Rhine River Research Articles

Unveiling industrial emissions in a large European river: Insights from data mining of high-frequency measurements

Despite the tremendous efforts to improve river water quality, chemical contamination remains a significant issue. Besides well-known contaminants, in recent years, pollutants of industrial origin received increasing attention because of the huge knowledge gap regarding their occurrence, fate and environmental risks. Moreover, such pollutants often exhibit high concentration fluctuations over time, which makes them less predictable and measurable with classical short-time campaigns.This study provides insights into the different sources of chemical contamination of the Rhine River based on temporal high-frequency LC-HRMS monitoring data from a single location. A newly developed prioritization strategy selected nearly 3000 substances as potentially major contaminants. A novel classification analysis based on temporal behavior identified 53% of these compounds (accounting for 62% of the time-integrated intensity recorded in the dataset) as originating from irregular emission sources. Irregular emissions can originate from industrial production cycles. After delimiting other potential irregular sources, we have strong evidence indicating that a considerable share of the irregular emissions likely comes from industrial activities. This finding is supported by the structural elucidation of sixteen irregularly emitted substances, for which the industrial origin was successfully confirmed. Those compounds include 3-chloro-5-(trifluoromethyl)pyridine-2-carboxylic acid and 4-(dimethylamino)-2,2-diphenylpentanenitrile. In addition, 40 other compounds exhibited temporal emission patterns similar to the sixteen industrial compounds, which strongly suggests a common contamination source. Finally, 100 top-ranking compounds were selected for further structural elucidation and emission reduction measures. The computational approach outlined within this study can be effectively applied in other large river catchments to identify unknown contaminants stemming from industrial sources.

Governance Conditions for a Successful Restoration of Riverine Ecosystems, Lessons from the Rhine River Basin

Over the years, human impacts have resulted in great losses in riverine biodiversity. Ecosystem restoration could contribute to reversing this trend. Ecosystem restoration, however, involves many actors and perspectives and is, therefore, a complex governance challenge. So far, this governance challenge has been understudied, and it is not clear which governance conditions may contribute to a successful restoration of riverine ecosystems. This paper addresses this knowledge gap by developing an assessment framework that is applied in a critical case study. We first reviewed scientific papers and compiled governance conditions found in an assessment framework. The framework is tested and refined by conducting a case study on the ecosystem restoration process coordinated by the International Commission for the Protection of the Rhine. This process aims to bring back the Atlantic salmon and other species in the basin. Our analysis revealed that despite efforts to reintroduce Atlantic salmon, a self-sustaining population is not present in the basin. Moreover, the governance structure in the basin only meets 13 out of 23 governance conditions. Challenges identified include slow decision-making, ambiguity in responsibilities, and limited financial incentives. Based on our case study, we have refined the framework to tailor it more for future research and policy development.

Widespread Evidence for Rapid Recent Changes in Global Range and Abundance of Threespine Stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus)

ABSTRACTThe threespine stickleback, Gasterosteus aculeatus, has undergone dramatic increases in abundance in parts of its historical native range, and it is also undergoing a major range expansion. We review available information and discuss the vectors and sources of the species' range expansions, the genetic characteristics of recently founded populations and the ecological consequences of both stickleback introductions and increases in abundance. Dramatic range expansions occurred in the Caspian Sea drainage, large rivers in the Black Sea drainage, reservoirs of the Rhine basin, isolated lakes in North America and Japan and remote islands in the Arctic. Likely reasons for these range expansions include canal construction, accidental inclusion with stocking of commercially valuable fish, intentional release by aquarists and fishermen and climate change. In some cases, range expansions of stickleback were likely facilitated by genetic admixture of previously separated lineages, as well as by high‐standing genetic variation that promotes rapid adaptation to new habitats. Accordingly, range expansions are often accompanied by striking increases in abundance, although these are two distinct processes. Notably, population growth within the species' native range, particularly in the White and Baltic Seas, has been observed alongside expansions into new areas. Where stickleback colonise new habitats or increase in abundance, extensive ecological impacts on ecosystems typically occur. Given these massive and widespread changes, the species has the potential to provide considerable insight into the evolutionary and ecological effects of human impacts on aquatic ecosystems.

