RS Ophiuchi Research Articles

Interpretation of the light curve of gamma-ray emission from the 2021 outburst of the recurrent nova RS Ophiuchi

Nova outbursts take place in binary star systems comprising a white dwarf (WD) and either a low-mass Sun-like star (classical novae) or, a red giant. GeV gamma-ray emission has been detected from a dozen of classical novae and from one novae in symbiotic system (V407 Cyg) by Fermi-LAT. For classical novae, gamma-ray emission is generally thought to be related to internal shocks formed as fast outflow collides with the slow outflow. However, for V407 Cyg, the origin of the gamma-ray emission has been debated, as both internal shock and external shock, resulted from the collision between the nova ejecta and the ambient wind of the giant companion, were suggested to explain the gamma-ray data. Recently, bright GeV and TeV gamma-ray emission has been detected from a nova in symbiotic system, RS Ophiuchi, during its 2021 outburst, which shows a remarkably smooth power-law decay in time up to about one month after the outburst. We show that this temporal decay behavior can be interpreted as arising from an adiabatic external shock expanding in the red giant wind. In this interpretation, the gamma-rays are produced by shock-accelerated protons interacting with the dense wind through the hadronic process. We also derive the scaling relations for the decay slopes for both adiabatic and radiative nova shocks in the self-similar deceleration phase.

Shocks in the Outflow of the RS Oph 2021 Eruption Observed with X-Ray Gratings

The 2021 outburst of the symbiotic recurrent nova RS Oph was observed with the Chandra High Energy Transmission Gratings (HETG) on day 18 after optical maximum and with XMM-Newton and its Reflection Grating Spectrographs (RGS) on day 21, before the supersoft X-ray source emerged and when the emission was due to shocked ejecta. The absorbed flux in the HETG 1.3–31 Å range was 2.6 × 10−10 erg cm−2 s−1, three orders of magnitude lower than the γ-ray flux measured on the same date. The spectra are well fitted with two components of thermal plasma in collisional ionization equilibrium, one at a temperature ≃ 0.75 keV and the other at a temperature in the 2.5–3.4 keV range. With the RGS we measured an average flux of 1.53 × 10−10 erg cm−2 s−1 in the 5–35 Å range, but the flux in the continuum and especially in the lines in the 23–35 Å range decreased during the 50 ks RGS exposure by almost 10%, indicating short-term variability on a timescale of hours. The RGS spectrum can be fitted with three thermal components, respectively at plasma temperatures between 70 and 150 eV, 0.64 keV, and 2.4 keV. The post-maximum epochs of the exposures fall between those of two grating spectra observed in the 2006 eruption on days 14 and 26: they are consistent with a similar spectral evolution, but in 2021 cooling seems to have been more rapid. Iron is depleted in the ejecta with respect to solar values, while nitrogen is enhanced.

Radio interferometric imaging of RS Oph bipolar ejecta for the 2021 nova outburst

The recurrent nova and symbiotic binary RS Oph erupted again in August 2021 for its eighth known outburst. We observed RS Oph 34 days after the outburst at 5 GHz with the European VLBI Network (EVN). The radio image is elongated over the east–west direction for a total extension of about 90 mas (or about 240 AU at the Gaia DR3 distance d = 2.68−0.15+0.17 kpc), and shows a bright and compact central component coincident with the Gaia astrometric position, and two lobes east and west of it, expanding perpendicular to the orbital plane. By comparing with the evolution of emission-line profiles on optical spectra, we found the leading edge of the lobes to be expanding at ∼7550 km s−1, and i = 54° as the orbital inclination of the binary. The 2021 radio structure is remarkably similar to that observed following the 2006 eruption. The obscuring role of the density enhancement on the orbital plane (DEOP) is discussed in connection to the time-dependent visibility of the receding lobe in the background to the DEOP, and the origin of the triple-peaked profiles is traced to the ring structure formed by the nova ejecta impacting the DEOP.

