Abstract The objective of this study was to determine genetic parameter estimates for age at first calving (AFC) in Red Angus and Simmental heifers. The ability for a heifer to calve earlier has implications on calf performance and the heifer's successive re-breeding. Heifer pregnancy data were obtained from International Genetic Solutions, where females with exposure records were included in the population. Females with a subsequent record of calving between 630 and 810 days of age were included in the analysis. Females with embryo transfer or multiple birth progeny were excluded. Records from single-animal and contemporary groups with no variation were eliminated and after data filtering, there were 149,379 Simmental with a mean Simmental breed proportion of 0.58 ± 0.25, and 83,191 Red Angus records with a mean Red Angus breed proportion of 0.80 ± 0.13. A 3-generation pedigree file containing 291,530 Simmental animals with 25,585 unique sires and 161,921 unique dams, and a 3-generation pedigree file containing 174,914 Red Angus animals with 19,733 unique sires and 99,464 unique dams were used for the separate analysis. The mean AFC in Simmental and Red Angus was 724.8 ± 28.64 d, and 724.2 ± 29.93 d, respectively. Data for each breed were modeled separately using a single trait animal model with random additive genetic and residual effects, and the fixed effect of contemporary group using ASReml 3.0. Contemporary group was defined as breeder, herd, year born, birth group and yearling group. The additive, residual, and phenotypic variances for Simmental were 120.08, 520.37, and 640.45 d2, respectively. For Red Angus, 85.67, 543.56, and 629.24 d2 were the additive, residual, and phenotypic variances, respectively. The heritability estimates of AFC for Simmental and Red Angus were 0.19 ± 0.0059 and 0.14 ± 0.0076, respectively. These results demonstrate AFC in days is lowly to moderately heritable. Lower residual and higher additive variance in Simmental compared to Red Angus may suggest the Simmental population has larger variation for underlying fertility influences such as age at puberty. The mean breeding values for AFC in Simmental was 6.1 ± 8.0, with a minimum of -24.4 and maximum of 54.7. Whereas Red Angus breeding values for AFC resulted in a mean of 4.0 ± 5.6 and a minimum and maximum of -16.1, and 37.3, respectively. The comparable heritability estimates, low standard error, and range in breeding values suggest selection for improved AFC can be attained. It is worth further exploring the impact of breed effects and heterosis influences on age at first calving. While this study does not account for heifers that did not calve in their first year, tandem selection for heifer fertility and age at calving should be heavily emphasized due to the economic importance of both traits.