Scanning Tunneling Microscopy Break Junction Research Articles

Recent Advances in Single-Molecule Sensors Based on STM Break Junction Measurements

Single-molecule recognition and detection with the highest resolution measurement has been one of the ultimate goals in science and engineering. Break junction techniques, originally developed to measure single-molecule conductance, recently have also been proven to have the capacity for the label-free exploration of single-molecule physics and chemistry, which paves a new way for single-molecule detection with high temporal resolution. In this review, we outline the primary advances and potential of the STM break junction technique for qualitative identification and quantitative detection at a single-molecule level. The principles of operation of these single-molecule electrical sensing mainly in three regimes, ion, environmental pH and genetic material detection, are summarized. It clearly proves that the single-molecule electrical measurements with break junction techniques show a promising perspective for designing a simple, label-free and nondestructive electrical sensor with ultrahigh sensitivity and excellent selectivity.

Photoconductance from the Bent-to-Planar Photocycle between Ground and Excited States in Single-Molecule Junctions.

Single-molecule conductance measurements for 9,14-diphenyl-9,14-dihydrodibenzo[a,c]phenazine (DPAC) may offer unique insight into the bent-to-planar photocycle between the ground and excited states. Herein, we employ DPAC derivative DPAC-SMe as the molecular prototype to fabricate single-molecule junctions using the scanning tunneling microscope break junction technique and explore photoconductance dependence on the excited-state structural/electronic changes. We find up to ∼200% conductance enhancement of DPAC-SMe under continuous 340 nm light irradiation than that without irradiation, while photoconductance disappears in the case where structural evolution of the DPAC-SMe is halted through macrocyclization. The in situ conductance modulation as pulsed 340 nm light irradiation is monitored in the DPAC-SMe-based junctions alone, suggesting that the photoconductance of DPAC-SMe stems from photoinduced intramolecular planarization. Theoretical calculations reveal that the photoinduced structural evolution brings about a significant redistribution of the electron cloud density, which leads to the appearance of Fano resonance, resulting in enhanced conductance through the DPAC-SMe-fabricated junctions. This work provides evidence of bent-to-planar photocycle-induced conductance differences at the single-molecule level, offering a tailored approach for tuning the charge transport characteristics of organic photoelectronic devices.

Dual Modulation of Single Molecule Conductance via Tuning Side Chains and Electric Field with Conjugated Molecules Entailing Intramolecular O•••S Interactions.

Herein, single‐molecule conductance studies of TBT1‐TBT6 which entails 1,4‐dithienylbenzene as the backbone and —SMe groups as the anchoring units, with the scanning tunneling microscope break junction (STM‐BJ) technique, are reported. The molecular conductance of TBT1 with intramolecular O•••S noncovalent interactions is enhanced by about one order of magnitude in comparison to their analogue TBT2 (which contains alkyl instead of alkoxy chains). By replacing the methoxy groups in TBT1 with extending alkoxy chains in TBT3, TBT4, and TBT5, the molecular backbones become twisted and as a consequence the single‐molecule conductance decreases gradually, showing that the intramolecular O•••S noncovalent interaction is influenced by the structural features of alkoxy chains. More importantly, the single‐molecule conductance of TBT3, TBT4, and TBT5 can be boosted by increasing the electric field applied to the molecular junctions. Remarkably, the conductance of TBT3, TBT4, and TBT5 can be reversibly modulated due to the conformational changes between twisted and planar ones by varying the electric field. These results demonstrate that molecules with intramolecular O•••S noncovalent interactions have the potential for in situ control of the electrical properties of molecular‐scale devices.

Transport Modulation Through Electronegativity Gating in Multiple Nitrogenous Circuits.

Investigating the correlations of electron transport between multiple channels shows vital promises for the design of molecule-scale circuits with logic operations. To control the electron transport through multiple channels, the modulation of electronegativity shows an effective frontier orbit control method with high universality to explore the interactions between transport channels. Here, two series of compounds with a single nitrogenous conductive channel (Sg) and dual-channels (Db) are designed to explore the influence of electronegativity on electron tunneling transport. Single-molecule conductance measured via the scanning tunneling microscope break junction technique (STM-BJ) reveals that the conductance of Db series is significantly suppressed as the electronegativity of nitrogen becomes negative, while the suppression on Sg is less obvious. Theoretical calculations confirm that the effect of electronegativity extends to a dispersive range of molecular frameworks owing to the delocalized orbital distribution from the dual-channel structure, resulting in a more significant conductance suppression effect than that on the single-channel. This study provides the experimental and theoretical potentials of electronegativity gating for molecular circuits.

