This is an original and imaginative study. Hélène Bah Ostrowiecki sets out to show the body — whether animate or inanimate as pure physical entity, and distinct from mind, spirit, or soul — as the anchor of Pascal’s apologetic discourse, both as a nucleus in which his ideas cohere, but also as the essential and independent reference point in man’s search for God. ‘Bodies’ function as witnesses for those able to recognize them as such. The text is densely written, and careful reading is required to avoid becoming disorientated, because it imitates Pascal’s own to-and-fro style of argumentation, and constantly relates Pascal’s various ternary ordres to the Cartesian division of body from spirit. But the reader is rewarded by Ostrowiecki’s fresh insights, and her close attention both to Pascal’s writing, principally the Pensées, and to scholarly debate. From the matrix of ternary and binary interactions, five focuses are identified through which to interpret Pascal’s attitude to the body. The first is ‘Maladie: la fiction d’un homme sans corps’. After an excellent discussion the dualist proposition, ‘séparant un esprit (une intérieure salvatrice) et un corps (une extériorité corruptrice)’ (p. 43), is firmly rejected. Since this is not a physiological study, there is no extended discussion of the diagnoses of Pascal’s pathophysiological illnesses, nor of the effect of physical illness of the body on the psychopathological development of the mind. In the second chapter, ‘Chair’, Ostrowiecki provides an illuminating examination of Pascal’s distinction of corps from chair, how they interact, and the primacy of the former. Without the body, there can be no carnality. The following chapter, ‘Sentiment’, continues the exploration of corporality in the mystical subjects of feeling/conscience and experience and the place of the cœur in the theological argument. The notion of the body as witness is introduced and elaborated. The next and most inventive chapter is ‘Machine’, which deals with two of the most enigmatic words of Pascal’s imagery: ‘machine’ and ‘abêtir’. Here we find what might serve as a mission statement for Ostrowiecki’s enterprise: ‘[P]our Pascal, la réponse au défi apologétique passe conjointement par un geste de soumission et par un recours au corps, ce qui invite à explorer les voies selon lesquelles cette soumission est soumission au corps’ (p. 123). The final chapter, ‘Tout’, is a particularly absorbing text about the part played by the body in the constitution of the individual. The body opens the moi to experience and situates the individual among other bodies and also within metaphorical bodies such as the Church. Ostrowiecki incorporates Pascal’s scientific pursuits into this discussion, and by the end of the book all idea of the body as a barrier is convincingly abolished. There seems to be an inclination, possibly unintentional, to rationalize all of Pascal’s many personal activities under the apologetic umbrella, and the odour of hagiography is occasionally unmistakable, as, for example, when Pascal’s involvement in the commercialization of a public transport system, initially alluded to as ‘troublant’ (pp. 167, 168), has within a few paragraphs become ‘l’expression de la piété’ (p. 169). These few caveats notwithstanding, this thought-provoking book is a valuable contribution to Pascal studies.
Read full abstract