Detailed workflow for estimating bedload transport based on dune tracking method

ABSTRACT Accurate assessment of bedload transport is a challenging task due to its variable nature in space and time. Bedload transport measurement techniques can be divided into two categories of direct and indirect methods. The focus of this study is on dune tracking as an indirect measurement method that has received much attention in recent years. However, a comprehensive workflow that allows the integration of this method into a routine measurement operation instead of or jointly with the direct sampling method has not been implemented yet. During a three-day measurement campaign conducted in the Rhine River, a detailed workflow for performing bedload transport measurements using the dune tracking method was introduced. Dune tracking validation was thoroughly evaluated, with significant efforts to simultaneously collect data using direct sampling. Direct measurements of bedload transport showed higher and more variable rates compared to dune tracking estimates. It was assumed that finer sediment fractions, moving as patches or small-scale superimposed bedforms were presumably not captured by the dune tracking. However, their significant contribution to bedload transport suggests that dune tracking estimates may have been underestimated. Further research is needed to explore how varying flow and sediment conditions affect bedload transport modes and measurement methods comparability.

Round gobies (Neogobius melanostomus) in the River Rhine: Population genetic support for invasion via two different routes

The round goby, Neogobius melanostomus, is a successful invasive fish species. Originating from the Caspian and Black Sea, it is now distributed widely within European fresh- and brackish waters. The River Rhine was colonized in 2008 only a few years after the opening of the Rhine-Main-Danube canal and only four years after N. melanostomus was first reported in the upper Danube River. Its invasion history of the River Rhine was unclear because the species was first detected close to the Rhine river delta which would suggest a route of invasion other than via the Rhine-Main-Danube canal. To investigate the colonization history of N. melanostomus in the Rhine, we combined abundance estimates with molecular analysis. Abundance estimates found N. melanostomus to be dominant in the Lower Rhine (> 90% of all catches). Molecular analysis was done on 286 individuals from four different sites. Using the mitochondrial control region (d-loop), we found three different haplotypes in both Rhine sites. None of the potential invasive source populations in the rivers Danube and Trave exhibited all three haplotypes. The molecular data therefore supported a scenario of two different colonization directions. Our results show that the invasion history of the River Rhine is complex and warrants further investigation.

Environmental changes in the Fleuve Manche paleoriver drainage system (Western Europe) linked to North Atlantic sub-millennial climate variability across Heinrich Stadial 1: Palynological evidence from the Bay of Biscay

Marine microfossils (dinoflagellate cysts and planktonic foraminifera) and geochemical (XRF-Ti/Ca)-based climatic records from a core (MD13–3438) located off the Fleuve Manche (FM) paleo-mouth have revealed that sustained warm summer sea surface temperatures (SSTs) during sub-millennial climate changes within HS1 (∼18–14.7 ka) may have played a key role in the FM regime related to the European Ice Sheet (EIS) melting rate. In this study, we have analyzed the MD13–3438 pollen content over the HS1 at a mean resolution of ∼50 years to test whether vegetation-based air temperatures were coupled to SSTs face to this rapid climate variability. First, our results highlight two major phases of pollen sources at site MD13–3438, preventing the pollen record to be interpreted as a continuous record of the evolution of vegetation and climate occupying a single watershed across HS1. The first phase, i.e. the HS1-a interval (∼18–16.8 ka), is marked by strong occurrences of boreal pollen taxa (especially Picea-Abies). Considering their spatial distribution and the coalescence of the British and Scandinavian ice sheets into the North Sea during the Last Glacial Maximum, these taxa probably originated from the North European Plain, i.e., eastern FM tributaries (east of the Rhine River), where cool-humid conditions generally prevailed. Then, the second phase, i.e. the HS1-b interval (∼16.8–14.7 ka BP), is characterized by a deceleration of the EIS retreat and the drop of boreal pollen values at site MD13–3438 further signing a less influence of the upstream FM drainage system and thus a better characterization of pollen sources related with western FM tributaries. Superimposed to these two HS1 main phases, pollen fluctuations are concomitant with sub-millennial variability in the EIS deglaciation intensity. During the early HS1 (HS1-a), we discuss two short-term increases in the ratio between deciduous trees (Quercus-Corylus-Alnus) and herbaceous plants (Plantago-Amaranthaceae-Artemisia). These events are coeval with phases of increasing dinocyst-based SST seasonality (i.e. through summer SST amplification). We associate these events with lower contribution of the upstream FM catchment as well as, possibly, atmospheric warming and regional sea-level positive oscillations. The HS1-b is composed of three main phases that appear more influenced by the downstream FM drainage system. HS1-b1 (16.8–16.3 ka BP) corresponds to the driest and coldest conditions west of the Rhine River. HS1-b2 (16.3–15.5 ka BP) is coeval with large arrivals of iceberg from the Hudson strait in the Bay of Biscay and thus likely to a major sea-level positive oscillation associated with a phase of FM valley reworking. HS1-b3 (15.5–14.7 ka BP) corresponds to persistent arid conditions that preceded the subsequent more humid conditions recorded from 14.7 ka BP at the start of the Bölling-Alleröd.