Efficient Intermolecular Charge Transport in π-Stacked Pyridinium Dimers Using Cucurbit[8]uril Supramolecular Complexes.

Intermolecular charge transport through π-conjugated molecules plays an essential role in biochemical redox processes and energy storage applications. In this work, we observe highly efficient intermolecular charge transport upon dimerization of pyridinium molecules in the cavity of a synthetic host (cucurbit[8]uril, CB[8]). Stable, homoternary complexes are formed between pyridinium molecules and CB[8] with high binding affinity, resulting in an offset stacked geometry of two pyridiniums inside the host cavity. The charge transport properties of free and dimerized pyridiniums are characterized using a scanning tunneling microscope-break junction (STM-BJ) technique. Our results show that π-stacked pyridinium dimers exhibit comparable molecular conductance to isolated, single pyridinium molecules, despite a longer transport pathway and a switch from intra- to intermolecular charge transport. Control experiments using a CB[8] homologue (cucurbit[7]uril, CB[7]) show that the synthetic host primarily serves to facilitate dimer formation and plays a minimal role on molecular conductance. Molecular modeling using density functional theory (DFT) reveals that pyridinium molecules are planarized upon dimerization inside the host cavity, which facilitates charge transport. In addition, the π-stacked pyridinium dimers possess large intermolecular LUMO-LUMO couplings, leading to enhanced intermolecular charge transport. Overall, this work demonstrates that supramolecular assembly can be used to control intermolecular charge transport in π-stacked molecules.

Visualizing an Electrochemically Induced Radical Cation of Bipyridine at Au(111)/Ionic Liquid Interfaces toward a Single-Molecule Switch.

Room-temperature ionic liquids (RTILs) emerged as ideal solvents, and bipyridine as one of the most used ligands have been widely employed in surface science, catalysis, and molecular electronics. Herein, in situ shell-isolated nanoparticle-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SHINERS) and STM break junction (STM-BJ) technique has been employed to probe the electrochemical process of bipyridine at Au(111)/IL interfaces. It is interestingly found that these molecules undertake a redox process with a pair of well-defined reversible peaks in cyclic voltammograms (CVs). The spectroscopic evidence shows a radical cation generated with rising new Raman peaks related to parallel CC stretching of a positively charged pyridyl ring. Furthermore, these electrochemically charged bipyridine is also confirmed by electrochemical STM-BJ at the single-molecule level, which displays a binary conductance switch ratio of about 400% at the redox potentials. This present work offers a molecular-level insight into the pyridine-mediated reaction process and electron transport in RTILs.

Influence of a Coordinated Metal Center on Charge Transport through a Series of Porphyrin Molecular Junctions

Porphyrin-based molecular wires as promising candidates for nanoelectronic devices have attracted much attention. Therefore, it is fundamentally important to investigate structure–electrical properties involving such molecules. Herein, a series of 5-ethynyl-2,3-dihydrobenzo[b]thiophene-substituted free-metal porphyrins and metalloporphyrins have been synthesized. Rigid, structurally well-defined, and highly conjugated porphyrin-based molecular wires offer a good platform to explore the impact of coordinated metal ions (Cu, Fe, and Zn) on charge transport at a single-molecule scale. Using the scanning tunneling microscope break-junction (STM-BJ) technique, it is found that single-molecule conductance can change by nearly 500% when the central coordinated metal ions are changed. The theoretically simulated energy-dependent transmission spectra reveal that the spin state of FeTPP can tune charge transport at E = EF, and transmission coefficient T(E) is well correlated with the experimental observation. Our work proves a pronounced metal ion effect on charge transport through a porphyrin plane, providing guidance to design high-performance porphyrin-based nanodevices.

A one-pot synthesis of oligo(arylene–ethynylene)-molecular wires and their use in the further verification of molecular circuit laws

