The tendency for teeth to return to their original rotated positions following orthodontic alignment is a vexing problem for orthodontists. The purpose of this investigation was to assay the clinical adaptability of a minor surgical procedure as an adjunct to retention of orthodontically rotated teeth. The maxillary second incisors of five mongrel dogs approximately 1 year of age were rotated orthodontically. Appliance therapy for a period of 35 to 42 days resulted in rotations of 16 to 95 degrees. Following these rotations, the free gingival fibers were incised on the labial and lingual surfaces of the right second incisors. The left side served as a nonsurgical control. Subsequent to the surgical transsection of the free gingival fibers, the rotated incisors of four of the animals were retained for 148 to 150 days. Approximately 6 weeks following removal of the retentive appliances, the animals were killed by electrocution. The total period of repair was 190 to 192 days. For comparison, a fifth animal was retained for 14 days following the surgical procedure and was killed 4 weeks postretention, with a total repair period of 42 days. Study casts of tooth positions taken before treatment, before retention, and following retention revealed that the greatest percentage of regression occurred within the first 18 hours in the control incisors and was at a ratio of 24 to 1 as compared to the surgical side. The stability of the surgical side was evidenced by the fact that there was no regression in four of the animals and only 1 degree of regression in the fifth animal. Regression measured from the control incisors ranged from 5 to 34 degrees. Serial transverse sections of the maxilla were evaluated for the histologic changes. These changes were seen as cementum resorption, cementum repair, and areas of cementum deposition without prior resorption. To a lesser extent, osseous changes were evident. The alterations in cementum and bone were consistently more numerous and more extensive on the control side. Similarly, the degree of repair as evidenced by cementum and bone deposition was more complete on the surgical side. It may be theorized, on the basis of this finding, that the greater amount of tissue alteration on the control side was due to tooth movement during rerotation. The fibers in the cervical adnexa of the orthodontically rotated incisors were reorganized and demonstrated a fibrous pattern and density similar to that observed in the nonrotated first incisors. In the nonsurgical control incisors, regression of the rotations contributed to fiber reorganization, whereas on the surgical side, where regression was minimal, transsection of the fibers and subsequent repair resulted in fiber rearrangement. The surgical procedure resulted in reduction of the forces of regression transmitted by the displaced gingival tissues. Even more important, the repair of these fibers contributed to the retention of the rotated incisors. The stability of a rotated tooth is dependent upon many factors. However, analyses of the data from this investigation suggest that the transsection of the free gingival fibers following orthodontic tooth rotation, coupled with a period of retention allowing for optimum biologic repair, can be a definite adjunct to retention.
Read full abstract