We are pleased to have been invited to write a commentary on Alan Fogel’s paper in which he integrates sociocultural information into a dynamical systems approach to human movement. Working, as we both are, on perceptuo-motor development in infancy, we have developed a particular interest in an ecological approach to perception and action. Such an approach ‘seeks to account for order and variability in movement as emerging in evolution, development, and learning from physical and informational constraints, without assuming sources of organisation in cognitive or neural structures a priori’ (Warren 1990: 23). We are therefore delighted that Fogel proposes a theory of social communication and development which is not based on internalized schemes or codes to account for developmental change, but on the emergence of communicative forms following a dynamic process of mutual interaction between adult and child. We also agree with Fogel that movements play an important role in social communication. When Fogel reverses this claim, however, by arguing that all movements are to be understood socially, we must object.
Read full abstract