Multi-model hydrological reference dataset over continental Europe and an African basin

Although Essential Climate Variables (ECVs) have been widely adopted as important metrics for guiding scientific and policy decisions, the Earth Observation (EO) and Land Surface and Hydrologic Model (LSM/HM) communities have yet to treat terrestrial ECVs in an integrated manner. To develop consistent terrestrial ECVs at regional and continental scales, greater collaboration between EO and LSM/HM communities is needed. An essential first step is assessing the LSM/HM simulation uncertainty. To that end, we introduce a new hydrological reference dataset that comprises a range of 19 existing LSM/HM simulations that represent the current state-of-the-art of our LSM/HMs. Simulations are provided on a daily time step, covering Europe, notably the Rhine and Po river basins, alongside the Tugela river basin in Africa, and are uniformly formatted to allow comparisons across simulations. Furthermore, simulations are comprehensively validated with discharge, evapotranspiration, soil moisture and total water storage anomaly observations. Our dataset provides valuable information to support policy development and serves as a benchmark for generating consistent terrestrial ECVs through the integration of EO products.

Tracking aquatic non-native macroinvertebrate species in Germany using long-term data

Biological invasions pose a global challenge, threatening both biodiversity and human well-being. Projections suggest that as invasions increase, the financial costs associated with management and the ecological harm they cause will also escalate. Here, we examined whether long-term biomonitoring strategies were adequate to identify and track benthic aquatic non-native macroinvertebrate species by using the German subset (151 time series; 129 of which reported non-native species) of the currently most comprehensive European long-term dataset of 1816 macroinvertebrate community time series from 22 European countries. The detection of aquatic non-native species was directly linked to the availability of long-term sites and thus, monitoring effort, having identified the spatio-temporal occurrence of 32 non-native species. The available long-term monitoring site data were mostly concentrated in the western part of Germany, predominantly covering the Rhine River and its tributaries. The spatially biased network of long-term monitoring sites, therefore, naturally skews the detection and reporting of aquatic non-native species toward this area and underestimates Eastern and Southern regions, impeding the comprehension of invasion dynamics. However, based on the available data, we found that the absolute number of non-native species increased and the proportion of non-native species relative to native species decreased over time. This indicates complex ecological interactions between native and non-native species and underlines the value of long-term data for investigating invasion dynamics. Considering the value of comprehensive monitoring networks, a spatially biased network delays the application of management and mitigation plans, possibly worsening the ecological and economic effects of biological invasions in Germany. The results provided here indicate the disadvantages of biased datasets, but simultaneously underline the enormous potential of a dense network of long-term monitoring. Our results also highlight the urgent need to increase and diversify long-term biomonitoring efforts throughout Germany to cover the main freshwater resources and their connections where the introduction risk of non-native species is the highest. Centrally collating such data would provide a profound basis for the monitoring of spreading aquatic non-native species and could serve the implementation of national biosecurity efforts.