Rise and fall of silicate dust in RS Ophiuchi following the 2006 eruption

ABSTRACT We present an analysis of archival Spitzer InfraRed Spectrograph (IRS) observations of the recurrent nova RS Ophiuchi obtained on several occasions, beginning about 7 months after the outburst in 2006. These data show atomic emission lines, absorption bands due to photospheric SiO, and the well-known silicate dust features at 9.7 and $18\, \mu$m. The dust emission, arising in the wind of the secondary star, is fitted by dusty models for mass-loss rates in the range 1.0–1.7 × 10−7 M⊙ yr−1. The silicate features are similar in profile to those seen in circumstellar environments of isolated late-type stars and some dusty symbiotic binaries, although the longer wavelength feature peaks at $17\, \mu$m, instead of the usual $18\, \mu$m, indicating peculiar grain properties. The dust features are variable, appearing stronger in 2006–2007 during outburst than in 2008–2009 when the system was in the quiescent state. This variability is attributed to changes in the ultraviolet output and the reformation of the accretion disc, although a decline in the mass-loss rate of the red giant secondary star could also play a role. Further observations, in the aftermath of the 2021 eruption, could provide a definitive conclusion.

7Be detection in the 2021 outburst of RS Oph

ABSTRACT The recurrent nova RS Oph underwent a new outburst on 2021 August 8, reaching a visible brightness of V = 4.8 mag. Observations of the 2021 outburst made with the high-resolution UVES spectrograph at the Kueyen-UT2 telescope at ESO-VLT in Paranal enabled detection of the possible presence of 7Be newly made in the thermonuclear runaway reactions. The 7Be yields can be estimated at N(7Be)/N(H) = 5.7 × 10−6, which are close to the lowest yields measured in classical novae so far. 7Be is short-lived and decays only into 7Li. By means of a spectrum taken during the nebular phase we estimated an ejected mass of ≈ 1.1 × 10−5 M⊙, providing an amount of ≈ 4.4 × 10−10 M⊙ of 7Li created in the 2021 event. Recurrent novae of the RS Oph type may synthesize slightly lower amounts of 7Li per event than classical novae, but occur 103 times more frequently. The recurrent novae fraction is in the range of 10–30 per cent and they could have contributed to the making of the 7Li that we observe today. The detection of 7Be in RS Oph provides further support to the recent suggestion that novae are the most effective source of 7Li in the Galaxy.

Fermi LAT Gamma-ray Detection of the Recurrent Nova RS Ophiuchi during its 2021 Outburst

We report the Fermi LAT γ-ray detection of the 2021 outburst of the symbiotic recurrent nova RS Ophiuchi. In this system, unlike classical novae from cataclysmic binaries, the ejecta from the white dwarf form shocks when interacting with the dense circumstellar wind environment of the red giant companion. We find the LAT spectra from 50 MeV to ∼20–23 GeV, the highest-energy photons detected in some subintervals, are consistent with π 0-decay emission from shocks in the ejecta as proposed by Tatischeff & Hernanz for its previous 2006 outburst. The LAT light curve displayed a fast rise to its peak >0.1 GeV flux of ≃6 × 10−6 ph cm−2 s−1 beginning on day 0.745 after its optically constrained eruption epoch of 2021 August 8.50. The peak lasted for ∼1 day and exhibited a power-law decline up to the final LAT detection on day 45. We analyze the data on shorter timescales at early times and found evidence of an approximate doubling of emission over ∼200 minutes at day 2.2, possibly indicating a localized shock-acceleration event. Comparing the data collected by the American Association of Variable Star Observers, we measured a constant ratio of ∼ 2.8 × 10−3 between the γ-ray and optical luminosities except for a ∼5×smaller ratio within the first day of the eruption likely indicating attenuation of γ rays by ejecta material and lower high-energy proton fluxes at the earliest stages of the shock development. The hard X-ray emission due to bremsstrahlung from shock-heated gas traced by the Swift-XRT 2–10 keV light curve peaked at day ∼6, later than at GeV and optical energies. Using X-ray derived temperatures to constrain the velocity profile, we find the hadronic model reproduces the observed >0.1 GeV light curve.

For how long are particles accelerated in shells of recurrent novae?

