Scaphoid Excision Research Articles

DIC Ligament Prevents Increased DISI after Distal Scaphoid Excision: Not a clinical study

DIC Ligament Prevents Increased DISI after Distal Scaphoid Excision: Not a clinical study

Four-Corner Fusion and Scaphoid Excision Using Headless Compression Screws for SLAC and SNAC Wrist Deformities

Scapholunate advanced collapse and scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse wrist deformities are the most common causes of traumatic arthritis of the wrist. Four-corner fusion and scaphoid excision has proven to be an effective procedure for relieving pain and preserving range of motion in the wrist joint. Several methods for providing fixation of the midcarpal joint during fusion have been used, including K-wires, staples, and the Spider plate. K-wire fixation has proven effective, but requires a period of cast immobilization to protect the fusion mass. The Spider plate was promising, but has not been without complications. The development and improvements in cannulated headless compression screws has resulted in increased indications for their use, including fixation for 4-corner fusion. We review the technique and tips developed by the senior author over the last several years using headless compression screws for fixation of the midcarpal joint. Acutrak 2 Standard implants were used. This technique has allowed for early range of motion with reliable fusion rates.

The outcomes of NiTi shape memory alloy four-corner arthrodesis concentrator for carpal collapse

Objective To evaluate the results of NiTi shape memory alloy four-corner arthrodesis concentrator (NTMA-FCAC) for carpal collapse. Methods We reviewed retrospectively 13 patients who underwent scaphoid excision with four-corner arthrodesis using NTMA-FCAC for carpal collapse from August 2006 to June 2009. There were eight males and five females, with an average age of 38 years (range, 23-61years). The cause of carpal collapse was SNAC in 7 cases, perilunate dislocations in five and SLAC in one.The injury mechanisms included traffic accidents (5 cases), falling from a height (4 cases), crashes (3 cases)and sprain (1 case). Objective measurements included grip strength and range of the wrist. Radiographs were performed in all patients. A visual analogue scale (VAS) was used to assess wrist pain. The results were evaluated according to the Krimmer wrist scores. Results The mean follow-up time was 26.5 months (range,6-36 months). Clinical evaluation yielded the mean grip strength of (32.49±6.21) kg (80.8% of opposite side).The mean range of the wrist reached over 53% of the healthy side. Non-union and wound infection were not seen. The mean VAS scores had improved from 4.46±1.27 preoperatively to 1.31 ±0.95 postoperatively. The mean pain scores under stress had improved from 7.00±1.41 preoperatively to 2.62±1.26 postoperatively.There were remarkable differences between them. The mean Krimmer wrist score was 79. Conclusion Four-corner arthrodesis using NTMA-FCAC is an effective method for carpal collapse, preserving a majority of wrist function. Key words: Carpal joints; Nickel; Titanium; Osteoarthritis; Arthrodesis

Four-corner arthrodesis concentrator of Ni-Ti memory alloy for carpal collapse

To evaluate the treatment outcomes of a four-corner arthrodesis concentrator of Ni-Ti memory alloy for carpal collapse. From August 2006 to November 2009, 13 patients with carpal collapse underwent scaphoid excision and four-corner (capitate, lunate, triquetrum and hamate) arthrodesis using a four-corner arthrodesis concentrator of Ni-Ti memory alloy. The mean follow-up time was 26.5 months (range, 7-38 months). Various wrist parameters, including the grip strength, range of wrist movements and degree of pain (visual analogue scales) were recorded and compared before and after surgery. The average fusion time was 2.3 months (range, 2-4 months). Neither non-union nor wound infection was found in any of the patients. By the sixth month postoperatively, the grip strength had reached an average of 32.49 ± 6.21 kg with a range of 22.3-39.7 kg, this being 80.8% of that found on the healthy side. The range of motion reached over 53.0% of that of the healthy side. Preoperatively and at 6 months postoperatively, the mean pain scores were (4.46 ± 1.27) and 1.31 ± 0.95, respectively, when resting (P < 0.05), and 7.00 ± 1.41 and 2.62 ± 1.26, respectively, when weight-bearing (P < 0.05). The mean value of the Krimmer wrist score was 79.2 (range, 64-84). The rate of excellent and fine results was 84.6% (11/13), being excellent in three cases, good in eight and fair in two. Four-corner arthrodesis using a four-corner arthrodesis concentrator of Ni-Ti memory alloy is an effective method for treating carpal collapse and preserving most wrist function.

