Scheduled Treatment Interruption Research Articles

FAILURE OF 1 WEEK ON/1 WEEK OFF ANTIRETROVIRAL THERAPIES IN A RANDOMIZED TRIAL

Ananworanich J, Nuesch R, Le Braz M, et al. AIDS. 2003;17:F33–F37Although highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) has dramatically improved the duration and quality of life of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected individuals, an increasing number of serious complications are being identified among patients who are treated with these agents for long periods of time. Strategies that reduce the total drug exposure among infected patients while maintaining the stability of HIV and T cell levels would be welcomed. Scheduled or structured treatment interruptions are being evaluated in an effort to decrease the costs and side effects of HAART.In this study, 600 patients receiving successful HAART were randomized to either continuous therapy, CD4+ T cell count-guided therapy, or 1 week on/1 week off therapy.This report described the preliminary analysis of data for the 1 week on/1 week off arm. Of 36 evaluable patients, 19 had 2 successive HIV RNA plasma concentrations of >500 copies/mL after 1 week off therapy; those cases were classified as virologic failures. Most of the patients who experienced failure were receiving didanosine, stavudine, saquinavir, and ritonavir. Among those patients, there was no evidence of mutations suggesting drug resistance. Plasma saquinavir levels were within the expected range.The 1 week on/1 week off schedule tested in this study showed an unacceptably high failure rate and was therefore terminated early.Early anecdotal reports suggested that HIV-specific immune responses were boosted after discontinuation of therapy. Clinical trials based on this concept were developed for both acute and chronic HIV infections. The most promising results were from studies involving subjects who were treated for acute HIV infections; specific T cell responses to HIV were enhanced after interruptions in therapy. Similar findings have not been demonstrated for patients with chronic HIV infections. The results of this study are certainly disappointing. However, the definition of virologic failure in this study was a rebound to ≥500 copies/mL. Current guidelines suggest that HIV RNA levels of <50 000 copies/mL, with stable CD4+ T cell levels, might be acceptable. The major concern with this approach would be the development of resistance to the antiretroviral therapy if repeated rebounds were allowed to continue in the off weeks. Studies of scheduled or structured treatment interruptions will continue. Perhaps a 2 weeks on/1 week off or 3 weeks on/1 week off schedule would limit the viral rebounds and still reduce the cumulative drug exposure for patients.

T-cell receptor excision circles (TREC) in SHIV 89.6p and SIVmac251 models of HIV-1 infection.

T-cell receptor excision circles (TREC) may be a useful surrogate marker in HIV-1 infection for evaluating the likelihood of continued clinical stability and/or the response to therapeutics, including vaccines. Analysis of TREC in SHIV and SIV models of HIV-1 infection may provide additional information concerning the utility of TREC as a marker. We measured TREC in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from rhesus macaques in SHIV89.6p (n = 20) and SIVmac251 (n = 11) models of HIV-1 infection. TREC were also evaluated in tissues in the SIVmac251 model at end-point. In the SHIV89.6p model, TREC in PBMC were significantly lower at 12 weeks postinfection compared to preinfection levels. The decrease in TREC correlated with the decline in CD4+ T cells (r(s) = 0.496; P = 0.026), which in turn correlated inversely with serum viral loads at end-point (r(s) = -0.517; P = 0.019). Macaques that controlled SHIV89.6p infection to some degree (n = 6) had higher TREC at study end-point (P = 0.017). In the SIVmac251 model, TREC in PBMC were significantly reduced after 17 months of infection (P = 0.012) despite receiving highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) consisting of didanosine (ddI) and (R)-9-(2-phosphonylmethoxypropyl)-adenine (PMPA) when not cycling off therapy during scheduled treatment interruptions (STI). However, macaques that received continuous hydroxyurea (HU) in addition to the HAART regimen had higher end-point TREC compared to the non-HU group (P = 0.041), and the reduction in TREC observed at end-point within the HU group was not significant. In the SIVmac251 model, TREC correlated with the percentage of CD4+ T cells (r(s) = 0.426; P = 0.048) and CD4+CD28+ T cells (r(s) = 0.624; P = 0.002), and inversely with CD8+ T cells (r(s) = -0.622; P = 0.002), CD8+CD28- T cells (r(s) = -0.516; P = 0.014), and serum viral loads (r(s) = -0.627; P = 0.039). High levels of TREC were observed in the thymus, levels comparable to PBMC were seen in the lymph node, and low but detectable levels of TREC were present in bone marrow. The use of correlates of TREC as covariates in ANCOVA revealed that the decline in TREC in the SHIV 89.6p model reflected the decline in the percentage of CD4+ T-cells due to viral cytopathogenicity. In the SIVmac251 model, the decline in TREC was related to increased immune activation and proliferation due to viral replication, as reflected by decreases in percentages of CD4+CD28+ T cells and increases in CD8+ and CD8+CD28- T cells.

