Rib Cage Distortion Research Articles

Rib cage distortion and dynamic hyperinflation during two exercise intensities in people with COPD

BackgroundThe relationship between rib cage (RC) motion abnormalities, dynamic hyperinflation (DH), and exercise capacity in people with COPD is controversial. AimTo investigate RC distortion and operational chest wall volumes during moderate and high constant-rate exercises in people with COPD. MethodsSeven male participants [median(Q1-Q3) age: 63(60.0–66.0) years; FEV1: 39.0(38.0–63.0)% of predicted] performed a symptom-limited incremental exercise testing on cycle ergometer, followed by constant-rate tests (60 % and 80 % of peak work rate). Optoelectronic plethysmography was used to evaluate RC distortion: phase angle-PhAng, inspiratory phase ratio-PhRIB, expiratory phase ratio-PhREB; and chest wall volumes: end-inspiratory volume-Vei and end-expiratory volume-Vee. ResultsPhRIB and PhREB significantly increased during both constant-rate exercise tests, without difference between them. In general, Vei of the chest wall significantly increased in both exercise intensities while Vee did not change. ConclusionsThe occurrence of RC distortion seemed not to limit the exercise capacity in people with COPD evaluated, and it was present even in the absence of DH.

Thoracoabdominal asynchrony and paradoxical motion in Duchenne muscular dystrophy and healthy subjects during cough: A case control study.

To assess thoracoabdominal asynchrony (TAA) and inspiratory paradoxical motion at different positionings in subjects with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) versus healthy subjects during quiet spontaneous breathing (QB) and cough. This is a case control study with a matched-pair design. We assessed 14 DMD subjects and 12 controls using optoelectronic plethysmography (OEP) during QB and spontaneous cough in 3 positions: supine, supine with headrest raised at 45°, and sitting with back support at 80°. The TAA was assessed using phase angle (θ) between upper (RCp) and lower rib cage (RCa) and abdomen (AB), as well as the percentage of inspiratory time the RCp (IPRCp ), RCa (IPRCa ), and AB (IPAB ) moved in opposite directions. During cough, DMD group showed higher RCp and RCa θ (p < .05), RCp and AB θ (p < .05) in supine and 45° positions, and higher RCp and Rca θ (p = .006) only in supine position compared with controls. Regarding the intragroup analysis, during cough, DMD group presented higher RCp and AB θ (p = .02) and RCa and AB θ (p = .002) in supine and higher RCa and AB θ (p = .002) in 45° position when compared to 80°. Receiver operating characteristic curve analyzes were able to discriminate TAA between controls and DMD in RCa supine position (area under the curve: 0.81, sensibility: 78.6% and specificity: 91.7%, p = .001). Subjects with DMD yields TAA with insufficient deflation of chest wall compartments and rib cage distortion during cough, by noninvasive assessment.

Dyspnea, Chest Wall Hyperinflation, and Rib Cage Distortion in Exercising Patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease

Whether dyspnea, chest wall dynamic hyperinflation, and abnormalities of rib cage motion are interrelated phenomena has not been systematically evaluated in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Our hypothesis that they are not interrelated was based on the following observations: (i) externally imposed expiratory flow limitation is associated with no rib cage distortion during strenuous incremental exercise, with indexes of hyperinflation not being correlated with dyspnea, and (ii) end-expiratory chest wall volume may either increase or decrease during exercise in patients with COPD, with those who hyperinflate being as breathless as those who do not. Sixteen patients breathed either room air or 50% supplemental O2 at 75% of peak exercise in randomized order. We evaluated the volume of chest wall (V(cw)) and its compartments: the upper rib cage (V(rcp)), lower rib cage (V(rca)), and abdomen (V(ab)) using optoelectronic plethysmography; rib cage distortion was assessed by measuring the phase angle shift between V(rcp) and V(rca). Ten patients increased end-expiratory V(cw) (V(cw,ee)) on air. In seven hyperinflators and three non-hyperinflators, the lower rib cage paradoxed inward during inspiration with a phase angle of 63.4° ± 30.7° compared with a normal phase angle of 16.1° ± 2.3° recorded in patients without rib cage distortion. Dyspnea (by Borg scale) averaged 8.2 and 9 at the end of exercise on air in patients with and without rib cage distortion, respectively. At iso-time during exercise with oxygen, decreased dyspnea was associated with a decrease in ventilation regardless of whether patients distorted the rib cage, dynamically hyperinflated, or deflated the chest wall. Dyspnea, chest wall dynamic hyperinflation, and rib cage distortion are not interrelated phenomena.