Scaphoid Hemiresection and Arthrodesis of the Radiocarpal Joint

Radiocarpal arthritis is frequently the result of trauma and/or degenerative disease. The leading causes are malunited or nonunited fractures of the radius or scaphoid, radiocarpal or intercarpal dislocations or dissociations, or a form of primary osteoarthritis or inflammatory arthritis. Management focuses on reducing pain, increasing function, and preserving some degree of motion when possible. Total wrist arthrodesis remains the ultimate salvage procedure. Several surgical procedures attempt to preserve some motion including proximal row carpectomy; lunotriquetrocapitohamate (4-corner) or luno-capito-hamate (3-corner) fusion with scaphoid excision; radiolunate or radioscapholunate; and lunocapitate arthrodesis, and total wrist replacement arthroplasty. These have been used with various success rates. The choice of the procedure depends on which articulation(s) are diseased and which are spared. Motion-sparing procedures require healthy articular cartilage at the site of preserved motion. This paper described scaphoid hemiresection and arthrodesis of the radiocarpal joint, the SHARC procedure.

Surgical Simulations of Proximal Row Carpectomy and Scaphoid Excision, Four-Corner Fusion: Not a clinical study

Surgical Simulations of Proximal Row Carpectomy and Scaphoid Excision, Four-Corner Fusion: Not a clinical study

The Outcome of Scaphoid Excision and Four-Corner Arthrodesis for Advanced Carpal Collapse at a Minimum of Ten Years

Scaphoid excision and 4-corner arthrodesis is a salvage option for patients with advanced carpal collapse. This study aims to compare the clinical outcomes of 4-corner arthrodesis (FCA) at one year, 2 years, and a minimum of 10 years. A cohort study was performed of patients having scaphoid excision and FCA procedure by a single surgeon. Thirty-one of 35 recruited were followed up for 10 years. The mean patient age was 47 years. All patients had scaphoid excision and FCA, using bone graft and 3M Shapiro staples (3M, St Paul, MN). Patients were followed up prospectively at one year, 2 years, and a minimum of 10 years after surgery by an independent observer. Three patients were lost to follow-up between the 2-year and 10-year assessments because they were untraceable, and one patient died at 7 years, without any further intervention. Before surgery, pain scores measured with a visual analog scale, range of wrist movement, grip and pinch strength, and scores from a self-assessment functional questionnaire were recorded prospectively. These measures were repeated at each time point, in addition to patient satisfaction scores measured on a visual analog scale. The pain scores decreased from a median preoperative score of 6/10 to 0/10 at one year. Grip strength did not change significantly. Wrist flexion decreased significantly after surgery, by an average of 22%. The average patient-reported satisfaction score was 8/10. There was no significant change in pain, wrist function, satisfaction, or arc of motion between one and 10 years. Two of 35 patients recruited had gone on to a total wrist arthrodesis for ongoing pain. The outcome of scaphoid excision and 4-corner arthrodesis is favorable at one year and does not deteriorate significantly between one and 10 years. There is a low rate of conversion to total wrist arthrodesis. Pain scores are reduced at the cost of reduced wrist flexion.

