1: 2 500 000 a scheme of structures formed in the Riphean was developed. These constructions made it possible the purposeful plan of the oil-and-gas searching and exploratory works, estimation of thickness and area of the parent material. The investigations made can be applied for clarification of the structure of the eastern Siberian Platform.

Cenozoic Clinoform Complexes and the Geological History of the North Chukchi Basin (Chuckchi Sea, Arctic)

A new seismostratigraphic model was developed for the sedimentary cover of the North-Chukchi Basin and the main paleogeographic events that occurred within this territory were interpreted. The post-rift sedimentary history of the North-Chukchi basin can be divided into three stages: the late Cretaceous–Paleocene with strong progradation of shelf sedimentary packages to the north, the middle Eocene–Miocene with gradual differently oriented filling of the basin from different sides, and the late Miocene until the present. At the last stage, the shelf outlines were formed along with slow aggradation of the clinoform complex with an insignificant northern deviation.

Seismo-stratigraphic model of "La Bandita" area in the Palermo Plain (Sicily, Italy) through HVSR inversion constrained by stratigraphic data

Ambient noise Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR) technique is commonly used approach to obtain 1D models of the shear-wave velocity in the shallow surface of an investigated area. However, obtained models can have a wide margin of uncertainty if inversions have not been appropriately constrained by detailed stratigraphic information. An application of HVSR inversion constrained by lithostratigraphic data is presented in order to verify the effectiveness of this technique for purposes of geological and geophysical reconstruction of a sedimentary basin in a densely urbanized area. This is often the case of seismic microzonation studies, in which almost all the information derives from near surface stratigraphic drillings, since other geophysical methods are logistically difficult to carry out. In our work, we used stratigraphic constraints derived from 93 superficial bore-holes whose depth rarely exceeds 30 m. In an area called La Bandita, located in Palermo Plain (Sicily, Italy), a geophysical survey was performed by means of 55 microtremor recordings. Part of these was distributed randomly, while others very close to the available stratigraphic perforations. The reconstruction of the stratigraphy in the studied area has been obtained by a review of the main stratigraphic sequences and by a consequent stratigraphic three-dimensional modelling. HVSR curves have been interpreted taking care the thicknesses of the near surface successions derived by the stratigraphic 3-D model. The results, in terms of vertical profiles of the shear-wave velocity, have been interpolated to obtain a 3D seismic model. This has been used to extract basic information to identify and reconstruct the seismic bedrock and the main geological boundaries that were not directly identifiable by means of only stratigraphic logs. It results that the bedrock is affected by a fault system that generated adjacent depressions where Quaternary successions deposited.

Evaluation of local site effect from microtremor measurements in Babol City, Iran

Every year, numerous casualties and a large deal of financial losses are incurred due to earthquake events. The losses incurred by an earthquake vary depending on local site effect. Therefore, in order to conquer drastic effects of an earthquake, one should evaluate urban districts in terms of the local site effect. One of the methods for evaluating the local site effect is microtremor measurement and analysis. Aiming at evaluation of local site effect across the city of Babol, the study area was gridded and microtremor measurements were performed with an appropriate distribution. The acquired data was analyzed through the horizontal-to-vertical noise ratio (HVNR) method, and fundamental frequency and associated amplitude of the H/V peak were obtained. The results indicate that fundamental frequency of the study area is generally lower than 1.25 Hz, which is acceptably in agreement with the findings of previous studies. Also, in order to constrain and validate the seismostratigraphic model obtained with this method, the results were compared with geotechnical, geological, and seismic data. Comparing the results of different methods, it was observed that the presented geophysical method can successfully determine the values of fundamental frequency across the study area as well as local site effect. Using the data obtained from the analysis of microtremor, a microzonation map of fundamental frequency across the city of Babol was prepared. This map has numerous applications in designing high-rise building and urban development plans.

Seismostratigraphy of the Siberian Sector of the Arctic Ocean and adjacent Laptev Sea Shelf

AbstractA new seismostratigraphic model has been established within the Arctic Ocean adjacent to the East Siberian Shelf on the basis of multichannel seismic reflection data acquired along a transect at 81°N. Ages for the sedimentary units were estimated via links to seismic lines and drill site data of the US Chukchi Shelf, the Lomonosov Ridge, and the adjacent Laptev Shelf. Two distinct seismic units were mapped throughout the area and are the constraints for dating the remaining strata. The lower marker unit, a pronounced high‐amplitude reflector sequence (HARS), is the most striking stratigraphic feature over large parts of the Arctic Ocean. It indicates a strong and widespread change in deposition conditions. Probably, it developed during Oligocene times when a reorientation of Arctic Plates took place, accompanied by the gradual opening of the Fram Strait, and a widespread regression of sea level. The top of the HARS likely marks the end of Oligocene/early Miocene (23 Ma). An age estimate for the base of the sequence is less clear but likely corresponds to base of Eocene (˜56 Ma). The second marked unit detected on the seismic lines parallels the seafloor with a thickness of about 200 ms two‐way travel time (160 m). Its base is marked by a change from a partly transparent sequence with weak amplitude reflections below to a set of continuous high‐amplitude reflectors above. This interface likely marks the transition to large‐scale glaciation of the northern hemisphere and therefore is ascribed to the top Miocene (5.3 Ma).

