ABSTRACT Sustainability requires understanding and respecting the ecosystem functioning to plan the use of its resources. Improvised planning plus economic benefits can stimulate unsustainable decisions that lead to complications and obscures the application of appropriate adaptations when a change is required. This paper is a historical review of a reservoir when the dam changes its use from hydroelectric to water supply and then tourism is superimposed on the ecosystem. Data collected from the literature are systematically analyzed to see the effects on basin-reservoir dynamics. The main effect was the increase in the hydraulic retention time of the reservoir that facilitates the accumulation of nutrients and eutrophication, aggravated by the increase in the fixed and floating population stimulated by tourism. The consequent cyanobacteria blooms deteriorate the landscape, become a health risk and cancels the use of the reservoir to tourism. The increase in emerging compounds detected in the treatment plant effluent discharged into the reservoir poses a risk to aquatic species and the water supply. These results are analyzed in light of the objectives and dimensions of Sustainability. Recommendations include modifying Goal 1 of SDO 8, because it is shown that an annual growth of 7% of GDP in developing countries threatens their natural resources.