Chest wall kinematics in young subjects with Pectus excavatum

Quantifying chest wall kinematics and rib cage distortion during ventilatory effort in subjects with Pectus excavatum (PE) has yet to be defined. We studied 24 patients: 19 during maximal voluntary ventilation (MVV) and 5 during MVV and cycling exercise (CE). By optoelectronic plethysmography (OEP) we assessed operational volumes in upper rib cage, lower rib cage and abdomen. Ten age-matched healthy subjects served as controls. Patients exhibited mild restrictive lung defect. During MVV end-inspiratory and end-expiratory volumes of chest wall compartments increased progressively in controls, whereas most patients avoided dynamic hyperinflation by setting operational volumes at values lower than controls. Mild rib cage distortion was found in three patients at rest, but neither in patients nor in controls did MVV or CE consistently affect coordinated motion of the rib cage. Rib cage displacement was not correlated with a CT-scan severity index. Conclusions, mild rib cage distortion rarely occurs in PE patients with mild restrictive defect. OEP contributes to clinical evaluation of PE patients.

Chest wall kinematics and breathlessness during unsupported arm exercise in COPD patients

We hypothesised that chest wall displacement inappropriate to increased ventilation contributes to dyspnoea more than dynamic hyperinflation or dyssynchronous breathing during unsupported arm exercise (UAE) in COPD patients. We used optoelectronic plethysmography to evaluate operational volumes of chest wall compartments, the upper rib cage, lower rib cage and abdomen, at 80% of peak incremental exercise in 13 patients. The phase shift between the volumes of upper and lower rib cage (RC) was taken as an index of RC distortion. With UAE, no chest wall dynamic hyperinflation was found; sometimes the lower RC paradoxed inward while in other patients it was the upper RC. Phase shift did not correlate with dyspnoea (by Borg scale) at any time, and chest wall displacement was in proportion to increased ventilation. In conclusions neither chest wall dynamic hyperinflation nor dyssynchronous breathing per se were major contributors to dyspnoea. Unlike our prediction, chest wall expansion and ventilation were adequately coupled with each other.

Chest wall kinematics during voluntary cough in neuromuscular patients

Muscular diseases are characterized by progressive loss of muscle strength, resulting in cough ineffectiveness with its deleterious effects on the respiratory system. Assessment of cough effectiveness is therefore a prominent component of the clinical evaluation and respiratory care in these patients. Owing to uneven distribution of muscle weakness in neuromuscular patients, we hypothesized that forces acting on the chest wall may impact on the compartmental distribution of gas volume resulting in a decrease in cough effectiveness. Pulmonary volumes, respiratory muscle strength, peak cough flow and chest wall kinematics by optoelectronic plethysmography were studied in 8 patients and 12 healthy subjects as controls. Chest wall volume was modeled as the sum of volumes of the rib cage and abdomen. The plot of the volumes of upper to lower rib cage allowed assessment of rib cage distortion. Unlike controls, patients were unable to reduce end-expiratory chest wall volume, and exhibited greater rib cage distortion during cough. Peak cough flow was negatively correlated with rib cage distortion (the greater the former, the smaller the latter), but not with respiratory muscle strength. In conclusion, insufficient deflation of chest wall compartments and marked rib cage distortion resulted in cough ineffectiveness in these neuromuscular patients.

