Volatile anesthetic agents like sevoflurane, isoflurane, and desflurane are widely used for maintaining general anesthesia (GA). Their effect on the autonomic system is different and can impact the blood sugar homeostasis. This study compares the intraoperative blood glucose levels in non-diabetic patients undergoing non-cardiac surgery under GA with the three volatile agents. A randomized, single-blind, parallel-arm study recruited 105 non-diabetic patients into three groups. GA induction and maintenance were standardized except for the volatile agent. Capillary blood sugar levels were measured at different time points and compared between and within the groups. A p-value of <0.05 was considered significant. Entire participants completed the study, and their baseline characteristics were statistically indifferent. Intraoperative blood glucose rise and variation were the highest in the desflurane group and the lowest in the isoflurane group; the differences were statistically significant at 15, 30, and 45 minutes. The highest blood sugar level was noted at 60 minutes in all groups; after that, the level started falling. However, none of the raises were beyond 140 mg% to categorize them as hyperglycemia. Intraoperative glycemic variation was evident with isoflurane, sevoflurane, and desflurane. The maximum increase from the pre-induction level was noted at 60 minutes. However, none of the readings reached the hyperglycemia level. The rise was significantly higher in desflurane-based anesthesia than in isoflurane. This study was, however, conducted in non-diabetic patients; hence, results might not be extrapolated to diabetic patients.