Restricted Developmental Potential Research Articles

Comparison of Gene Expression During Preimplantation Development Between Diploid and Haploid Mouse Embryos1

Haploid development is a normal part of the life cycle for some animals, but it has not been observed in mammals. Studies in mice have revealed that the preimplantation developmental potential of haploid embryos is significantly impaired relative to diploid embryos. The reasons for the severely limited developmental potential of haploid embryos in mammals have not been discerned. To examine the effects of haploid development on gene expression, and in particular on X-linked gene expression, and to evaluate to what degree newer techniques of producing and culturing such embryos might affect developmental potential, haploid and diploid parthenogenetic and androgenetic embryos were produced and reevaluated for developmental potential, genomic integrity, and relative expression levels of specific autosomal and X-linked gene transcripts. Our data confirm the previously observed restriction in haploid developmental potential, eliminate chromosomal abnormalities as a major factor in this restriction, and reveal subtle alterations in gene expression. Haploid parthenogenones display only very subtle alterations in the expression of most mRNAs but a consistent elevation in X-linked Bex1 mRNA expression. Haploid androgenones seem to lack repression of the Pgk1 gene that is seen in diploid androgenones, but this may reflect ongoing loss of those haploid androgenones that experience X chromosome inactivation. The significance and possible explanations for these differences are discussed.

Lineage specific differentiation of pluripotent cells in vitro: a role for extraembryonic cell types.

The controlled differentiation of pluripotent cells will be a prerequisite for many cell therapies. We have previously reported homogeneous conversion of embryonic stem (ES) cells in vitro to early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells, equivalent to early primitive ectoderm, an obligatory differentiation intermediate between ES cells and somatic cell populations. Early primitive ectoderm-like cells differentiated within aggregates form mesodermal lineages at the expense of ectoderm. In this work we demonstrate that the failure of EPL cells to form ectodermal cell types does not reflect an inherent restriction in developmental potential. Early primitive ectoderm-like cells form ectodermal derivatives such as neurons in response to neural inducers such as retinoic acid, or when differentiated in the environment provided by ES cell embryoid bodies. This could be explained by signals from the extraembryonic cell type visceral endoderm which forms in differentiating ES cell but not EPL cell aggregates. Consistent with this possibility, culture of EPL cell aggregates in the presence of visceral endoderm-like signals did not prevent differentiation of the pluripotent cells, but resulted in suppression of mesoderm formation. These results suggest a role for visceral endoderm in regulation of germ layer specification from pluripotent cells, and can be integrated into a model for cell differentiation in vitro and in vivo.

To B or not to B: Pax5 in B-cell development

Nutt, S.L. et al. (1999) Commitment to the B-lymphoid lineage depends on the transcription factor Pax5. Nature 401, 556–562

Multipotent and restricted precursors in the central nervous system.

Acquisition of cell type-specific properties in the nervous system is likely a process of sequential restriction in developmental potential. At least two classes of pluripotent stem cells, neuroepithelial (NEP) stem cells and EGF-dependent neurosphere stem cells, have been identified in distinct spatial and temporal domains. Pluripotent stem cells likely generate central nervous system (CNS) and peripheral nervous system (PNS) derivatives via the generation of intermediate lineage-restricted precursors that differ from each other and from multipotent stem cells. Neuronal precursors termed neuronal-restricted precursors (NRPs), multiple classes of glial precursors termed glial-restricted precursors (GRPs), oligodendrocyte-type 2 astrocytes (O2As), astrocyte precursor cells (APCs), and PNS precursors termed neural crest stem cells (NCSCs) have been identified. Multipotent stem cells and restricted precursor cells can be isolated from embryonic stem (ES) cell cultures providing a non-fetal source of such cells. Analysis in multiple species illustrates similarities between rat, mouse, and human cell differentiation raising the possibility that similar factors and markers may be used to isolate precursor cells from human tissue or ES cells. Anat Rec (New Anat): 257:137-143, 1999.

Restriction of developmental potential during divergence of the enteric and sympathetic neuronal lineages.