Prehistorical and historical occurrence and range dynamic of the Eurasian Spoonbill (Platalea leucorodia) and the White Stork (Ciconia ciconia) in Europe

AbstractThe Eurasian Spoonbill (Platalea leucorodia) and the White Stork (Ciconia ciconia) are emblematic birds of high conservation interest. This article examines their range history in Europe since the end of the last Glacial by analyzing subfossil bone finds of both species, mostly from archaeological excavations. It is shown that two thousand years ago, White Storks occurred exclusively in the territory of the Roman Empire, i.e. the northern border of their distribution ran along the Rhine and Danube rivers. The north-east part of the continent, with its high population density today, was only colonized in the last few centuries. The Spoonbill’s patchy occurrence in Europe today appears to be a typical distribution pattern for this species. The subfossil findings also do not indicate a large, closed distribution area for any phase of the last 10,000 years. Some of its distribution islands (e.g. those in the Netherlands) have existed for thousands of years.

Coupling higher-order probability weighted moments with norming constants method for non-stationary annual maximum flood frequency analysis

Non-stationary flood frequency analysis (NFFA) is essential for reducing the risk of hydrologic engineering design and operation, especially when done under the severe influences of climate change and strong human activities. Although different types of methods have been proposed, NFFA is still a challenging task due to the complex characteristics of hydroclimatic data and weaknesses of diverse methods. In this article, a new method, called HPWM-NCM, is proposed for NFFA. The method uses the higher-order probability weighted moments (HPWM) method to accurately estimate parameters of flood data, and then applies the norming constants method (NCM) to precisely calculate the norming constants and further do NFFA. Results of both Monte-Carlo experiments and observed hydrologic data at 62 stations in the Rhine River basin illustrated that HPWM-NCM significantly improved the NFFA results compared to conventional NCM and the probability weighted moments method, as evaluated by overall fitting bias, residuals’ correlation, and residuals’ maximum error. Results highlighted the importance of using the information in high quantiles (rather than low quantiles) of flood data for NFFA, which is the key of the proposed method and ensures its superiority. Overall, the advantages of HPWM-NCM for non-stationary flood frequency analysis were confirmed, and the method has the potential for wide use in hydrologic and climate sciences.

Untargeted metabolomic insights into plastisphere communities in European rivers.

Every year, rivers introduce a staggering amount of hundred kilotons of plastic into the Oceans. This plastic is inhabited by microorganisms known as the plastisphere, which can be transferred between different ecosystems through the transport of microplastics. Here, we simulated the microbial colonization of polyethylene-based plastic pellets that are classically used to manufacture large-scale plastic products. The pellets were immersed for 1month in four to five sampling stations along the river-to-sea continuum of nine of the major European rivers. This study presents the first untargeted metabolomics analysis of the plastisphere, by using ultra high-performance liquid chromatography coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry (UHPLC-HRMS). The plastisphere metabolomes were similar in the Rhine and Rhone rivers, while being different from the Tiber and Loire rivers, which showed greater similarity to the Thames and Seine rivers. Interestingly, we found a clear distinction between plastisphere metabolomes from freshwater and marine water in most of the river-to-sea continuum, thus suggesting a complete segregation in plastisphere metabolites that is not consistent with a major transfer of microorganisms between the two contrasted ecosystems. Putative annotations of 189 discriminating metabolites suggested that lipid metabolism was significantly modulated. These results enlightened the relevance of using environmental metabolomic as complementary analysis to the current OMICs analysis.

The effects of changing channel retention: Unravelling the mechanisms behind the spatial and temporal trends of suspended sediment in the Rhine basin

The effects of changing channel retention: Unravelling the mechanisms behind the spatial and temporal trends of suspended sediment in the Rhine basin

Temporal trajectories of artificial radiocaesium 137Cs in French rivers over the nuclear era reconstructed from sediment cores

137Cs is a long-lived man-made radionuclide introduced in the environment worldwide at the early beginning of the nuclear Era during atmospheric nuclear testing’s followed by the civil use of nuclear energy. Atmospheric fallout deposition of this major artificial radionuclide was reconstructed at the scale of French large river basins since 1945, and trajectories in French nuclearized rivers were established using sediment coring. Our results show that 137Cs contents in sediments of the studied rivers display a large spatial and temporal variability in response to the various anthropogenic pressures exerted on their catchment. The Loire, Rhone, and Rhine rivers were the most affected by atmospheric fallout from the global deposition from nuclear tests. Rhine and Rhone also received significant fallout from the Chernobyl accident in 1986 and recorded significant 137Cs concentrations in their sediments over the 1970–1985 period due to the regulatory releases from the nuclear industries. The Meuse River was notably impacted in the early 1970s by industrial releases. In contrast, the Seine River display the lowest 137Cs concentrations regardless of the period. All the rivers responded similarly over time to atmospheric fallout on their catchment, underlying a rather homogeneous resilience capacity of these river systems to this source of contamination.