Mittelfristige Ergebnisse nach Skaphoidresektion und mediokarpaler Teilarthrodese unter Verwendung von K-Drähten bei fortgeschrittenem karpalen Kollaps

Successful four-corner fusion after scaphoid excision provides pain relief und preserves an acceptable movability of the wrist. However, this treatment option for advanced carpal collapse is not without complications, such as malunion, hardware impingement or incomplete correction of lunate extension. K-wires, staples, Herbert screws or, recently, locking plates are all possible fixation techniques after scaphoid excision. Only a few studies including mid-term results using K-wires are available. The aim of our study was to evaluate clinical and radiological mid-term results after scaphoid excision and four-corner arthrodesis using K-wires for stage II and III scapholunate and scaphoid non-union advanced collapse. Twelve wrists of 11 patients (4/SNAC II degrees, 3/SNAC III degrees, 0/SLAC II degrees, 5/SLAC III degrees) were treated operatively by scaphoid excision and four-corner arthrodesis. Four K-wires were used for osteosynthesis. After an average follow-up of 60.25 months, reexamination included subjective, objective and radiological values. Clinical examinations covered wrist motion, grip strength and pinch strength. These parameters were compared with preoperatively collected data and values of the unaffected side. The DASH score (disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand), Cooney score and the visual analogue scale (VAS 0-10) were analysed. Radiographic assessment of consolidation was verified by conventional X-rays. The carpal height was compared to the preoperative value by assessing the Youm index. All patients were satisfied, pain relief was reported and displayed on VAS from 7.4 (5-10) to 1.4 (0-5). The mean flexion-extension arc of 76.3 +/- 28.8 degrees (59.7% of the opposite wrist), preoperatively 75 +/- 17.3 degrees, was documented. The average total arc of ulnar and radial deviation was 37.5 +/- 9.2 degrees (51% of the opposite wrist). The preoperative value was 33.5 +/- 9.8 degrees. Further clinical evaluation yielded a mean grip strength of 39.3 kp (89.5% of the anaffected side) and pinch strength of 7.6 kp (81.7%). Total DASH score and Cooney score averaged 15 and 74.17 points, respectively. Osseus consolidation was observed radiologically in all patients already after 6 weeks. The Youm index decreased from 0.55 +/- 0.054 to 0.51 +/- 0.057. The radiolunate joint space remained unaltered in height. There were no infections. Except for wire removal, no additional surgery was necessary. Scaphoid excision and four-corner arthrodesis for advanced collapse of the wrist enjoy great satisfaction by the patients, with a high degree of pain reduction. This method shows persistent strength and movability in mid-term-results. Compared to alternative fixation techniques, the use of K-wires is a low-risk and low-cost treatment option, although removal of the K-wires is commonly necessary.

Clinical Outcomes of Scaphoid and Triquetral Excision With Capitolunate Arthrodesis Versus Scaphoid Excision and Four-Corner Arthrodesis

Clinical Outcomes of Scaphoid and Triquetral Excision With Capitolunate Arthrodesis Versus Scaphoid Excision and Four-Corner Arthrodesis

High Fusion Rates with Circular Plate Fixation for Four-corner Arthrodesis of the Wrist

Scaphoid excision and four-corner fusion is commonly performed to reconstruct advanced scapholunate collapse and scaphoid nonunion with collapse. Metallic plates were introduced for achieving fixation of the four carpal bones. Although the developer reported high rates of fusion, several other early reports of circular plate fixation suggest higher complication rates and inferior outcomes compared with traditional fixation techniques. To clarify the controversy in the literature we determined the fusion rates, complications, and functional outcomes of patients having circular plate fixation for four-corner fusion. We retrospectively reviewed 15 patients treated for radioscaphoid arthritis with four-corner fusion using circular plate fixation. The minimum followup was 11 months (mean, 22 months; range, 11-39 months). Radiographic union was achieved by all 15 patients. There was only one postoperative complication. ROM was 71% and grip strength was 78% of the opposite normal side. Our results compare favorably with those using traditional fixation techniques. ROM measurements seem superior to those reported in the literature. Level IV, therapeutic study. See Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Clinical Outcomes of Scaphoid and Triquetral Excision With Capitolunate Arthrodesis Versus Scaphoid Excision and Four-Corner Arthrodesis

