Initiating Change in Highland Ethiopia: Causes and Consequences of Cultural Transformation. By Dena Freeman. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002. Pp. x, 180; 3 maps, 6 figures, 10 b/w photographs. $55.00. In this rich historical/ethnographic account of life in the Gamo Highlands of Southern Ethiopia-an area on which little anthropological work has been done-Dena Freeman poses the following ethnographic puzzle: In a society that practices both sacrificial and initiatory rituals, the former have remained relatively stable over the last hundred years, while the latter have undergone radical transformation (p. 1). The author seeks to explain why the two systems have evolved in such different ways. In so doing, she considers how the effect of political and economic integration of people in the newer parts of the Ethiopian state has sparked systemic and individualistic actions that have worked together to generate variation and change in politico-ritual forms. Gamo make animal and other food sacrifices to spirits who are believed to protect and guarantee the of the earth and its inhabitants. Failure to feed spirits can result in crop failure, sickness and conflicts (p. 66). Sacrifices are made by senior members of the community on behalf of their juniors. Thus, senior members are seen to be caretakers of the entire community, for it is only through their actions that the wellbeing of the community is ensured. Seniors accede to their roles through primogeniture as they assume the roles of household, segment, lineage, or clan head. In the initiatory system, individuals become halak'as for a given period of time, and in that role are said to herd the entire community (p. 84). Unlike the sacrificial system, men originally obtained their position as halak'as by sponsoring huge feasts for the community. Whereas in the nineteenth century (before the area was incorporated into the Ethiopian state), halak'as had more political power and actually passed laws, dealt with litigation, and made decisions about whether or not to go to war (p. 86), in more recent times their functions have shifted so that they are less involved in direct political leadership. However, their role in protecting the welfare of the community is maintained by observing prohibitions on their personal behavior; these prohibitions vary one community to another, but are generally associated with distancing the individual (and thus the community) from death and weakness and to associate him with success and fertility (p. 85). During the Derg regime (1974-1991), initiation of halak'as was prohibited as a potential threat to government control. However, Freeman finds that while one of her study sites, Doko Gembela, obeyed the edict and virtually stopped initiating halak'as, another site, Doko Masho continued its initiation practices. Freeman explains the different fate of initiation in the two communities by tracing the political and economic developments over the last two hundred years that have resulted in the splitting of what was a single Doko community into two separate communities with different dynamics. As they integrated with the Ethiopian state and with market forces, more men became traders and weavers in both communities, although at different rates. …
Read full abstract