Oxidation of cyclopentanone (CPO) was studied over metal-free carbon catalysts in solvent-free conditions. Norit SX plus (900 m2 g−1) and Vulcan XC72 (240 m2 g−1) were used as pristine materials. Catalysts were prepared by activation in nitrogen and by treatment with urea, calcined in nitrogen at 500 °C and 950 °C. SEM, EDX, XPS, X-ray powder diffraction, nitrogen adsorption–desorption isotherms, acid–base titration, FTIR and Raman techniques were used for characterization. Catalytic tests carried out at 0.45 MPa and 80–110 °C enabled to find the best results: 30% selectivity to glutaric acid (GA) and 3% to succinic acid at 25% conversion of CPO, over Vulcan type catalysts. A low activity, selectivity and strong deactivation of Norit type catalysts can be ascribed to a higher specific surface in a disordered arrangement providing a high concentration of unselective catalytic sites. A higher extent of side reactions can yield in higher molar mass products, which stick on the surface and block catalytic sites. Optimum amount of accessible planar domains, represented by graphene and/or graphitic plates with some disorders present in Vulcan type catalysts classified them superior to Norit catalysts. A redox reaction scheme of oxidation of CPO to GA is also proposed.Graphical abstract