To compare the clinical outcomes of scaphoid and triquetral excision combined with capitolunate arthrodesis versus 4-corner (capitate, hamate, lunate, triquetrum) intercarpal arthrodesis. We retrospectively identified 50 patients with scapholunate advanced collapse wrist changes who had 4-corner arthrodesis. Thirty-four patients were able to return and complete all follow-up evaluations. Patient demographics were similar between the 2 groups. Follow-up evaluation included radiographs, wrist range of motion (flexion-extension, radial-ulnar deviation, and pronation-supination); grip strength; visual analog scale (VAS); and Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) questionnaire. Complications of nonunion, hardware migration, conversion to wrist arthrodesis or arthroplasty, and pisotriquetral arthritis were recorded. Sixteen patients had capitolunate arthrodesis, and 18 patients had a 4-corner arthrodesis. There was no statistical difference in radial-ulnar deviation, pronation-supination, grip strength, VAS, or DASH scores between groups. There was a slight increase in flexion-extension in the 4-corner group. There were 2 nonunions in the 4-corner group and none in the capitolunate group. Five patients in the capitolunate group required screw removal secondary to migration. Three patients in the 4-corner group required a subsequent pisiform excision. Capitolunate arthrodesis compares favorably to 4-corner arthrodesis at an average 3-year follow-up in this series with respect to range of motion, grip strength, DASH scores, and VAS. Advantages of capitolunate arthrodesis include a lessened need for bone graft harvesting while maintaining a similarly low nonunion rate, easier reduction of the lunate following triquetral excision, and avoiding subsequent symptomatic pisotriquetral arthritis. Screw migration, however, remains a concern with this technique. Therapeutic III.

Long-term results of lunocapitate arthrodesis with scaphoid excision for SLAC and SNAC wrists

When treating the degenerative arthritis that follows scapholunate instability or scaphoid pseudarthrosis, excision of the scaphoid must be combined with a stabilisation of the midcarpal joint. Two alternatives have been proposed for that purpose: fusing the lunate, triquetrum, capitate and hamate (four corner fusion), 4CF; or limiting the arthrodesis to the lunate and capitate, preserving or excising the triquetrum. Previous reports have attributed a high level of complications to lunocapitate arthrodesis, mainly in respect of nonunion. We have reviewed 17 patients who had been treated with a lunocapitate fusion, after an 8 to 12-year follow-up period, and found similar results compared with 4CF, even with a major degree of motion in ulnar-radial deviation. Recent work on the innervation of the radiotriquetral ligaments has given relevance to the preservation of lunotriquetral motion in maintaining proprioception. Also if the triquetrum is excised to gain more motion, the proprioceptive role of the radiotriquetral ligaments is compromised.

Effect of scaphoid and triquetrum excision after limited stabilisation on cadaver wrist movement

This study assessed the effect of excision of the scaphoid and triquetrum on the range of motion of the embalmed cadaver wrist joint after midcarpal stabilisation. The range of motion was measured in 12 cadaver wrists before and after stabilisation of the joints between the lunate, capitate, triquetrum and hamate. This was measured again following resection of the scaphoid and then the triquetrum. Scaphoid excision after four-corner stabilisation increased the radioulnar (RU) arc by 12 degrees and the flexion-extension (F-E) arc by 10 degrees. Subsequent excision of the triquetrum, to produce a three-corner stabilisation, further increased the RU arc by 7 degrees and the F-E arc by 6 degrees. Three-corner stabilisation with excision of scaphoid and triquetrum improved wrist motion in embalmed cadavers.