Strategies to Decrease Viral Load Rebound, and Prevent Loss of Cd4 and Onset of Resistance during Structured Treatment Interruptions

Toxicity and other drug adherence-related factors have contributed to decreased compliance to antiretroviral regimens amongst HIV-infected patients. Irregular therapy disruption causes loss of CD4 T cells, onset of drug resistance and rapid rebound of plasma viral load (VL). However, an appropriate choice of drugs and properly scheduled structured treatment interruptions (STIs) may limit VL rebound, maintain CD4 counts and minimize resistance. We conducted a clinical study of STIs, RIGHT 901, involving 60 drug-naive patients with chronic HIV infection (CD4 >300, VL >10,000) randomized to receive didanosine-stavudine-indinavir (IDV group) or didanosine-stavudine-hydroxyurea (HU group), for 12 weeks. Subsequently, all patients were randomized again to start STI (short induction) or to continue the therapy for an additional 24 weeks before starting STI (long induction). Both groups underwent four STI cycles and then stopped therapy as long as viraemia remained below 10,000 copies/ml before reinitiating another four cycles of STI. During continuous therapy VLs were suppressed at similar rates in both the HU and IDV groups, while a blunted CD4 count was documented in the HU group. Following the first stop median VL rebounded close to baseline values in both groups, however, during the following STI median VL rebound decreased in the HU group, while in the IDV group VL continued to rebound to values close to baseline, and the difference between the two groups was statistically significant. Moreover, patients treated with HU had a constant and stable CD4 increase during STI, whereas CD4 counts fluctuated in the IDV group, with sharp falls during treatment interruptions and partial CD4 recovery following treatment restart. Even in the presence of IDV resistance predisposing mutations at baseline, no genotypic change in the protease sequence was observed during STI. A relevant mutation in the reverse transcriptase sequence (K70R) emerged in one patient interrupting treatment after 36 weeks of continuous therapy and in one patient after four STI cycles. Side effects (no major events) were similar among groups. An appropriate choice of STI schedule and regimens containing drugs less prone to resistance and/or able to prevent CD4 fluctuation may contribute to optimizing STI for chronically infected patients with respect to limiting viral rebound, improving CD4 counts and maintaining a resistance profile comparable to continuous highly active antiretroviral therapy.

Structured interruptions of therapy

Background: Scheduled treatment interruptions are being evaluated in an effort to decrease costs and side effects of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART). A schedule of 1 week on and 1 week off therapy offers the promise of 50% less drug exposure with continuously undetectable HIV RNA concentration. Methods: In the Staccato study 600 patients on successful HAART were to be randomized to either continued therapy, CD4-guided therapy, or one week on, one week off therapy. A scheduled preliminary analysis evaluated effectiveness in the 1-week-on-1-week-off arm. Results: Of 36 evaluable patients, 19 (53%) had two successive HIV RNA concentrations > 500 copies/ml at the end of the week off therapy, and were classified as virological failure. Most of those who failed took didanosine, stavudine, saquinavir, and ritonavir (11 patients). In these patients, there was no evidence of mutations suggestive of drug resistance, and plasma saquinavir levels were within the expected range.