ABSTRACT Galactic novae are at present a well established class of γ-ray sources. We wonder for how long the mechanism of acceleration of electrons operates in the shells of novae. In order to put constraints on the time-scale of the electron acceleration, we consider a specific model for the injection and propagation of electrons within the shell of the recurrent nova RS Ophiuchi. We calculate the equilibrium spectra of electrons within the nova shell and the γ-ray fluxes produced by these electrons in the Comptonization of the soft radiation from the red giant within a nova binary system and also radiation from the nova photosphere. We investigate a two-component time-dependent model in which a spherically ejected nova shell propagates freely in the polar region of a nova binary system. However, the shell is significantly decelerated in the dense equatorial region of the binary system. We discuss the conditions under which electrons can produce γ-rays that might be detectable by present and/or future γ-ray observatories. It is concluded that freely expanding shells of novae in the optimal case (strongly magnetized shell and efficiency of acceleration of electrons of the order of 10 per cent) can produce TeV γ-rays within the sensitivity of the Cherenkov Telescope Array within 1–2 yr of explosion only. On the other hand, decelerated shells of novae have a chance to be detected during the whole recurrence period of RS Ophiuchi, i.e. ∼15 yr.

Study of 2021 outburst of the recurrent nova RS Ophiuchi: Photoionization and morphokinematic modelling

ABSTRACT We present the evolution of the optical spectra of the 2021 outburst of RS Ophiuchi (RS Oph) over about a month after the outburst. The spectral evolution is similar to the previous outbursts. Early spectra show prominent P Cygni profiles of hydrogen Balmer, Fe ii, and He i lines. The emission lines were very broad during the initial days, which later became narrower and sharper as the nova evolved. This is interpreted as the expanding shocked material into the winds of the red giant companion. We find that the nova ejecta expanded freely for ∼4 d, and afterwards, the shock velocity decreased monotonically with time as v ∝ t−0.6. The physical and chemical parameters associated with the system are derived using the photoionization code cloudy. The best-fitting cloudy model shows the presence of a hot central white dwarf source with a roughly constant luminosity of ∼1.00 × 1037 erg s−1. The best-fitting photoionization models yield absolute abundance values by number, relative to solar of He/H ∼1.4–1.9, N/H = 70–95, O/H = 0.60–2.60, and Fe/H ∼1.0–1.9 for the ejecta during the first month after the outburst. Nitrogen is found to be heavily overabundant in the ejecta. The ejected hydrogen shell mass of the system is estimated to be in the range of $3.54 - 3.83 \times 10^{-6}\, {\rm M}_{\odot }$. The 3D morphokinematic modelling shows a bipolar morphology and an inclination angle of i = 30° for the RS Oph binary system.

Flickering Returns as RS Oph Reestablishes Quiescent Conditions Following its 2021 Nova Outburst

RS Oph has persistently displayed flickering at optical wavelengths when observed away from its repeating nova outbursts. During the 2006 eruption the flickering disappeared, and this repeated during the recent 2021 event. We have been monitoring RS Oph looking for the reappearance of flickering at B-band following the 2021 outburst. The flickering was still absent (σ(B) < 0.002 mag) on day +210 (counted from nova optical maximum), appeared at σ(B) = 0.008 mag on day +224, and raised to σ(B) = 0.029 mag on day +250. On following dates the amplitude remained large, although fluctuating. The recovery of B-band quiescence brightness by RS Oph begun around day +225 and was completed by day +260. The parallel patterns followed by the rise in system brightness and the reappearance of flickering confirm the central role played in RS Oph by the return to pre-outburst conditions of the accretion disk and the refilling by the RG wind of the immediate circumstellar space.

The 2021 outburst of the recurrent nova RS Ophiuchi observed in X-rays by the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory: a comparative study