Range of Motion Effects of Distal Pole Scaphoid Excision and Triquetral Excision After Radioscapholunate Fusion: A Cadaver Study

Radioscapholunate (RSL) fusion is an effective surgical procedure for the treatment of isolated radiocarpal arthritis. Although functional wrist motion is typically preserved through the midcarpal joint, many patients are still frustrated by postoperative limitations. The purpose of this study was to evaluate motion of cadaver wrists after simulated RSL fusion with excision of the distal pole of the scaphoid and the triquetrum. Ten fresh-frozen cadaver upper extremities were mounted on a custom testing apparatus after isolation of the flexor carpi radialis, flexor carpi ulnaris, extensor carpi radialis longus, and extensor carpi ulnaris tendons. Sequential loading of these tendons resulted in flexion, extension, radial, and ulnar deviation. We subsequently measured range of motion with the use of digital photography. All specimens were tested in 4 states: intact (normal), RSL fusion (simulated), RSL fusion with distal scaphoid pole excision, and RSL fusion with distal scaphoid pole and triquetrum excision. The results were statistically analyzed using a repeated measures analysis of variance. Range of motion decreased to 39% to 46% of normal for flexion and extension and 65% to 71% of normal for radial and ulnar deviation after simulated RSL fusion. The addition of distal pole of scaphoid excision resulted in flexion and extension returning to 72% to 79% of normal, and radial and ulnar deviation returning to 84% to 89% of normal. Excision of the triquetrum further increased flexion and extension to 87% to 97% of normal, and radial and ulnar deviation to 119% to 137% of normal. The combination of triquetral and distal scaphoid pole excision after RSL fusion improves wrist motion to levels close to normal in the cadaver model.

Proximal Row Carpectomy vs Four Corner Fusion for Scapholunate (Slac) or Scaphoid Nonunion Advanced Collapse (Snac) Wrists: A Systematic Review of Outcomes

Proximal row carpectomy (PRC) and scaphoid excision with four-corner fusion (4CF) are common motion-preserving, salvage procedures for the treatment of wrists with scaphoid nonunion (SNAC) or scapholunate advanced collapse (SLAC). A systematic review was undertaken to clarify controversies regarding which of these procedures has the better outcome. We collated 52 articles that examine outcomes for SNAC or SLAC patients undergoing PRC or 4CF. Although the lack of unbiased trials must be acknowledged, this systematic review confirms that both procedures give improvements in pain and subjective outcome measures for patients with symptomatic and appropriately staged SLAC or SNAC wrists. PRC may provide better postoperative range of movement and lacks the potential complications specific to 4CF (nonunion, hardware issues and dorsal impingement). However, the risk of subsequent osteoarthritis is significantly higher in PRC patients despite the majority being asymptomatic at the time of review. Grip strength, pain relief and subjective outcomes are similar in both treatment groups.

Biomechanical Effect of Triquetral and Scaphoid Excision on Simulated Midcarpal Arthrodesis in Cadavers

To examine the biomechanical effects of triquetral and scaphoid excision on wrist motion and radiolunate contact characteristics in a cadaveric model after simulated 4-corner arthrodesis with rigid internal fixation. Ten fresh-frozen cadaveric upper extremities were studied. For all surgical manipulations, the motion was measured and contact characteristics were assessed using ultralow prescale pressure-sensitive film. Compared with the intact specimen, simple 4-corner arthrodesis with scaphoid retention led to a significant decrease in flexion (-23%), extension (-69%), radial deviation (-129%), and ulnar deviation (-25%), but no significant change in radiolunate contact characteristics. After 4-corner arthrodesis with scaphoid excision, there was a significant increase in radial deviation (+213%) without significant change in radiolunate contact characteristics, but average radial deviation was still less than in the intact specimen. After further excision of the triquetrum, radial deviation increased significantly (+238%), to a mean value 5% greater than that of the intact state, but at the cost of a significant increase in mean radiolunate contact pressure (+44% compared to the intact state). When performing 4-corner arthrodesis, scaphoid and triquetrum excision may improve motion at the cost of increased mean radiolunate contact pressure.

Scaphoid Excision and Four-Corner Arthrodesis

Summary: This review article highlights the indications, technique, and summary results of scaphoid excision and 4-corner arthrodesis for scapholunate advanced collapse and scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse. Technically important tips for successful outcomes are presented.