A convenient two-step, one-pot synthesis of oligo(arylene–ethynylene) (OAE) type molecular wires in yields of up to 70% via in situ desilylation of protected bis(alkynes) Me3SiC≡CArC≡CSiMe3 (Ar = 2,5-thienyl, 1,4-naphthylene, 9,10-anthrylene) and subsequent Sonogashira cross-coupling with S-(4-iodophenyl) ethanethiolate, 4-iodothioanisole, or 5-bromo-3,3-dimethyl-2,3-dihydrobenzo[b]thiophene is described. The in situ desilylation avoids the manipulation of the sensitive terminal dialkynes (HC≡CArC≡CH), whilst the general approach presented has some advantages over alternative synthetic strategies based on coupling of aryl dihalides (XArX) by avoiding the multi-step preparation and purification of the terminal alkynes S-(4-ethynylphenyl) ethanethiolate, 4-ethynylthioanisole and 5-ethynyl 3,3-dimethyl-2,3-dihydrobenzo[b]thiophene. The molecular conductance of the resulting thiolate or thioether functionalised OAE molecular wires has been determined using scanning tunneling microscope break junction (STM-BJ) methods. The trends in molecular conductance do not track simply with the degree of aromaticity of the molecular core despite the rather similar molecular lengths. Rather, the STM-BJ data are better correlated with the nature of the anchor group, highlighting the important role of electrode–molecule coupling on electron transport in a molecular junction. The experimental conductance data are in good agreement with recently described quantum circuit rules, further highlighting the potential for these relationships to be used as predictive tools in molecular electronics research.

Substituent-mediated quantum interference toward a giant single-molecule conductance variation

Quantum interference (QI) in single molecular junctions shows a promising perspective for realizing conceptual nanoelectronics. However, controlling and modulating the QI remains a big challenge. Herein, two-type substituents at different positions of meta-linked benzene, namely electron-donating methoxy (–OMe) and electron-withdrawing nitryl (–NO2), are designed and synthesized to investigate the substituent effects on QI. The calculated transmission coefficients T(E) indicates that –OMe and –NO2 could remove the antiresonance and destructive quantum interference (DQI)-induced transmission dips at position 2. –OMe could raise the antiresonance energy at position 4 while –NO2 groups removes the DQI features. For substituents at position 5, both of them are nonactive for tuning QI. The conductance measurements by scanning tunneling microscopy break junction show a good agreement with the theoretical prediction. More than two order of magnitude single-molecule conductance on/off ratio could be achieved at the different positions of –NO2 substituent groups at room temperature. The present work proves chemical substituents can be used for tuning QI features in single molecular junctions, which provides a feasible way toward realization of high-performance molecular devices.

Regio- and Steric Effects on Single Molecule Conductance of Phenanthrenes

Here, six phenanthrene (the smallest arm-chair graphene nanoribbon) derivatives with dithiomethyl substitutions at different positions as the anchoring groups were synthesized. Scanning tunneling microscopy break junction technique was used to measure their single molecule conductances between gold electrodes, which showed a difference as much as 20-fold in the range of ∼10-2.82 G0 to ∼10-4.09 G0 following the trend of G2,7 > G3,6 > G2,6 > G1,7 > G1,6 > G1,8. DFT calculations agree well with this measured trend and indicate that the single molecule conductances are a combination of energy alignment, electronic coupling, and quantum effects. This significant regio- and steric effect on the single molecule conductance of phenanthrene model molecules shows the complexity in the practice of graphene nanoribbons as building blocks for future carbon-based electronics in one hand but also provides good conductance tunability on the other hand.

Tracking Confined Reaction Based on Host-Guest Interaction Using Single-Molecule Conductance Measurement.

The host-guest interaction acts as an essential part of supramolecular chemistry, which can be applied in confined reaction. However, it is challenging to obtain the dynamic process during confined reactions below micromolar concentrations. In this work, a new method is provided to characterize the dimerization process of the guest 1,2-bis(4-pyridinyl) ethylene in host cucurbit[8]curil using scanning tunneling microscope-break junction (STM-BJ) technique. The guest reaction kinetics is quantitatively by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and in situ single-molecule junctions. It is found that in the single-molecule conductance measurements, the electrical signals of the reactants with a concentration as low as 5× 10-6 m are clearly detected, and the reaction kinetics at micromolar concentrations are further obtained. However, in NMR measurements, the characteristic peak signal of the reactants is undetectable when the concentration of the reactants is lower than 0.5× 10-3 m and it cannot be quantified. In addition, the strong electric field from the nanogap accelerates the reaction. This work reveals that single-molecule STM-BJ techniques are more sensitive for tracking confined reactions than that by NMR techniques and can be used to study effect of extremely strong electric field on kinetics.

Mechanically Induced Switching between Two Discrete Conductance States: A Potential Single-Molecule Variable Resistor.