ABSTRACT On 2021 August 8, the recurrent nova RS Ophiuchi (RS Oph) erupted again, after an interval of 15.5 yr. Regular monitoring by the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory began promptly, on August 9.9 (0.37 d after the optical peak), and continued until the source passed behind the Sun at the start of November, 86 d later. Observations then restarted on day 197, once RS Oph emerged from the Sun constraint. This makes RS Oph the first Galactic recurrent nova to have been monitored by Swift throughout two eruptions. Here we investigate the extensive X-ray data sets between 2006 and 2021, as well as the more limited data collected by the European X-ray Observatory Satellite (EXOSAT) in 1985. The hard X-rays arising from shock interactions between the nova ejecta and red giant wind are similar following the last two eruptions. In contrast, the early supersoft source (SSS) in 2021 was both less variable and significantly fainter than in 2006. However, 0.3–1 keV light curves from 2021 reveal a 35 s quasi-periodic oscillation consistent in frequency with the 2006 data. The Swift X-ray spectra from 2021 are featureless, with the soft emission typically being well parametrized by a simple blackbody, while the 2006 spectra showed much stronger evidence for superimposed ionized absorption edges. Considering the data after day 60 following each eruption, during the supersoft phase the 2021 spectra are hotter, with smaller effective radii and lower wind absorption, leading to an apparently reduced bolometric luminosity. We explore possible explanations for the gross differences in observed SSS behaviour between the 2006 and 2021 outbursts.

Spectroscopic Signature of a Re-established Accretion Disk in Symbiotic-like Recurrent Nova RS Ophiuchi

A novel method is presented which can pin down the time the accretion disk re-established itself in the RS Oph system after it experienced a nova disruption. The method is based on the re-ionization of the ejecta by photoionization from the radiation released in the boundary layer from accretion.

Proton acceleration in thermonuclear nova explosions revealed by gamma rays

Classical novae are cataclysmic binary star systems in which the matter of a companion star is accreted on a white dwarf (WD). Accumulation of hydrogen in a layer eventually causes a thermonuclear explosion on the surface of the WD, brightening the WD to ~10^5 solar luminosities and triggering ejection of the accumulated matter.They provide extreme conditions required to accelerate particles, electrons or protons, to high energies. Here we present the detection of gamma rays by the MAGIC telescopes from the 2021 outburst of RS Ophiuchi (RS Oph), a recurrent nova with a red giant (RG) companion, that allowed us, for the first time, to accurately characterize the emission from a nova in the 60 GeV to 250 GeV energy range. The theoretical interpretation of the combined Fermi-LAT and MAGIC data suggests that protons are accelerated to hundreds of GeV in the nova shock. Such protons should create bubbles of enhanced Cosmic Ray density, on the order of 10 pc, from the recurrent novae.

Time-resolved hadronic particle acceleration in the recurrent nova RSOphiuchi.

Recurrent novae are repeating thermonuclear explosions in the outer layers of white dwarfs, due to the accretion of fresh material from a binary companion. The shock generated when ejected material slams into the companion star's wind can accelerate particles. We report very-high-energy (VHE; [Formula: see text]) gamma rays from the recurrent nova RSOphiuchi, up to 1 month after its 2021 outburst, observed using the High Energy Stereoscopic System (H.E.S.S.). The temporal profile of VHE emission is similar to that of lower-energy giga-electron volt emission, indicating a common origin, with a 2-day delay in peak flux. These observations constrain models of time-dependent particle energization, favoring a hadronic emission scenario over the leptonic alternative. Shocks in dense winds provide favorable environments for efficient acceleration of cosmic rays to very high energies.

Expanding Bipolar X-Ray Structure After the 2006 Eruption of RS Oph

Abstract We report on the detection and analysis of extended X-ray emission by the Chandra X-ray Observatory stemming from the 2006 eruption of the recurrent nova RS Oph. The extended emission was detected 1254 and 1927 days after the start of the 2006 eruption and is consistent with a bipolar flow oriented in the East–West direction of the sky with opening angles of approximately 70°. The length of both lobes appeared to expand from 1.″3 in 2009 to 2.″0 in 2011, suggesting a projected expansion rate of 1.1 ± 0.1 mas day−1 and an expansion velocity of 4600 km s−1 (D/2.4 kpc) in the plane of the sky. This expansion rate is consistent with previous estimates from optical and radio observations of material in a similar orientation. The X-ray emission does not show any evidence of cooling between 2009 and 2011, consistent with free expansion of the material. This discovery suggests that some mechanism collimates ejecta away from the equatorial plane, and that after that material passes through the red giant wind, it expands freely into the cavity left by the 1985 eruption. We expect similar structures to arise from the latest eruption and to expand into the cavity shaped by the 2006 eruption.

