This study focuses on the resilience of gut microbiota during a five-month multi-interventional nutrition trial. The modulatory effects of beta-glucan, rye bran and two dietary fiber mixtures on the fecal pH and compositional changes of the microbiome of healthy subjects were studied. To analyze the stability of intestinal microbiota, we collected an extensive dataset of sequential fecal samples (23–29 from each participant) during a week of the base, beta-glucan consumption and wash-out periods accompanied by the collection of daily food diary data. Microbiota analyses were also conducted after the end of each fiber intake and wash-out period, along with measurements of fecal organic acids and pH. Based on the dominant bacterial taxa, two prevalent microbiota types were identified. The Prevotella-type microbiota responded more to the tested dietary fibers, while the Bacteroides-type microbiota was the least affected. Three microbiota types could not be clustered and behaved differently. Although we noted individual effects of definite fibers on participants’ gut microbiota and metabolic profile, relative abundances of bacteria remained stable in the base period (z-scores − 2.2 to 2.3). In most cases, the bacterial abundances of the final samples remained within the normal fluctuation range stressing out the resilience of healthy microbiota. The pH of all fecal samples varied between 6.1 and 8.3 and was associated with the concentration of organic acids and microbial composition. The effect of dietary fibers on the metabolism of fecal microbiota clearly depended on the individual microbiota type. Combining the analysis of gut microbiota with knowledge of the properties of dietary fibers would provide a powerful strategy for nutrition guidance and disease prevention.