In the peripheral nervous system, enteric and sympathetic neurons develop from multipotent neural crest cells. While local environmental signals in the gut and in the region of the sympathetic ganglia play a role in the choice of cell fate, little is known about the mechanisms that underlie restriction to specific neuronal phenotypes. We investigated the divergence and restriction of the enteric and sympathetic neuronal lineages using immuno-isolated neural crest-derived cells from the gut and sympathetic ganglia. Analysis of neuronal and lineage-specific mRNAs and proteins indicated that neural crest-derived cells from the gut and sympathetic ganglia had initiated neuronal differentiation and phenotypic divergence by E14.5 in the rat. We investigated the developmental potential of these cells using expression of tyrosine hydroxylase as a marker for a sympathetic phenotype. Tyrosine hydroxylase expression was examined in neurons that developed from sympathetic and enteric neuroblasts under the following culture conditions: culture alone; coculture with gut monolayers to promote enteric differentiation; or coculture with dorsal aorta monolayers to promote noradrenergic differentiation. Both enteric and sympathetic neuroblasts displayed developmental plasticity at E14.5. Sympathetic neuroblasts downregulated tyrosine hydroxylase in response to signals from the gut environment and enteric neuroblasts increased expression of tyrosine hydroxylase when grown on dorsal aorta or in the absence of other cell types. Tracking of individual sympathetic cells displaying a neuronal morphology at the time of plating indicated that neuroblasts retained phenotypic plasticity even after initial neuronal differentiation had occurred. By E19.5 both enteric and sympathetic neuroblasts had undergone a significant loss of their developmental potential, with most neuroblasts retaining their lineage-specific phenotype in all environments tested. Together our data indicate that the developmental potential of enteric and sympathetic neuroblasts becomes restricted over time and that this restriction takes place not as a consequence of initial neuronal differentiation but during the period of neuronal maturation. Further, we have characterized a default pathway of adrenergic differentiation in the enteric nervous system and have defined a transient requirement for gut-derived factors in the maintenance of the enteric neuronal phenotype.

Cell differentiation in the embryonic mammalian spinal cord.

The acquisition of cell type specific properties in the spinal cord is a process of a sequential restriction in developmental potential. Multipotent neuroepithelial stem cells (NEP cells) can give rise to all the major cell types in the central nervous system. The generation of these multiple cell types occurs via the generation of intermediate precursor cells, which are restricted in their differentiation potential, but are still able to give rise to more than one cell type. These intermediate precursor cells are different from NEP cells and are different from each other. We have identified neuronal restricted precursor cells (NRP's) which can only generate neurons but no longer glial cells and glial restricted precursor cells (GRP's), which give rise to glial cells but not to neurons. These intermediate precursor cells can be purified and expanded in vitro and might offer a new tool for gene discovery, drug screening and transplantation approaches.

Cell lineage in the developing neural tube

Acquisition of cell type specific properties in the spinal cord is a process of sequential restriction in developmental potential. A multipotent stem cell of the nervous system, the neuroepithelial cell, generates central nervous system and peripheral nervous system derivatives via the generation of intermediate lineage restricted precursors that differ from each other and from neuroepithelial cells. Intermediate lineage restricted neuronal and glial precursors termed neuronal restricted precursors and glial restricted precursors, respectively, have been identified. Differentiation is influenced by extrinsic environmental signals that are stage and cell type specific. Analysis in multiple species illustrates similarities between chick, rat, mouse, and human cell differentiation. The utility of obtaining these precursor cell types for gene discovery, drug screening, and therapeutic applications is discussed.

Cell lineage in the developing neural tube

Acquisition of cell type specific properties in the spinal cord is a process of sequential restriction in developmental potential. A multipotent stem cell of the nervous system, the neuroepithelial cell, generates central nervous system and peripheral nervous system derivatives via the generation of intermediate lineage restricted precursors that differ from each other and from neuroepithelial cells. Intermediate lineage restricted neuronal and glial precursors termed neuronal restricted precursors and glial restricted precursors, respectively, have been identified. Differentiation is influenced by extrinsic environmental signals that are stage and cell type specific. Analysis in multiple species illustrates similarities between chick, rat, mouse, and human cell differentiation. The utility of obtaining these precursor cell types for gene discovery, drug screening, and therapeutic applications is discussed.