Variability in Cenozoic sedimentation and paleo-water depths of the Weddell Sea basin related to pre-glacial and glacial conditions of Antarctica

The Weddell Sea basin is of particular significance for understanding climate processes, including the generation of ocean water masses and their influence on ocean circulation as well as the dynamics of the Antarctic ice sheets. The sedimentary record, preserved below the basin floor, serves as an archive of the pre-glacial to glacial development of these processes, which were accompanied by tectonic processes in its early glacial phase. Three multichannel seismic reflection transects, in total nearly 5000km long, are used to interpret horizons and define a seismostratigraphic model for the basin. We expand this initial stratigraphic model to the greater Weddell Sea region through a network of more than 200 additional seismic lines. Information from few boreholes is used to constrain sediment ages in this stratigraphy, supported by magnetic anomalies indicating decreasing oceanic basement ages from southeast to northwest. Using these constraints, we calculate grids to depict the depths, thicknesses and sedimentation rates of pre-glacial (145–34Ma), transitional (34–15Ma) and full-glacial (15Ma to present) units. These grids allow us to compare the sedimentary regimes of the pre-glacially dominated and glacially dominated stages of Weddell Sea history. The pre-glacial deposition with thicknesses of up to 5km was controlled by the tectonic evolution and sea-floor spreading history interacting with terrigenous sediment supply. The transitional unit shows a relatively high sedimentation rate and has thicknesses of up to 3km, which may attribute to an early formation of the East Antarctic Ice Sheet, which was partly advanced to the coast or even inner shelf. The main deposition center of the full-glacial unit lies in front of the Filchner-Ronne Ice Shelf and has sedimentation rates of up to 140–200m/Myr, which infers that ice sheets grounded on the middle to the outer shelf and that bottom-water currents strongly impacted the sedimentation. We further calculate paleobathymetric grids at 15Ma, 34Ma, and 120Ma by using a backstripping technique. Our results provide constraints for an improved understanding of the paleo-ice sheet dynamics and paleoclimate conditions of the Weddell Sea region.

Variations in bottom water activity at the southern Argentine margin: indications from a seismic analysis of a continental slope terrace

Continental slope terraces at the southern Argentine margin are part of a significant contourite depositional system composed of a variety of drifts, channels, and sediment waves. Here, a refined seismostratigraphic model for the sedimentary development of the Valentin Feilberg Terrace located in ~4.1 km water depth is presented. Analyzing multichannel seismic profiles across and along this terrace, significant changes in terrace morphology and seismic reflection character are identified and interpreted to reflect variations in deep water hydrography from Late Miocene to recent times, involving variable flow of Antarctic Bottom Water and Circumpolar Deep Water. A prominent basin-wide aggradational seismic unit is interpreted to represent the Mid-Miocene climatic optimum (~17–14 Ma). A major current reorganization can be inferred for the time ~14–12 Ma when the Valentin Feilberg Terrace started growing due to the deposition of sheeted and mounded drifts. After ~12 Ma, bottom water flow remained vigorous at both margins of the terrace. Another intensification of bottom flow occurred at ~5–6 Ma when a mounded drift, moats, and sediment waves developed on the terrace. This may have been caused by a general change in deep water mass organization following the closure of the Panamanian gateway, and a subsequent stronger southward flow of North Atlantic Deep Water.

Review of geology of the New Siberian Islands between the Laptev and the East Siberian Seas, North East Russia

