Early recognition of stroke symptoms and risk factors is important for timely intervention to improve outcomes. This study aimed to investigate differences in stroke frequency, risk factors, and presentation in pregnant and non-pregnant women of reproductive years. This multicenter ambispective cohort study, conducted from 4th August 2021 to 4th March 2023, examined strokes in women of reproductive years at the neurology outpatient/emergency department of five busiest/referred neuro-medical facilities in Karachi, Pakistan, where patients from across the nation are assessed. In all, 1210 patients were enrolled via consecutive or convenient sampling retrospectively from January 2017 to August 2021 and prospectively from August 2021 to March 2023. Pregnancy-related and non-pregnancy-related stroke occurrence and characteristics were compared using the chi-square/Fischer's exact test. 56% were non-pregnancy-related strokes and 44% were pregnancy-related strokes with non-pregnancy-related strokes approximately equal throughout the reproductive years (15-24 years = 34%, 25-34 years = 25%, 35-45 years = 41%) and pregnancy-related stroke between 15 and 35 years (82%). In the non-pregnancy-related stroke, arterial stroke dominated (96.4%); while in pregnancy-related stroke, arterial stroke accounted for 61.4% and venous stroke for 38.6% of cases. Middle cerebral artery was a typical stroke site (66%). Infarction was the most significant CT/MRI finding (PRS = 89%, NPRS = 66%), with pregnancy-related stroke hemorrhagic stroke occurring in only 11% of cases and non-pregnancy-related stroke comprising one-third (34%). The most prevalent etiologies were eclampsia in pregnancy-related stroke (32%), hypertension in non-pregnancy-related stroke (40%), and cardiac problems among both groups (25%:33%). Weakness and headache were the common clinical manifestations among both groups. In the pregnancy-related and non-pregnancy-related stroke groups, the initial presentation of stroke resulted in severe disability for 91% and 75%, respectively. With timely treatment, the outcome improved significantly. The mortality rate was 7% for the pregnancy-related stroke group and 4% for the non-pregnancy-related stroke group. Our findings show that stroke is prevalent among reproductive-year women, posing a significant mortality risk if not adequately recognized and treated. Awareness, research, and screening of stroke risk factors and their often-overlooked early presentation (i.e., headache and weakness) in reproductive years are essential to reducing stroke occurrence among reproductive-year women.