2 Insights into Development and Genetics from Mouse Chimeras

This chapter discusses the production and characteristics of mouse chimeras. The chapter discusses some of the major contributions to mouse developmental biology and genetics. The chapter focuses on recent chimera studies that provide insights into mouse developmental genetics. The availability of new transgenic lineage markers during the past decade has significantly improved the power of chimeras for studies of cell mixing and organogenesis, and the introduction of green fluorescent protein as an alternative transgenic lineage marker should further enhance this capability. The greatest impact of the new transgenic markers, however, has been to provide the means to analyze the developmental potential of genetically abnormal cells, including those with mutations (including genetic knockouts), cytogenetic abnormalities, or imprinting anomalies. This increased analytical power accounts for the resurgent interest in using chimeras for phenotypic analysis. The analysis of Mash2 and nodal illustrates how the analytical power of chimeras can be enhanced by the incorporation of cells with a restricted developmental potential. It is reported that chimeric rescue analysis plays an increasingly important role in the phenotypic evaluation of numerous new mutations that are being produced by genetic knockout techniques.

In vitro-generated neural precursors participate in mammalian brain development.

During embryogenesis, pluripotent stem cells segregate into daughter lineages of progressively restricted developmental potential. In vitro, this process has been mimicked by the controlled differentiation of embryonic stem cells into neural precursors. To explore the developmental potential of these cell-culture-derived precursors in vivo, we have implanted them into the ventricles of embryonic rats. The transplanted cells formed intraventricular neuroepithelial structures and migrated in large numbers into the brain tissue. Embryonic-stem-cell-derived neurons, astrocytes, and oligodendrocytes incorporated into telencephalic, diencephalic, and mesencephalic regions and assumed phenotypes indistinguishable from neighboring host cells. These observations indicate that entirely in vitro-generated neural precursors are able to respond to environmental signals guiding cell migration and differentiation and have the potential to reconstitute neuronal and glial lineages in the central nervous system.

Miranda directs Prospero to a daughter cell during Drosophila asymmetric divisions

Asymmetric cell division is a general process used in many developmental contexts to create two differently fated cells from a single progenitor cell. Intrinsic mechanisms like the asymmetric transmission of cell-fate determinants during cell division, and extrinsic cell-interaction mechanisms, can mediate asymmetric divisions. During embryonic development of the Drosophila central nervous system, neural stem cells called neuroblasts divide asymmetrically to produce another multipotent neuroblast and a ganglion mother cell (GMC) of more restricted developmental potential. Intrinsic mechanisms promote asymmetric division of neuroblasts: for example, the transcription factor Prospero localizes to the basal cell cortex of mitotic neuroblasts and then segregates exclusively into the GMC, which buds off from the basal side of the neuroblast. In the GMC, Prospero translocates to the nucleus, where it establishes differential gene expression between sibling cells. Here we report the identification of a gene, miranda, which encodes a new protein that co-localizes with Prospero in mitotic neuroblasts, tethers Prospero to the basal cortex of mitotic neuroblasts, directing Prospero into the GMC, and releases Prospero from the cell cortex within GMCs. miranda thus creates intrinsic differences between sibling cells by mediating the asymmetric segregation of a transcription factor into only one daughter cell during neural stem-cell division.

In vitro tracking of IL-7 responsiveness and gene expression during commitment of bipotent B-cell/macrophage progenitors

