BackgroundAntidepressant treatments can differ in the depressive symptoms that improve the least and the most. The profile of symptom change with TMS has yet to be characterized. MethodsThe PHQ-9 and QIDS-SR were administered to 578 patients with MDD who scored ≥ 10 on both instruments at baseline and received ≥ 36 TMS sessions. For both instruments, differences in severity among symptoms were characterized before and following TMS. The extent to which TMS produced a non-specific, generalized improvement across symptoms or a symptom-specific profile of improvement was evaluated. ResultsSymptoms differed markedly in average severity at baseline, with the profiles consistent across the two instruments. Comparisons of symptom severity before and after TMS produced very large main effects of time (Pre vs Post) and inventory item, but only small interaction effects, indicating limited symptom specificity in improvement. There was widespread improvement across symptoms, and the limited apparent symptom specificity was largely due to floor effects in specific symptoms present at baseline. Comparisons of three TMS protocols, Left, Sequential Bilateral, and Mixture, revealed no differences in profile of symptom change. Following TMS, the severity of residual symptoms in responders who did not remit, while substantially improved, largely mirrored the baseline profile. LimitationsThe findings derived from two self-report instruments that assess nine criterion depressive symptoms. Corroboration with clinician ratings is needed. ConclusionsTreatment of depression with TMS results in a marked downward shift of the baseline profile of symptom severity. There is large, generalized improvement across symptoms and limited symptom specificity.
Read full abstract