Introduction: Metacarpophalangeal (MCP) joint arthroplasty is a common treatment modality to correct ulnar drift, pain, and functional deficits in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, an autoimmune condition targeting the synovium of joints. While silicone MCP joint implants are susceptible to revision in the long term, there is a lack of literature discussing their early breakage. The present case illustrates silicone implant fracture only 10 weeks after MCP arthroplasty—the first instance in the literature to the authors’ knowledge. Materials and Methods: The patient is a 64-year-old female with stage 4 rheumatoid arthritis who underwent right index and middle finger MCP joint arthroplasties using 0-degree silicone implants, radial sagittal band imbrication on these digits, and right ring and small finger extensor tendon centralization at the MCP joint. Results: During the 10th postoperative week, the patient presented with atraumatic middle finger pain and ulnar deviation. Imaging revealed a right middle finger MCP implant fracture at the distal stem, which underwent successful revision using a 30-degree flexed implant and index and middle extensor tendon centralization. Discussion: Nineteen months after revision surgery, the patient continues to have no pain and an improved range of motion. Ultimately, we are hopeful that the flexed silicone implant will last the patient's lifetime.