Chest wall kinematics and Hoover's sign

No attempt has been made to quantify the observed rib cage distortion (Hoover's sign) in terms of volume displacement. We hypothesized that Hoover's sign and hyperinflation are independent quantities. Twenty obstructed stable patients were divided into two groups according to whether or not they exhibited Hoover's sign during clinical examination while breathing quietly. We evaluated the volumes of chest wall and its compartments: the upper rib cage, the lower rib cage and the abdomen, using optoelectronic plethysmography. The volumes of upper rib cage, lower rib cage and abdomen as a percentage of absolute volume of the chest wall were similar in patients with and without Hoover's sign. In contrast, the tidal volume of the chest wall, upper rib cage, lower rib cage, their ratio and abdomen quantified Hoover's sign, but did not correlate with level of hyperinflation. Rib cage distortion and hyperinflation appear to define independently the functional condition of these patients.

Chest wall kinematics during cough in healthy subjects

The study of kinematics of the chest wall (CW) could allow us to define the relative deflationary contribution of its compartments during fits of coughing. We hypothesized that if forces applied to the lung apposed rib cage are not commensurate with those applied to the abdomen-apposed rib cage, cough could result in rib cage distortion. In 12 (five women) healthy subjects we evaluated the volumes of CW (Vcw) and its compartments: the lung apposed rib cage, the abdomen apposed rib cage and the abdomen, by optoelectronic plethysmography. The loop of volume of the lung apposed rib cage/volume of the abdomen apposed rib cage allowed the calculation of mean rib cage distortion, resulting in a dimensionless number which, when multiplied by 100, gives percentage distortion. Each subject performed voluntary single and prolonged coughing efforts at functional residual capacity (FRC) and after maximal inspiration (max). The normal level of mean distortion was set at <0.5%. The three compartments contributed to reducing end-expiratory Vcw during cough at FRC and prolonged maximum cough, with the latter resulting in the greatest CW deflation. Mean rib cage distortion did not differ between men and women (P > 0.1), but tended to significantly increase from single to prolonged Cough Max (1.3% +/- 1.0 vs. 2.3% +/- 1.6, respectively; P = 0.06). Rib cage distortion may ensue during coughing, probably as a result of uneven distribution of forces applied to the rib cage.

Chest wall kinematics, respiratory muscle action and dyspnoea during arm vs. leg exercise in humans

We hypothesize that different patterns of chest wall (CW) kinematics and respiratory muscle coordination contribute to sensation of dyspnoea during unsupported arm exercise (UAE) and leg exercise (LE). In six volunteer healthy subjects, we evaluated the volumes of chest wall (V(cw)) and its compartments, the pulmonary apposed rib cage (V(rc,p)), the diaphragm-abdomen apposed rib cage (V(rc,a)) and the abdomen (V(ab)), by optoelectronic plethysmography. Oesophageal, gastric and trans-diaphragmatic pressures were simultaneously measured. Chest wall relaxation line allowed the measure of peak rib cage inspiratory muscle, expiratory muscle and abdominal muscle pressures. The loop V(rc,p)/V(rc,a) allowed the calculation of rib cage distortion. Dyspnoea was assessed by a modified Borg scale. There were some differences and similarities between UAE and LE. Unlike LE with UAE: (i) V(cw) and V(rc,p) at end inspiration did not increase, whereas a decrease in V(rc,p) contributed to decreasing CW end expiratory volume; (ii) pressure production of inspiratory rib cage muscles did not significantly increase from quiet breathing. Not unlike LE, the diaphragm limited its inspiratory contribution to ventilation with UAE with no consistent difference in rib cage distortion between UAE and LE. Finally, changes in abdominal muscle pressure, and inspiratory rib cage muscle pressure predicted 62% and 41.4% of the variability in Borg score with UAE and LE, respectively (P < 0.01). Leg exercise and UAE are associated with different patterns of CW kinematics, respiratory muscle coordination, and production of dyspnoea.

