Abstract Extensive tin mining activities produce sand piles with high silica, leaving vast environmental and economic responsibilities. The circular economy implementation can address these problems by valorizing quartz sand as industrial sand. Therefore, the study assesses the quartz sand left over from tin mining and processing activities on Bangka Island to become a valuable product within the CPQvA Framework consisting of classification (C), potential utilization (P), quantity and viability (Qv), and application (A). The criteria comprise 12 weighted questions to define the criticality indices categorized as easy, moderate, and difficult. With complex purification technology, quartz sand can be used as silica sand for ceramics, foundry mould, refractory bricks, glass, and solar cells. The quantity is large and feasible for a factory scale with expensive investment and operational costs. The product performance shows good quality from a technical aspect. Due to impurities content and its complex purification technology, the valorization of quartz sand produces a difficult criticality index for the solar cells, a moderate criticality index for the glass and ceramics industry, and an easy criticality index for the glaze, refractory brick, and foundry mold industries. Therefore, proven and efficient purification technology is crucial for further research.