Recurring Nova RS Oph spectroscopic observation at Bosscha Observatory and ITERA Astronomical Observatory (IAO)

We report low and intermediate resolution spectra of the recurrent nova RS Oph taken at two observatories. A low resolution spectrum (R ≈ 1000) was taken at ITERA Astronomical Observatory (IAO) in Lampung by using 25 cm (f/8) RC Astrograph telescope equipped with a LISA Pack Spectrograph eight days after the outburst. Twenty intermediate spectra (R ≈ 5000) were taken on several consecutive nights using LHIRES III spectrograph attached to a 25 cm (f/10) Meade LX-200R telescope at Bosscha Observatory, Lembang. We identified significant change in the strength of atomic lines from low resolution spectrum compared to previous observations. A clear and distinct Balmer emission decrement can be seen from the spectrum. Our intermediate resolution spectroscopy revealed a variability of P-Cygni profile on a broad Hα line. The P-Cygni profile evolved and disappeared at recent observations. It is thought that there was a new shell formed after the outburst and later combined with the previous shell in the next days. From the broad Hα profile, we measured and found decreasement in expansion velocity during our observation. We estimated vexp = 2907.97 ± 64.14 km/s and vexp = 997.12 ± 8.18 km/s on 1.6440 and 22.729 days after the outburst, respectively.

AT 2019qyl in NGC 300: Internal Collisions in the Early Outflow from a Very Fast Nova in a Symbiotic Binary* †

Abstract Nova eruptions, thermonuclear explosions on the surfaces of white dwarfs (WDs), are now recognized to be among the most common shock-powered astrophysical transients. We present the early discovery and rapid ultraviolet (UV), optical, and infrared (IR) temporal development of AT 2019qyl, a recent nova in the nearby Sculptor Group galaxy NGC 300. The light curve shows a rapid rise lasting ≲1 day, reaching a peak absolute magnitude of M V = −9.2 mag and a very fast decline, fading by 2 mag over 3.5 days. A steep dropoff in the light curves after 71 days and the rapid decline timescale suggest a low-mass ejection from a massive WD with M WD ≳ 1.2 M ⊙. We present an unprecedented view of the early spectroscopic evolution of such an event. Three spectra prior to the peak reveal a complex, multicomponent outflow giving rise to internal collisions and shocks in the ejecta of an He/N-class nova. We identify a coincident IR-variable counterpart in the extensive preeruption coverage of the transient location and infer the presence of a symbiotic progenitor system with an O-rich asymptotic-giant-branch donor star, as well as evidence for an earlier UV-bright outburst in 2014. We suggest that AT 2019qyl is analogous to the subset of Galactic recurrent novae with red-giant companions such as RS Oph and other embedded nova systems like V407 Cyg. Our observations provide new evidence that internal shocks between multiple, distinct outflow components likely contribute to the generation of the shock-powered emission from such systems.

A light curve model of V2491 Cyg: Classical nova outburst on a cool and massive white dwarf

Abstract The classical nova V2491 Cyg was once suggested to be a recurrent nova. We have broadly reproduced the light curve of V2491 Cyg by a nova outburst model on a cold 1.36 M⊙ white dwarf (WD), which strongly suggests that V2491 Cyg is a classical nova outbursting on a cold very massive WD rather than a recurrent nova outbursting on a warmer WD like the recurrent nova RS Oph. In the long-term evolution of a cataclysmic binary, an accreting WD has settled to a thermal equilibrium state with the balance of gravitational energy release and neutrino loss. The central temperature of the WD is uniquely determined by the energy balance. The WD is hot (cold) for a high (low) mass accretion rate. We present the central temperatures, ignition masses, ignition radii, and recurrence periods for various WD masses and mass accretion rates. In a classical nova, which corresponds to a low mass accretion rate, the WD is cool and strongly degenerated and the ignition mass is large, which result in a strong nova outburst. In a recurrent nova, the WD is relatively warmer because of a high mass accretion rate and the outburst is relatively weaker. The gravitational energy release substantially contributes to the luminosity during the recurrent nova outbursts. We compare physical properties between classical novae and recurrent novae and discuss the essential differences between them.