Background The development of B lymphocytes from multipotent hematopoietic stem cells occurs through a series of intermediate cell types with increasingly restricted developmental potential. Despite intensive investigation, the underlying basis for commitment to a given lineage or the restriction in developmental potential of multipotent cells is unknown. To gain insight into this process we have developed an in vitro system that tracks a bipotent progenitor, which has the capacity to give rise to both B lymphocytes and macrophages, as it makes the transition to a B-lineage-committed precursor. The development of mature B lymphocytes from bipotent progenitors is dependent on interleukin 7 (IL-7), a pre-B-cell growth factor, in addition to other stromal-cell-derived factors such as IL-11 and mast cell growth factor (MGF). IL-7 acts on pre-B lymphocytes, but the stage of differentiation at which B-lineage cells become responsive to this factor, and its potential role in lineage commitment have not been investigated thoroughly. Here, we examine the requirements for IL-7 during the development of B lymphocytes from bipotent progenitors. Furthermore, we define onset of B-lineage-associated gene expression during the development of committed B-lineage cells under defined culture conditions.Results We demonstrate that, under our experimental conditions, bipotent progenitors commit to differentiation through either the B or macrophage lineages within the first 3 days of culture. Cells that require IL-7 for survival first develop on day 3 of culture; however, commitment to the B lineage occurs at the same frequency in the presence or absence of this factor. After day 3 of culture, IL-7 is required both for the proliferation and survival of committed B-lineage progenitors and for the expression of several B-cell-associated genes, such as λ5, VpreB, mb-1 and Rag1.Conclusions Our results demonstrate that the growth factor combination of IL-11 and MGF provides sufficient support for bipotent progenitors to commit to either the B or the macrophage lineage. Single-cell cloning assays revealed that IL-7 does not influence the decision to commit to the B lineage, despite the observation that the bipotent cells potentially respond to IL-7, as indicated by an increase in cell number, prior to the commitment event. Furthermore, the addition of IL-7 to cells developing along the B-cell pathway promotes the expression of mRNA transcripts which encode several B-cell-specific genes.

Transcription Factors and Hematopoietic Development

Transcription Factors and Hematopoietic Development

A functional analysis of imprinting in parthenogenetic embryonic stem cells

A detailed analysis of the developmental potential of parthenogenetic embryonic stem cells (PGES) was made in vivo and in vitro, and a comparison was made with the development of cells from parthenogenetic embryos (PG). In vivo, in chimeras with normal host cells (N), PGES cells showed a restricted tissue distribution consistent with that of PG cells, suggesting faithful imprinting in PGES cells with respect to genes involved in lineage allocation and differentiation. Restricted developmental potential was also observed in teratomas formed by ectopic transfer under the kidney capsule. In contrast, the classic phenotype of growth retardation normally observed in PG<==>N chimeras was not seen, suggesting aberrant regulation in PGES cells of genes involved in growth regulation. We also analysed the expression of known imprinted genes after ES cell differentiation. Igf2, H19 and Igf2r were all appropriately expressed in the PGES derived cells following induction of differentiation in vitro with all-trans retinoic acid or DMSO, when compared with control (D3) and androgenetic ES cells (AGES). Interestingly, H19 was found to be expressed at high levels following differentiation of the AGES cells. Due to the unexpected normal growth regulation of PGES<==>N chimeras we also examined Igf2 expression in PGES derived cells differentiated in vivo and found that this gene was still repressed. Our studies show that PGES cells provide a valuable in vitro model system to study the effects of imprinting on cell differentiation and they also provide invaluable material for extensive molecular studies on imprinted genes. In addition, the aberrant growth phenotype observed in chimeras has implications for mechanisms that regulate the somatic establishment and maintenance of some imprints. This is of particular interest as aberrant imprinting has recently been invoked in the etiology of some human diseases.