Impact of groundwater nitrogen legacy on water quality

The loss of agricultural nitrogen (N) is a leading cause of global eutrophication and freshwater and coastal hypoxia. Despite regulatory efforts, such as the European Union’s Nitrogen Directive, high concentrations of N persist in freshwaters. Excessive N leaching and accumulation in groundwater has created a substantial N reservoir as groundwater travel times are orders-of-magnitude slower than those of surface waters. In this study we reconstructed past and projected future N dynamics in groundwater for four major river basins, the Rhine, Mississippi, Yangtze and Pearl, showcasing different N trajectories. The Rhine and Mississippi river basins have accumulated N since the 1950s and although strategies to reduce excess agricultural N have worked well in the Rhine, groundwater legacy N persists in the Mississippi. The Yangtze and Pearl river basins entered the N accumulation phase in the 1970s and the accumulation is expected to continue until 2050. Policies to reduce N pollution from fertilizers have not halted N accumulation, highlighting the importance of accounting for the N legacy in groundwater. Restoring groundwater N storage to 1970 levels by diminishing N leaching will therefore take longer in the Yangtze and Pearl (>35 years) than in the Rhine (9 years) and Mississippi (15 years). Sustainable watershed management requires long-term strategies that address the impacts of legacy N and promote sustainable agricultural practices aligned with the Sustainable Development Goals to balance agricultural productivity with water conservation.

Low-Flow Similarities between the Transboundary Lauter River and Rhine River at Maxau from 1956 to 2022 (France/Germany)

Low-Flow Similarities between the Transboundary Lauter River and Rhine River at Maxau from 1956 to 2022 (France/Germany)

Optimization of sample preparation, fluorescence- and Raman techniques for environmental microplastics

Microspectroscopic imaging techniques based on spontaneous Raman scattering, Stimulated Raman Scattering (SRS), or fluorescence (with a selective dye) can be used to detect environmental microplastics (MPs) and determine their chemical as well as physical properties. The present study first focuses on optimizing the sample preparation, including a new design for a density separation apparatus and optimization of the Nile Red staining procedure. Tests were carried out with both white and colored reference materials, as well as environmental MPs in a suspended matter sample from the Rhine river. The new ‘MESSY’ system has a mean recovery of 95 ± 5.5 % (three polymer materials, in duplicate). The optimized Nile Red staining allows coarse categorization of MPs into “polar” vs. “non-polar” materials based on their Fluorescence Index (emission wavelength), but fluorescent additives in the polymer can cause misclassification. For unambiguous identification of the polymer type, Raman spectroscopy can be used. Even colored polymers, with or without Nile Red staining, were readily identified by Raman spectroscopy using a red laser (785 nm), except for particles containing carbon black. A Deep-UV Raman microscope (ex = 248.6 nm) was constructed, which allowed identification of all colored plastics, even those pigmented with carbon black. Since unsupervised mapping with spontaneous Raman is very slow, point measurements are preferably used after preselection of particles of interest based on fluorescence imaging. SRS is several orders of magnitude faster than spontaneous Raman mapping but requires multiple scans at different z-heights and at multiple wavenumber settings to detect and identify all particles. The results are expected to contribute to the development of suitable methodologies for the detection and identification of environmental microplastics.