Rib cage mechanics during quiet breathing and exercise in humans

During exercise, large pleural, abdominal, and transdiaphragmatic pressure swings might produce substantial rib cage (RC) distortions. We used a three-compartment chest wall model (J. Appl. Physiol. 72: 1338-1347, 1992) to measure distortions of lung- and diaphragm-apposed RC compartments (RCp and RCa) along with pleural and abdominal pressures in five normal men. RCp and RCa volumes were calculated from three-dimensional locations of 86 markers on the chest wall, and the undistorted (relaxation) RC configuration was measured. Compliances of RCp and RCa measured during phrenic stimulation against a closed airway were 20 and 0%, respectively, of their values during relaxation. There was marked RC distortion. Thus nonuniform distribution of pressures distorts the RC and markedly stiffens it. However, during steady-state ergometer exercise at 0, 30, 50, and 70% of maximum workload, RC distortions were small because of a coordinated action of respiratory muscles, so that net pressures acting on RCp and RCa were nearly the same throughout the respiratory cycle. This maximizes RC compliance and minimizes the work of RC displacement. During quiet breathing, plots of RCa volume vs. abdominal pressure were to the right of the relaxation curve, indicating an expiratory action on RCa. We attribute this to passive stretching of abdominal muscles, which more than counterbalances the insertional component of transdiaphragmatic pressure.

Rib cage distortion in a canine model of flail chest.

Although blunt chest injuries frequently lead to respiratory failure, the effects of flail chest on the mechanics of breathing have not been evaluated. In the present studies, we have measured the respiratory displacements of the ribs and sternum and the electromyograms (EMG) of the parasternal and external intercostal muscles in eight supine, anesthetized, spontaneously breathing dogs before and after the third to sixth ribs on the right side of the chest were fractured both dorsally and ventrally. After flail, the fractured ribs moved inward, rather than outward, during inspiration, but their inspiratory cranial displacement remained unchanged. The inspiratory outward and caudal displacement of the sternum, the inspiratory EMG activity of the parasternal intercostals, the pattern of breathing, and the arterial blood gases were also unaltered. However, the inspiratory EMG activity recorded from the external intercostals increased consistently to 327 +/- 101% of control (p < 0.05). These observations indicate that with flail chest, the disconnected segment of the rib cage shows paradoxical motion exclusively along the lateral axis; the increased external intercostal activation may account, at least in part, for the persistent inspiratory cranial motion of the ribs. These observations also suggest that the harmful effects of blunt chest injuries are related to pulmonary contusion and pain, rather than to flail chest per se.

Thoracic Epidural Anesthesia Causes Rib Cage Distortion in Anesthetized, Spontaneously Breathing Dogs

The effects of thoracic epidural anesthesia on the performance of the parasternal intercostal muscles were investigated by measuring electromyographic activity and length changes of the parasternals (EMG activities and length, respectively, of the parasternals) in seven pentobarbital anesthetized, spontaneously breathing dogs. Epidural injection of 0.1 mL/kg of 2% lidocaine decreased tidal volume and minute ventilation during unstimulated breathing. These changes were accompanied by complete abolishment of EMG activities of the parasternals and passive elongation of the parasternals during inspiration. At equivalent end-tidal PCO2 values (70 and 80 mm Hg) during CO2 rebreathing, tidal volume and minute ventilation were lower after epidural block compared to the corresponding values before the block. Thoracic epidural anesthesia impaired contraction of the parasternals and conceivably other respiratory muscles in the rib cage as well and could induce a distortion of the rib cage. The authors conclude that respiratory muscles in the rib cage contribute considerably to the maintenance of ventilation in anesthetized dogs.

Action of the intercostal muscles on the rib cage

Recent studies suggest that the parasternal muscles (PA) are primarily responsible for rib cage expansion during eupneic breathing with a much lesser role played by the interosseous external intercostals (EI). The purpose of the present investigation was to assess the capacity of the EI to expand the rib cage during sponstaneous breathing in the absence of coincident ipsilateral PA activation. In 9 anaesthetized dogs, we measured PA EMG and length in the 3rd interspace and EI EMG and length in the 3rd and 4th interspaces. During resting breathing, each muscle was electrically active and shortened to a similar degree, approximately 3% of resting length. Following ipsilateral PA denervation (1st through 6th interspaces), the level of EI shortening in the 3rd and 4th interspaces was maintained, but with an increase in neural drive to these muscles. The parasternal muscle in the 3rd interscience lengthened during inspiration. Subsequent sequential denervation of EI in the 3rd and 4th interspaces resulted in their lengthening. In 4 additional animals, axial motion of the 4th rib was measured in the mid axillary line. Ipsilateral PA denervation had no significant effect on rib motion. External intercostal denervation (3rd interspace), on the other hand, had a substantial impact on rib motion, causing the 4th rib to move in the caudal direction during inspiration. Our results indicate that: (a) the EI of the lateral rib cage are capable of elevating the ribs during inspiration independent of PA contraction; (b) PA contraction contributes to EI shortening during eupneic breathing and (c) regional of muscle activation results in local rib cage distortion, suggesting that the upper rib cage has multiple degrees of freedom.

