(RECEIVED FOR PUBLICATIONJULY 17,1950) Themostreliable method forRhesus group determination isprobably thestandard tubemethod(Landsteiner andWiener, 1941; Boorman, Dodd,andMollison, 1942; Taylor, 1943). Thistechnique hasonlyoneserious disadvantage: itmaytakeaslong astwohours toperform, although occasional high-avidity anti-D sera will give clearcutresults in30minutes orevenless. Foremergency Rhesus typing aconsiderably quicker procedure isdesirable. Rapidmethods whichhavebeendescribed include theChowncapillary tubetest (Chown, 1944;ChownandLewis, 1946) andthe Diamondslide test (Diamond andAbelson, 1945). Mollison, Mourant, andRace haverecommended centrifuging after tenminutes' incubation asa meansof accelerating agglutination inthetubemethod. Inpre-transfusion Rhesus grouping inthis laboratory, ithasbeenthepractice forsometimetousetheChownmethod.Theresults werechecked bythetube method carried outbyadifferent observer working inaseparate room.Whereboth tests wereinagreement, itwasassumed thatthecorrect result hadbeenfound: whenever discrepancies occurred, investigations wererepeated until noreasonable doubt remained. After several hundred parallel observations hadbeenmadeinthis way,itbecame clear that theChowntest, atanyratewiththetechnique inuse, was notaltogether satisfactory: bothfalse positive andfalse negative results wereoccasionally encountered. We therefore decided tocarry outanumber ofexperiments to trytodiscover thereasons forincorrect results intheChowntest, andtodetermine asfaraspossible theoptimum conditions forthetest. Atthesametimeatrial ofthe tubecentrifuging methodwasmadeinparallel withtheother twotechniques. Weaiminthis paper tocompare thereliability ofthree methods forRhesus group determination asusedinaroutine laboratory; todrawattention tosomesources of error intheChowntest ;andtodescribe theconditions inwhichsatisfactory results canbeobtained withthetubecentrifuging method. Methods TheChownTest.-A thick suspension ofcells intheir ownserum isobtained byshaking uptheremains ofaclotted specimen ofblood after mostoftheserumhasbeenremoved. This isallowed tofall through acolumn ofanti-D serum inacapillary tubesetupinasmall lumpofplasticine andinclined atanangle of45°.Approximately equal volumes ofcell suspension andanti-D serum areused. Thetest iscarried outatroomtemperature andread after 15minutes. Thistechnique issubstantially thesameasthat advocated byMollison et al. (1948). Standard vaccine capillary tubes havebeenusedinmostoftheexperiments, as
Read full abstract