RADIOSCAPHOLUNATE ARTHRODESIS — A PROSPECTIVE STUDY

The purpose of this prospective study was to evaluate pain levels, range of motion, patient activity and satisfaction after radioscapholunate (RSL) arthrodesis. This was in association with distal scaphoid excision and complete resection of the triquetrum. The non-union rate for radioscapholunate arthrodesis was examined and the results compared with previous studies. Twenty-three patients (14 males and nine females) with an average age of 47 (range 26-73) years underwent RSL fusion for post-traumatic osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis and Kienböck's disease of the lunate with a mean follow-up of 32 (range 13-70) months. The absolute prerequisite for any of these groups of patients was a functional midcarpal joint which was assessed pre-operatively with radiographs and intra-operatively prior to RSL fusion. The average flexion to extension motion changed from 66 degrees to 57 degrees . The ulnoradial range of motion also increased to 43 degrees from a pre-operative value of 22 degrees . The patients visual analogue pain scores reduced from an average of 64 to 28 (p = 0.01). Nineteen patients had no restriction in activity and all but one was satisfied with the outcome. All patients remained in full time employment with ten returning to some form of sport. RSL fusion with excision of the distal pole of the scaphoid and the entire triquetrum led to minimal reduction in the flexion-extension arc of motion and an increase in the ulnoradial arc. There was also good pain relief and maintenance of a patient's function. Memory staples are also an effective method of securing fusion in the wrist obtaining similar results to that seen in forefoot surgery.

ULNAR-SIDED WRIST PAIN AFTER FOUR-CORNER FUSION IN A PREVIOUSLY-ASYMPTOMATIC ULNAR POSITIVE WRIST: A CASE REPORT

Scaphoid excision and four-corner fusion is one of the treatment choices for patients who have stage II or III SLAC (scapholunate advanced collapse)/SNAC (scaphoid non-union advanced collapse) wrist arthritis. We report a case of ulnar-sided wrist pain which occurred after four-corner fusion for stage II SNAC wrist with a previously-asymptomatic ulnar positive variance, and was successfully treated by ulnar shortening osteotomy. This case highlights a possible coincidental pathology of the ulnocarpal joint in the setting of post-traumatic radiocarpal arthrosis.

Four-Corner Arthrodesis Using a Circular Plate and Distal Radius Bone Grafting: A Consecutive Case Series

Four-corner arthrodesis with scaphoid excision has been shown to be an acceptable method for treating wrist degenerative changes. Some recent studies have identified higher complication rates when circular plates are used. This study examined a consecutive case series with defined technique for outcome and complications. A retrospective assessment was performed in a consecutive cohort of 28 patients who underwent a standardized 4-corner arthrodesis with a 2nd-generation circular plate and distal radius bone grafting for a diagnosis of scapholunate advanced collapse, scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse, or midcarpal arthrosis. Complete data were obtained for 26 of the patients and partial data for the other 2. Follow-up examination included visual analog scale and activity scores, work status, posteroanterior and lateral radiographs, bone union status, grip strength, range of motion, and complications. Average follow-up was 46 months. Range of motion averaged 45% of the uninjured side (average extension, 35 degrees; average flexion, 26 degrees). Grip strength averaged 82% of the uninjured side. The mean visual analog scale pain and activity scores were 2.3/10 and 2.4/10. Only 1 patient required job modification because of wrist impairment. Radiographs demonstrated union of the primary capitolunate fusion mass in all of the cases. There was 1 case of probable but not certain peritriquetral nonunion and 1 case of asymptomatic loss of radiolunate joint space; in terms of hardware, there was screw back-out (of 1 screw) in 1 case the plate broke in 1 case. Two patients underwent reoperation, one for radial styloid impingement pain and the other for lack of flexion. Despite recent reports indicating a high nonunion rate with plate fixation, standardized 4-corner arthrodesis using a recessed, dorsal circular plate and distal radius bone grafting produced excellent and reproducible results in this consecutive series. Notably, there was no development of secondary arthritic changes at the radiolunate joint, indicating a reasonable durability to the procedure. Optimal results require exacting technique with quality bone graft.