Respiratory Mechanics in Acute Quadriplegia: Lung and Chest Wall Compliance and Dimensional Changes during Respiratory Maneuvers

We measured lung and chest wall compliance as well as rib cage and abdominal dimensions in the supine position in five acute C4-7 quadriplegics. Studies were performed serially from 1 to 12 months after injury. Results were compared with those of control groups of chronic (greater than 1 yr after injury) quadriplegics and normal volunteers. We found that lung compliance was lower in acute and chronic quadriplegics (0.129 +/- 0.023 and 0.176 +/- 0.043 L/mm Hg, respectively) than in normal subjects (0.278 +/- 0.086 L/mm Hg) and that these changes apparently occurred within 1 month of injury. Specific lung compliance appeared to be reduced to a lesser degree, suggesting that the changes in lung compliance were partly due to reduced lung volumes and partly to altered mechanical properties of the lung. During respiratory maneuvers, abdomen and rib cage dimensional changes demonstrated rib cage distortion. This distortion was less severe in chronic than in acute quadriplegics. The improvement in chest wall stability was likely due to increased strength of cervical accessory muscles of respiration and improved coupling of the various rib cage elements in chronic quadriplegics.

Diaphragmatic work of breathing in premature human infants.

Present methods of assessing the work of breathing in human infants do not account for the added load when intercostal muscle activity is lost and rib cage distortion occurs. We have developed a technique for assessing diaphragmatic work in this circumstance utilizing measurements of transdiaphragmatic pressure and abdominal volume displacement. Eleven preterm infants without evidence of lung disease were studied. During periods of minimal rib cage distortion, inspiratory diaphragmatic work averaged 5.9 g X cm X ml-1, increasing to an average of 12.4 g X cm X ml-1 with periods of paradoxical rib cage motion (P less than 0.01). Inspiratory work was strongly correlated with the electrical activity of the diaphragm as measured from its moving time average (P less than 0.05). Assuming a mechanical efficiency of 4% in these infants, the caloric cost of diaphragmatic work may reach 10% of their basal metabolic rate in periods with rib cage distortion. When lung disease is superimposed, the increased metabolic demands of the diaphragm may predispose preterm infants to fatigue and may contribute to a failure to grow.

Upper and lower rib cage deformation during breathing in quadriplegics.

In quadriplegia, the anteroposterior diameter of the rib cage (RC) decreases during inspiration. Our aim was to characterize this paradoxical motion further and to determine to what extent it was due to a diminished inspiratory effect of the diaphragm on the RC because of abdominal muscle paralysis. In six quadriplegics, upper and lower RC (URC, LRC) displacements were studied in various postures with and without extrinsic abdominal support. LRC was in its relaxed configuration at all lung volumes studied in three subjects before and four subjects during abdominal compression. URC distorted most and, despite improvement during abdominal compression, was never in the relaxed configuration during tidal inspiration. Thoracic distortability was further studied by noting the effect on URC and LRC of a cephalad force applied to the RC at the costal margin. This produced distortion similar to that observed during spontaneous inspiration. It was concluded that during spontaneous inspiration in quadriplegics lack of abdominal support does not entirely explain the RC distortion which occurs, and high abdominal pressure results in diminished RC distortion, an effect which we attribute to an increase in the area of diaphragmatic apposition to the RC.

Mechanical aspects of chest wall distortion.

