Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) and hydrogen persulfide (H2S2) are the simplest members of the peroxide and persulfide families, and both are signaling molecules that regulate several biological functions. Rotation about the O–O and S–S bonds impacts the strength of these molecules as H-bond donors or acceptors and tunes their polarity and stability by converting the polar equilibrium skewed structure (ϕHOOH ~ 112°, ϕHSSH ~ 91°) to the nonpolar less stable trans (ϕ = 180°) or the most polar and least stable cis (ϕ = 0°) conformers. The change in geometry in response to the structure and polarity of the microenvironment is an important feature that would influence how these molecules interact with or permeate through biological systems. Consistent with larger energy barriers for rotation about the S–S bond, quantum chemical calculations with MP2(full)/6–311++G(3df,3pd) reveal that when interacting with a single water, ethanol, or n-pentane molecule in the gas phase, the geometry of H2S2 is more rigid (ϕHSSH = 91 ± 3°) than that of H2O2 (ϕHOOH = 112 ± 8°). Molecular dynamics simulations of a single H2O2 or H2S2 in liquid water (ε = 80), ethanol (ε = 25), or n-pentane (ε = 2) reveal that, compared to the gaseous monomer, H2O2 maintains a more polar geometry in ethanol and water. Interestingly, the distribution of ϕHOOH significantly shifts towards the nonpolar conformation as solvent polarity decreases; the fraction of structures with ϕHOOH ≥ 160° is 0.10, 0.14, and 4.30% in water, ethanol, and n-pentane, respectively. The high-energy cis conformation of H2O2 was negligible in all solvents, especially in n-pentane. The equilibrium geometry of H2S2 is hardly influenced by solvent polarity and both cis and trans conformations are essentially absent in the three solvents. In contrast to rigid H2S2, H2O2 is thus a flexible molecule whose geometry depends on the environment polarity, a property that enables stabilizing H2O2 in different microenvironments and possibly plays a role in how biological systems discriminate between H2O2 and the rigid and polar close analog, H2O.