The symbiotic recurrent nova V3890 Sgr: binary parameters and pre-outburst activity

ABSTRACT We present and analyse optical photometry and high-resolution Southern African Large Telescope spectra of the symbiotic recurrent nova V3890 Sgr at quiescence. The orbital period, P = 747.6 d, has been derived from both photometric and spectroscopic data. Our double-line spectroscopic orbits indicate that the mass ratio is q = Mg/MWD = 0.78 ± 0.05, and that the component masses are MWD ≈ 1.35 ± 0.13 M⊙ and Mg ≈ 1.05 ± 0.11 M⊙. The orbit inclination is ≈67−69○. The red giant is filling (or nearly filling) its Roche lobe, and the distance set by its Roche lobe radius, d ≈ 9 kpc, is consistent with that resulting from the giant pulsation period. The outburst magnitude of V3890 Sgr is then very similar to those of RNe in the Large Magellanic Cloud. V3890 Sgr shows remarkable photometric and spectroscopic activity between the nova eruptions with time-scales similar to those observed in the symbiotic recurrent novae T CrB and RS Oph and Z And-type symbiotic systems. The active source has a double-temperature structure that we have associated with the presence of an accretion disc. The activity would be then caused by changes in the accretion rate. We also provide evidence that V3890 Sgr contains a CO WD accreting at a high, ∼a few× 10−8 to 10−7 M⊙ yr−1, rate. The WD is growing in mass, and should give rise to a Type Ia supernova within ≲106 yr – the expected lifetime of the red giant.

Supersoft X-ray phases of recurrent novae as an indicator of their white dwarf masses

Abstract We have examined the optical/X-ray light curves of seven well-observed recurrent novae, V745 Sco, M31N 2008-12a, LMC N 1968, U Sco, RS Oph, LMC N 2009a, T Pyx, and one recurrent nova candidate LMC N 2012a. Six novae out of the eight show a simple relation that the duration of supersoft X-ray source (SSS) phase is 0.70 times the total duration of the outburst (= X-ray turnoff time), i.e., tSSS = 0.70 toff, the total duration of which ranges from 10 to 260 d. These six recurrent novae show a broad rectangular X-ray light curve shape, the first half-period of which is highly variable in the X-ray count rate. The SSS phase also corresponds to an optical plateau phase that indicates a large accretion disk irradiated by a hydrogen-burning white dwarf (WD). The two other recurrent novae, T Pyx and V745 Sco, show a narrow triangular-shaped X-ray light curve without an optical plateau phase. Their relations between tSSS and toff are rather different from the above six recurrent novae. We also present theoretical SSS durations for recurrent novae with various WD masses and stellar metallicities (Z = 0.004, 0.01, 0.02, and 0.05) and compare them with the observed durations of these recurrent novae. We show that SSS duration is a good indicator of WD mass in recurrent novae with a broad rectangular X-ray light curve shape.

Chandra High Energy Transmission Gratings Spectra of V3890 Sgr

Abstract The recurrent nova (RN) V3890 Sgr was observed during the seventh day after the onset of its most recent outburst, with the Chandra ACIS-S camera and High Energy Transmission Gratings. A rich emission line spectrum was detected, due to transitions of Fe-L and K-shell ions ranging from neon to iron. The measured absorbed flux is ≈10−10 erg cm−2 s−1 in the 1.4–15 Å range (0.77–8.86 keV). The line profiles are asymmetric, blueshifted, and skewed toward the blue side, as if the ejecta moving toward us are less absorbed than the receding ejecta. The full width at half-maximum of most emission lines is 1000–1200 km s−1, with some extended blue wings. The spectrum is thermal and consistent with a plasma in collisional ionization equilibrium with column density 1.3 × 1022 cm−2 and at least two components at temperatures of about 1 and 4 keV, possibly a forward and a reverse shock, or regions with differently mixed ejecta and a red giant wind. The spectrum is remarkably similar to the symbiotic RNe V745 Sco and RS Oph, but we cannot distinguish whether the shocks occurred at a distance of a few au from the red giant, or near the giant’s photosphere, in a high-density medium containing only a low mass. The ratios of the flux in lines of aluminum, magnesium, and neon relative to the flux in lines of silicon and iron probably indicate a carbon–oxygen white dwarf.