During passive inflation of the respiratory system, the rib cage (RC) expands because the pressure applied to it [approximately equal to abdominal pressure (Pab)] increases. Similar Pab-tidal volume (VT) relationships between passive and spontaneous inspirations would occur only if 1) Pab acts on RC equally in the two situations (no distortion) or 2) the extradiaphragmatic inspiratory muscles expand RC, compensating for distortion. In anesthetized adult rats and in sleeping human infants the passive relationships between VT and Pab or abdomen motion (AB) were constructed by occluding the airways during expiration. For a given Pab (or AB) in active breathing VT averaged 55% (rats) and 49% (infants) of the passive volume change. With phrenic stimulation in rats VT was only slightly less than during spontaneous breathing, indicating that, in the latter case, the respiratory system was essentially driven only by the diaphragm. In both species occasional breaths with large RC expansion occurred, and VT was then equal to or larger than the passive volume at iso-Pab. We conclude that 1) RC distortion decreases VT to approximately half of the passive value and 2) being on the relaxation curve reflects "compensated" distortion and not absence of it.

Rib cage distortion during voluntary and involuntary breathing acts.

We examined chest wall and rib cage configuration in seven normal subjects during a variety of breathing maneuvers. Magnetometers were used to measure lower rib cage anteroposterior, lower rib cage transverse, upper rib cage anteroposterior, and abdomen anteroposterior diameters. Changes of these diameters were recorded during voluntary maneuvers, rebreathing, reading, and "natural" breathing. Relative motion of the rib cage and abdomen was displayed with the rib cage represented by the product of its lower anteroposterior and transverse diameters. During spontaneous breathing the rib cage and chest wall are near their relaxation configuration. During chemically driven ventilation the chest wall and rib cage progressively depart from this configuration. Much greater distortions of the chest wall and rib cage occurred during some voluntary maneuvers. Additionally, esophageal pressure and gastric pressure were measured during voluntary distortion of the rib cage. Substantial changes in lower rib cage shape occurred during voluntary maneuvers when compared with spontaneous breaths at the same transmural pressure. We conclude that the unitary behavior of the rib cage in normal subjects requires muscle coordination.

Action of abdominal muscles on rib cage in humans.

To assess the actions of the rectus abdominis and external oblique muscles on the rib cage in humans, these two muscles were stimulated with surface electrodes in four normal supine subjects at functional residual capacity. Changes in anteroposterior and transverse rib cage diameters and changes in xiphipubic distance were measured with pairs of magnetometers. Stimulation of rectus abdominis produced a marked decrease in the xiphipubic distance and in the anteroposterior diameter, thus making the rib cage more elliptic. In contrast, stimulation of the external oblique caused a decrease in the transverse diameter, making the rib cage more cylindrical. When both muscles were stimulated simultaneously, the resultant rib cage distortion depended on the relative voltage at which each muscle was stimulated. Electromyogram recordings showed that there was no cross contamination or activity of the diaphragm during the muscle stimulations. Transdiaphragmatic pressure increased with the voltage of stimulation, suggesting passive lengthening of the diaphragm. X-ray studies were performed in two subjects and confirmed the main magnetometer findings. These studies thus confirm that the rib cage in humans is more easily distortable than conventionally thought. The abdominal muscles can distort it in either direction depending on which muscles are contracting.

Activation of the parasternal intercostals during breathing efforts in human subjects.

We have tested the possibility that the electromyographic (EMG) activity present in the parasternal intercostal muscles during quiet inspiration was reflexive, rather than agonistic, in nature. Using concentric needle electrodes we measured parasternal EMG activity in four normal subjects during various inspiratory maneuvers. We found that 1) phasic inspiratory activity was invariably present in the parasternal intercostals during quiet breathing, 2) the parasternal EMG activity was generally increased during attempts to perform the tidal breathing maneuver with the diaphragm alone, 3) parasternal EMG activity was markedly decreased or suppressed in the presence of rib cage distortion during diaphragmatic isovolume maneuvers, and 4) that EMG activity could not be voluntarily suppressed during breathing unless the inspired volume was trivial. We conclude that the parasternal EMG activity detected during quiet inspiration in the normal subjects depends on a central involuntary mechanism and is not related to activation of intercostal mechanoreceptors.