In Vitro Clonal Analysis of Mouse Neural Crest Development

Analysis of lineage segregation during mammalian neural crest development has not been sufficiently performed due to technical difficulties. In the present study, therefore, we established a clonal culture system of mouse neural crest cells in order to analyze developmental potentials of individual neural crest cells and their patterns of lineage segregation. 12-O-Tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA) and cholera toxin (CT) were applied to culture medium to trigger melanogenic differentiation of mouse neural crest cells. Three morphologically distinct types of clones were observed. (1) "Pigmented clones" consisted of melanocytes only, suggesting that the clone-forming cells were committed to the melanogenic lineage. These clones were observed only in the presence of TPA and CT. The proportion of this type of clone (8%) was much lower than that of the equivalent type of clone in quail trunk neural crest (40-60%; Sieber-Blum and Cohen, 1980, Dev. Biol. 80, 96-106). It therefore appears that the segregation pattern to the melanogenic lineage during mouse neural crest development in vitro differs quantitatively from that in the quail. (2) "Mixed clones" consisted of pigmented and unpigmented cells. Like pigmented clones, they were observed only in the presence of TPA and CT. The clones contained up to four types of cells: melanocytes, S100-positive cells (Schwann cells or melanogenic precursor cells), serotonin (5-HT)-positive autonomic neuron-like cells, and substance P (SP)-immunoreactive sensory neuron-like cells. Thus, at least some mixed clone-forming cells are pluripotent. (3) Two classes of "unpigmented clones" were observed that consisted of unpigmented cells only. These clones developed in the presence and absence of TPA and CT. Unpigmented clones in one class contained up to three types of cells as well as other, as yet unidentified cells: S100-, 5-HT-, and SP-positive cells. This observation suggests that at least some of these clones originate from cells with a partially restricted developmental potential. Clones in another class consisted of S100- or SP-positive cells only. These clones might be derived from cells restricted to the SP-positive neuronal cell or melanocyte/Schwann cell lineage. The present data indicate that at initiation of migration, the mouse neural crest of the trunk region is a heterogeneous population of cells containing pluripotent cells, cells with a restricted developmental potential, and cells apparently committed to the melanogenic cell lineage.

Pluripotent and Developmentally Restricted Neural-Crest-Derived Cells in Posterior Visceral Arches

The early migratory cells of the posterior rhombencephalic neural crest consist of a heterogeneous population of pluripotent and developmentally restricted neural crest cells (Ito and Sieber-Blum, Dev. Biol. 148, 95-106, 1991). To determine if changes in developmental capacities occur during migration, the developmental potentials of posterior visceral arch mesenchymal cells were investigated by in vitro clonal analysis. Most of these cells consisted of the post-migratory cells of the posterior rhombencephalic neural crest. Four morphologically distinct types of clones were observed, and the cells within these clones expressed characteristic phenotypes as shown by their binding of antibodies against cell type-specific markers: (1) "DP" clones consisted of densely packed polygonal cells, with flattened large cells located predominantly at the periphery of these clones. Immunocytochemical analyses showed that DP clones contained smooth muscle cells, connective tissue cells, chondrocytes, and serotonin (5-HT)-positive neurons, and over 90% of the cells per clone were HNK-1 positive. This suggests that DP clone-forming cells are pluripotent neural-crest-derived cells with the capacity to develop into ectomesenchymal derivatives and serotonergic neurons. (2) "DS" clones consisted of densely packed spindle-shaped cells. These clones included smooth muscle cells, connective tissue cells, and chondrocytes. By contrast, neuronal phenotypes were not present. An average of 0.4% of the cells per clone were HNK-1 positive. DS clones appear to be formed by neural-crest-derived cells that are partially restricted, expressing ectomesenchymal phenotypes only. (3) "DF" clones consisted of densely packed small cells and flattened large cells. Although no HNK-1-positive cells were found in DF clones, these clones contained connective tissue cells and/or smooth muscle cells. DF clones appear to be derived from bipotent cells with the ability to differentiate into connective tissue cells and smooth muscle cells, or cells committed to the connective tissue cell lineage. (4) "LF" clones consisted of loosely arranged, flattened large cells. These clones did not contain HNK-1-positive cells. The clones consisted entirely of smooth muscle cells. Therefore, LF clones are most likely formed by precursors that are committed to the smooth muscle cell lineage. These results indicate the presence of pluripotent neural-crest-derived cells, cells with a restricted developmental potential, and apparently committed cells in the posterior visceral arch. Pluripotent cells can generate up to four neuronal and nonneuronal phenotypes. Other cells are restricted to ectomesenchymal cell types, and the proportion of these cells in the posterior visceral arch changes with progressing embryonic development. The present data in combination with our previous study (Ito and Sieber-Blum, Dev. Biol. 148, 95-106, 1991) suggest a characteristic pattern of lineage segregation during posterior rhombencephalic neural crest development, indicating that specification of some cell types can occur at the final sites of the neural crest cell localization.

