Clustered DNA damage, when multiple lesions are generated in close proximity, has various biological consequences, including cell death, chromosome aberrations, and mutations. It is generally perceived as a hallmark of ionizing radiation. The enhanced mutagenic potential of lesions within a cluster has been suggested to result, at least in part, from the selection of the strand with the mutagenic lesion as the preferred template strand, and that this process is relevant to the tolerance of persistent single-strand breaks generated during an attempted repair. Using a plasmid-based assay in Escherichia coli, we examined how the strand bias is affected in mutant strains deficient in different DNA polymerase I activities. Our study revealed that the strand-displacement and 5′-flap endonuclease activities are required for this process, while 3′-to-5′ exonuclease activity is not. We also found the strand template that the mutagenic lesion was located on, whether lagging or leading, had no effect on this strand bias. Our results imply that an unknown pathway operates to repair/tolerate the single-strand break generated at a bi-stranded clustered damage site, and that there exist different backup pathways, depending on which DNA polymerase I activity is compromised.