The fabrication of solid-state single-molecule switches with high on-off conductance ratios has been proposed to advance conventional technology in areas such as molecular electronics. Herein, we employed the scanning tunneling microscope break junction (STM-BJ) technique to modulate conductance in single-molecule junctions using mechanically induced stretching. Compound 1a possesses two dihydrobenzothiophene (DHBT) anchoring groups at the opposite ends linked with rigid alkyne side arms to form a gold-molecule-gold junction, while 1b contains 4-pyridine-anchoring groups. The incorporation of ferrocene into the backbone of each compound allows rotational freedom to the cyclopentadienyl (Cp) rings to give two distinct conductance states (high and low) for each. Various control experiments and suspended junction compression/retraction measurements indicate that these high- and low-conductance plateaus are the results of conformational changes within the junctions (extended and folded states) brought about by mechanically induced stretching. A high-low switching factor of 42 was achieved for 1a, whereas an exceptional conductance ratio in excess of 2 orders of magnitude (205) was observed for 1b. To the best of our knowledge, this is the highest experimental on-off conductance switching ratio for a single-molecule junction exploiting the mechanically induced STM-BJ method. Computational studies indicated that the two disparate conductance states observed for 1a and 1b result from mechanically induced conformational changes due to an interplay between conductance and the dihedral angles associated with the electrode-molecule interfaces. Our study reveals the structure-function relationship that determines conductance in such flexible and dynamic systems and promotes the development of a single-molecule variable resistor with high on-off switching factors.

Single-Molecule Charge-Transport Modulation Induced by Steric Effects of Side Alkyl Chains.

The experimental investigation of side-chain effects on intramolecular charge transport in π-conjugated molecules is essential but remains challenging. Herein, the dependence of intra-molecular conductance on the nature of branching alkyl chains is investigated through a combination of the scanning tunneling microscope break junction (STM-BJ) technique and density functional theory. Three thiophene-flanked diketopyrrolopyrrole (DPP) derivatives with different branching alkyl chains (isopentane, 3-methylheptane, and 9-methylnonadecane) are used with phenylthiomethyl groups as the anchoring groups. The results of single-molecule conductance measurements show that as the alkyl chain becomes longer, the torsional angles between the aromatic rings increase due to steric crowding, and therefore, the molecular conductance of DPP decreases due to reduction in conjugation. Both theoretical simulations and 1 H NMR spectra demonstrate that the planarity of the DPPs is directly reduced after introducing longer branching alkyl chains, which leads to a reduced conductance. This work indicates that the effect of the insulating side chain on the single-molecule conductance cannot be neglected, which should be considered for the design of future organic semiconducting materials.

A single-molecule conductance study on the rotational isomers of a hexaarylbenzene derivative carrying dipolar rotating units

Using a scanning tunneling microscopy-break junction (STM-BJ) technique, we evaluated the single-molecule conductance of stable but interconvertible two rotational isomers of a hexaarylbenzene derivative featuring dipolar rotatable difluorophenyl units and tripodal thiol groups. The STM-BJ measurements of a configuration of single-molecule junction, formed between a Au-STM tip and a Au(111)/mica substrate covered with the hexaarylbenzene molecule, showed that the conductance behaviors of the rotational isomers are different from one another. This result takes a step forward in our goal of developing single-molecule switching/memory systems driven by electric fields.

Single Dynamic Covalent Bond Tailored Responsive Molecular Junctions.

Responsive molecular devices are one of the core units for molecular electronics, and dynamic covalent bonds (DCBs) provide the opportunity for the fabrication of responsive molecular devices. Herein we employ a single dynamic acyl hydrazone bond to fabricate tailored molecular devices using the scanning tunneling microscopy break-junction technique (STM-BJ) and the eutectic Ga-In technique (EGaIn). We found that the single-DCB-tailored molecular devices exhibited acid-base and/or photo-thermal response with three well-defined molecular conductance states. The reversible switching has the ON/OFF ratio of ≈10 between each state for single-molecule junctions and ≈3 for the SAMs-based molecular junctions. Combined with the density functional theory calculations, we revealed that the multiple conductance states of these molecular junctions originate from the dynamic acyl hydrazone bond exchange and C=N isomerization. Our work opens the avenue towards the design of tailored single-molecule electrical devices by implanting dynamic covalent bonds in molecular architectures.

Heteroatom Effects on Quantum Interference in Molecular Junctions: Modulating Antiresonances by Molecular Design.