Late glacial to Holocene fluvial dynamics in the Upper Rhine alluvial plain, France

AbstractHigh-resolution sedimentological and geochronological investigations of paleochannel systems in the Ried Central d'Alsace (northeastern France) allow for the reconstruction of the late glacial and Holocene fluvial evolution of this section of the Upper Rhine alluvial plain. During the Oldest Dryas, the landscape featured a dominant braided Rhine system and, to a lesser extent, a braided Fecht system. The shift to the Bølling-Allerød saw a narrowing of the Rhine's active channel belt, the development of a complex channel pattern, and the genesis of the Ill River. The river channel patterns remained unchanged during the Younger Dryas. In the Early Holocene, the Rhine's active belt narrowed further, and the Rhine and Ill Rivers developed braided-anastomosing and anastomosing channel patterns, respectively. Throughout the Holocene, both rivers maintained their channel patterns while migrating east and west across the alluvial plain, respectively. In the late glacial, fluvial dynamics in this section of the Upper Rhine plain were primarily influenced by climate-related environmental and hydrogeomorphological changes. Conversely, during the Holocene, the evolution of the fluvial hydrosystems was driven by a complex interaction of climatic and non-climatic factors, including human activity at the catchment scale, alluvial plain architecture, and local neotectonics.

Achieving a Water-Resilient Rotterdam: Past, Present and Future Perspectives

Achieving a Water-Resilient Rotterdam: Past, Present and Future Perspectives

Divergent drivers of the spatial variation in greenhouse gas concentrations and fluxes along the Rhine River and the Mittelland Canal in Germany

Lotic ecosystems are sources of greenhouse gases (GHGs) to the atmosphere, but their emissions are uncertain due to longitudinal GHG heterogeneities associated with point source pollution from anthropogenic activities. In this study, we quantified summer concentrations and fluxes of carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), and dinitrogen (N2), as well as several water quality parameters along the Rhine River and the Mittelland Canal, two critical inland waterways in Germany. Our main objectives were to compare GHG concentrations and fluxes along the two ecosystems and to determine the main driving factors responsible for their longitudinal GHG heterogeneities. The results indicated that the two ecosystems were sources of GHG fluxes to the atmosphere, with the Mittelland Canal being a hotspot for CH4 and N2O fluxes. We also found significant longitudinal GHG flux discontinuities along the mainstems of both ecosystems, which were mainly driven by divergent drivers. Along the Mittelland Canal, peak CO2 and CH4 fluxes coincided with point pollution sources such as a joining river tributary or the presence of harbors, while harbors and in-situ biogeochemical processes such as methanogenesis and respiration mainly explained CH4 and CO2 hotspots along the Rhine River. In contrast to CO2 and CH4 fluxes, N2O longitudinal trends along the two lotic ecosystems were better predicted by in-situ parameters such as chlorophyll-a concentrations and N2 fluxes. Based on a positive relationship with N2 fluxes, we hypothesized that in-situ denitrification was driving N2O hotspots in the Canal, while a negative relationship with N2 in the Rhine River suggested that coupled biological N2 fixation and nitrification accounted for N2O hotspots. These findings stress the need to include N2 flux estimates in GHG studies, as it can potentially improve our understanding of whether nitrogen is fixed through N2 fixation or lost through denitrification.

The Rhine Catchment: A Review of Sediment-Related Knowledge, Monitoring, and a Future Research Perspective

The Rhine River is affected by major human interventions affecting its morphology and sediment regime, which have severely changed its flow and sediment transport. While channelization has increased the sediment transport capacity in the free-flowing sections, the sediment retention behind dams has caused a bedload deficit downstream and has additionally intensified riverbed erosion. The resulting consequences range from the exposure of less erodible sediment layers that pose obstacles for navigation, to the scouring of infrastructure, the lowering of groundwater levels, and multiple negative ecological consequences. To optimize the efficiency of countermeasures, a coherent overview of all sediment-related activities and the state of knowledge on the Rhine catchment is required. That is why the present study aims to give a catchment-wide overview in this regard, identify knowledge gaps and proposing a future research programme. The methodological approach includes a comprehensive literature review and online interviews with experts from six riparian countries working in the fields of sediment research and management. Based on our investigations, we have derived several research topics, each consisting of research questions. Three project ideas were defined that should primarily be realized: (i) the influence of climate change and land use change on the sediment regime; (ii) alteration and improvement of the sediment balance and continuity, sediment transport, and morphology; and (iii) national and bilateral projects on sediment transport processes and management.