Characterization of abnormal one pronuclear human oocytes by morphology, cytogenetics and in-situ hybridization

The morphology, chromosomal constitution and developmental capability of abnormal human oocytes (94/3500 oocytes; 2.7%) which after insemination exhibited only one pronucleus were examined. The majority of one pronuclear oocytes exhibited two or more distinct polar bodies. Dividing oocytes showed irregular chromosome distribution from haploid to diploid. Embryos resulting from abnormal oocytes displayed limited developmental potential. Many of them underwent fragmentation or were arrested at the 2- or 8-cell stage of development, and only some reached the morula or blastocyst state (11/35 oocytes). In approximately 45% (15/33) of examined oocytes, decondensed sperm heads or tiny nucleus-like structures were found in addition to a single nucleus. Chromosome Y was also detected in chromosomal preparations in approximately 10% of the oocytes by in-situ hybridization utilizing the human Y chromosome-specific DNA probe (DYZ3). These observations provided strong evidence that many of these oocytes originated from fertilized oocytes. The origin of the other one pronuclear oocytes could not be determined. Parthenogenetic activation of some oocytes cannot be excluded and other explanations concerning the origin of abnormal oocytes are discussed.

Ontogeny, pathology, oncology.

This article traces the history of using embryo-derived stem cells for genetic manipulation--first teratocarcinoma stem cells and then embryonic stem cells. It encompasses several decades of research investigating the similarity between cellular mechanisms of normal growth and differentiation in the embryo and abnormal growth and differentiation in neoplasia. The limited developmental potential of teratocarcinoma-derived, embryonal carcinoma (EC) stem cells is contrasted to the totipotentiality displayed by embryonic stem (ES) cells derived directly from early embryos. From early attempts to select mutants in EC cells in culture to the spectacular success of targeting genes in ES cells by homologous recombination, the different lines of developmental, genetic and cancer research have converged to open vast new areas of possibility in genetic manipulation.

Distribution of pluripotent neural crest cells in the embryo and the role of brain‐derived neurotrophic factor in the commitment to the primary sensory neuron lineage

Many early migratory neural crest cells are pluripotent in the sense that their progeny are able to generate more than one differentiated phenotype (Sieber-Blum and Cohen, 1980, Dev. Biol. 80:95-106; Baroffio, Dupin, and Le Douarin, 1988, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 85:5325-5329; Bronner-Fraser and Fraser, 1988, Nature 335:161-164; Sieber-Blum, 1989a, Science 243:1608-1611; Ito and Sieber-Blum, 1991, Dev. Biol. 148:95-106). At trunk levels, the neural crest contains two classes (Sieber-Blum and Cohen, 1980) and at posterior rhombencephalic levels, three different classes of pluripotent cells (Ito and Sieber-Blum, 1991). We investigated cell differentiation by in vitro clonal analysis to determine when in development the pool of pluripotent neural crest cells becomes exhausted. The data suggest that different classes of pluripotent cells, precursor cells with more restricted developmental potentials, and apparently committed cells, exist at sites of advanced migration (posterior branchial arches) and even at target sites of neural crest cell differentiation [posterior branchial arches, dorsal root ganglia (DRG), sympathetic ganglia (SG), and epidermal ectoderm]. Some putative classes of pluripotent cells persist well into the second half of embryonic development. These observations have implications for our understanding of the mechanisms that control neural crest cell migration and differentiation. They support the idea that cues originating from the microenvironment affect differentiation of pluripotent neural crest cells. One such signal appears to be brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF). In the presence of BDNF, but not nerve growth factor (NGF), there is a significant increase in the number of neural crest cells per colony that express a sensory neuron-specific marker. Because this increase is not accompanied by a corresponding increase in the total number of cells per colony, this suggests that BDNF plays a role in cell type specification.

1219 Early restriction of developmental potential in neocortical neuroepithelial cells for a molecular phenotype

1219 Early restriction of developmental potential in neocortical neuroepithelial cells for a molecular phenotype