In the context of valorizing underutilized crops, this study investigated the starch and protein characteristics of chestnut varieties (Balestrera and Rossera) and their potential for use at 15% and 25% in reformulating gluten-free baked snacks and fresh pasta. Chestnut varieties differ in protein and starch content (Balestrera > Rossera), as well as in amylose, dietary fiber, and lipids (Balestrera < Rossera). Differences in starch and amylose content affected starch gelatinization (Balestrera < Rossera), pasting and retrogradation properties, and water absorption capacity at 90 °C (Balestrera > Rossera). No differences in water and oil absorption capacity and mixing properties were observed, neither in the protein profile nor in the nature of protein aggregates. Both varieties exhibited a good aptitude for producing gluten-free baked snacks and fresh pasta, even at enrichment levels of 25%. Overall, this study could provide valuable information for the development of gluten-free products using sustainable, underutilized crops.