Abstract. The New Siberian Islands comprise De Long Islands, Anjou Islands, and Lyakhov Islands. Early Paleozoic, Mesozoic and Cenozoic sediments and igneous rocks are known on the De Long Islands. Cambrian slate, siltstone, mudstone and silicified limestone occur on Bennett Island. Ordovician volcanogenic turbidites, lavas, and small intrusions of andesite-basalt, basalt, dolerite, and porphyritic diorite were mapped on Henrietta Island. The igneous rocks are of calc-alkaline island arc series. The Ordovician age of the sequence was defined radiometrically. Early Paleozoic strata were faulted and folded presumably in the Caledonian time. Early Cretaceous sandstone and mudstone are known on Bennett Island. They are overlain by a 106–124 Ma basalt unit. Cenozoic volcanics are widespread on the De Long Islands. Zhokhov Island is an eroded stratovolcano. The volcanics are mostly of picrite-olivine type and limburgite. Radiometric dating indicates Miocene to Recent ages for Cenozoic volcanism. On the Anjou islands Lower-Middle Paleozoic strata consist of carbonates, siliciclastics, and clay. A Northwest-southeast syn-sedimentary facies zonation has been reconstructed. Upper Paleozoic strata are marine carbonate, clay and siliciclastic facies. Mudstone and clay predominate in the Triassic to Upper Jurassic section. Aptian-Albian coal bearing deposits uconformably overlap lower strata indicating Early Cretaceous tectonism. Upper Cretaceous units are mostly clay and siltstone with brown coal strata resting on Early Cretaceous weathered rhyolite. Cenozoic marine and nonmarine silisiclastics and clay rest upon the older units with a transgressive unconformity including a weathering profile in the older rocks. Manifestations of Paleozoic and Triassic mafic and Cretaceous acidic magmatism are also found on these islands. The pre-Cretaceous structure of the Anjou islands is of a block and fold type Late Cimmerian in age followed by faulting in Cenozoic time. The Lyakhov islands are located at the western end of the Late Cimmerian South Anyui suture. Sequences of variable age, composition, and structural styles are known on the Lyakhov Islands. These include an ancient metamorphic sequence, Late Paleozoic ophiolitic sequence, Late Mesozoic turbidite sequence, Cretaceous granites, and Cenozoic sediments. Fold and thrust imbricate structures have been mapped on southern Bol'shoi Lyakhov Island. North-northwestern vergent thrusts transect the Island and project offshore. Open folds of Jurassic–Early Cretaceous strata are characteristic of Stolbovoi and Malyi Lyakhov islands. Geology of the New Siberian Islands supports the concept of a circum Arctic Phanerozoic fold belt. The belt is comprised of Caledonian, Ellesmerian, Early Cimmerian and Late Cimmerian fold systems, manifested in many places on the mainland and on islands around the Arctic Ocean. Knowledge of the geology of the New Siberian Islands has been used to interpret anomalous gravity and magnetic field maps and Multi Channel Seismic (MCS) lines. Two distinguishing structural stages are universally recognized within the offshore sedimentary cover which correlate with the onshore geology of the New Siberian Islands. Dating of the upper structural stage and constituent seismic units is based on structural and stratigraphic relationships between Late Mesozoic and Cenozoic units in the archipelago. The Laptev Sea–western East Siberian Sea seismostratigraphic model for the upper structural stage has much in common with the seismostratigraphic model in the American Chukchi Sea.

Seismic facies and reservoir characteristics of a deep-marine channel belt in the Molasse foreland basin, Puchkirchen Formation, Austria

Oligocene–Miocene deep-water deposits of the Puchkirchen and basal Hall formations contain the main gas reservoirs of the Austrian Molasse Basin. A new seismostratigraphic model, based on a 2000-km2 (772-mi2), regional, three-dimensional (3-D) seismic data set, has fundamentally changed our understanding of the depositional processes and reservoir distribution in this classic deep-water foreland basin. Regional 3-D seismic attribute maps, calibrated by nearly 350 wells, reveal that sedimentation occurred primarily within the confines of a large (3–5 km [1.8–3.1 mi] wide by 100 km [62 mi] long), low-sinuosity channel belt that occupied the Molasse Basin foredeep. The channel fill consists predominantly of turbiditic conglomerate and sandstone, as well as chaotic slump and debris-flow deposits. Overbank areas are characterized by fine-grained turbiditic sandstone and mudstone. Incised canyons and ponded slope fans were active along the southern basin margin; lateral tributary channels intersected the axial channel belt in the north. Significant accumulations of gas are stratigraphically and structurally trapped in channel thalweg and slope-fan sandstones, with more modest amounts in overbank lobe and tributary-channel deposits. Basin geometry had a profound effect on the architecture of the channel belt and subsequent sediment distribution. Large-scale deep-water channel systems are poorly documented from foreland basins; the depositional model developed for the Puchkirchen Formation was made possible through the use of high-quality seismic data and an extensive drill-core database. The depositional model may be a useful analog for other elongate, deep-water basins, especially those that lack extensive, modern data sets.

Facies Analysis at Triassic/Jurassic Boundary: Support for Eustatic Control of Global Sequence Stratigraphy": ABSTRACT"

Recognition of global seismostratigraphic sequences and their eustatic interpretation has been a key geological concept of the past decade. Published criticism recently has led Exxon staff to constrain their sequence boundaries through the onshore geological record, thus placing the data base partially in the public domain. This act is a major step, since field testing of the eustatic model has been surprisingly limited, despite the latter's widespread use in interpretating basin histories. The type of field calibration required is exemplified by a comprehensive global analysis of the marine stratigraphic record from the basal Sevatian substrate (Norian) to the Semicostatum zone (Sinemurian). This 20 Ma interval was originally selected because of discrepancies between Exxon's and previous eustatic curves, and for its sound biostratigraphic control. Four key areas were studied at outcrop, in varied paleogeographic and paleotectonic settings (Peru, Nevada, northwestern Europe and pacific Canada). Fieldwork was supported by an extensive literature survey, including key areas of the eastern USSR. Interpretation involved depth assessment for each facies and the construction of bathymetric curves, which contrasts with the Exxon objective of recognizing depositional surfaces consistent with the seismostratigraphic model. A significant similarity between the 23 bathymetric curves created indicates eustatic control. The bathymetric more » data also constrain rates of global sea level change. Important global shallowing phases during Crickmayi zone and Angulata zone times were recognized in the study, consistent with the Exxon model. The Exxon perception of the Hettangian as a sea level lowstand is not supported and requires further discussion. « less