Controlling charge transport through molecular wires by utilizing quantum interference (QI) is a growing topic in single-molecular electronics. In this article, scanning tunneling microscopy-break junction techniques and density functional theory calculations are employed to investigate the single-molecule conductance properties of four molecules that have been specifically designed to test extended curly arrow rules (ECARs) for predicting QI in molecular junctions. Specifically, for two new isomeric 1-phenylpyrrole derivatives, the conductance pathway between the gold electrodes must pass through a nitrogen atom: this novel feature is designed to maximize the influence of the heteroatom on conductance properties and has not been the subject of prior investigations of QI. It is shown, experimentally and computationally, that the presence of a nitrogen atom in the conductance pathway increases the effect of changing the position of the anchoring group on the phenyl ring from para to meta, in comparison with biphenyl analogues. This effect is explained in terms of destructive QI (DQI) for the meta-connected pyrrole and shifted DQI for the para-connected isomer. These results demonstrate modulation of antiresonances by molecular design and verify the validity of ECARs as a simple “pen-and-paper” method for predicting QI behavior. The principles offer new fundamental insights into structure–property relationships in molecular junctions and can now be exploited in a range of different heterocycles for molecular electronic applications, such as switches based on external gating, or in thermoelectric devices.

Single-Molecule Junctions with Highly Improved Stability

Single-molecule junctions (SMJs) have been fabricated using layers generated by diazonium electroreduction. This process creates a C-Au covalent bond between the molecule and the electrode. Rigid oligomers of variable length, based on porphyrin derivatives in their free base or cobalt complex forms, have been grafted on the surface. The conductance of the oligomers has been studied by a scanning tunneling microscopy break junction (STM-bj) technique and G(t) measurements, and the lifetime of the SMJs has been investigated. The conductance histograms indicate that charge transport in the porphyrins is relatively efficient and influenced by the presence of the cobalt center. With both systems, random telegraph G(t) signals are easily recorded, showing SMJ on/off states. The SMJs then stabilize and exhibit a surprisingly long lifetime around 10 s, and attenuation plots, obtained by both G(t) and STM-bj measurements, give identical values. This work shows that highly stable SMJs can be prepared using a diazonium grafting approach.

An Enhanced Electrode via Coupling with a Conducting Molecule to Extend Interfacial Reactions

AbstractAn electron conductive matrix, or collector, facilitates electron transport in an electrochemical device. It is stationary and does not change during the entire operation once it is built. The interface of this matrix and an electrode is constructed at a 2D level at the micro‐scale, and naturally limits the breadth and depth of electrochemical reactions. Herein, the idea of an enhanced electrode coupled with a conducting molecule that can extend interfacial reactions is first introduced. With a spatialized interspace, this electrode can change the present understanding of the electrode process and opens up a new realm of electrode‐based reaction chemistry. A lithium–sulfur (Li–S) battery is used as the target for implementing the enhanced electrode owing to the complex multi‐electron reaction. Through the interaction of π–π stacking between graphite‐based carbon and iron (II) phthalocyanine (FePc), soluble FePc can be decorated on the surface of an electrode that has the capability of transporting electrons. The scanning tunneling microscope break junction characterization and density functional theory indicate that FePc has a strong molecular electronic conductivity. The reactants obtain electrons more easily from the conducting molecule than from the collector directly. As a result, the performance of the corresponding Li–S battery considerably improves.

Revealing Supramolecular Interactions and Electron Transport in Single Molecular Junctions of Cucurbit[n]uril

AbstractProbing binding interaction and electron transport of supramolecules bridging metal electrodes are crucial to the design and construction of supramolecular electronic devices. Herein, scanning tunneling microscope break junction technique is employed to form single molecular junctions of cucurbit[n]uril (CB[n]) and their conductance is measured. It is found that the electrostatic interactions of the carbonyl portals contribute to form the molecular junctions of CB[n] family. As the number of the terminal carbonyl groups increases, the single‐molecule conductance linearly decreases as CB[5] > CB[6] > CB[7], which arise from the different interfacial coupling. This conductance order is also further confirmed by calculated energy‐dependent transmission coefficient T(E). The present work provides a single‐molecule level picture of supramolecular interactions and electron transport of CB[n] for the future design of nanodevices using supramolecular assemblies.

Quantum interference enhanced thermopower in single-molecule thiophene junctions

Quantum interference (QI) effects, which offer unique opportunities to widely manipulate the charge transport properties in the molecular junctions, will have the potential for achieving high thermopower. Here we developed a scanning tunneling microscope break junction technique to investigate the thermopower through single-molecule thiophene junctions. We observed that the thermopower of 2,4-TP-SAc with destructive quantum interference (DQI) was nearly twice of 2,5-TP-SAc without DQI, while the conductance of the 2,4-TP-SAc was two orders of magnitude lower than that of 2,5-TP-SAc. Furthermore, we found the thermopower was almost the same by altering the anchoring group or thiophene core in the control experiments, suggesting that the QI effect is responsible for the increase of thermopower. The density functional theory (DFT) calculations are in quantitative agreement with the experimental data. Our results reveal that QI effects can provide a promising platform to enhance the thermopower of molecular junctions.