The instability of erythropoietin receptor agonists (ERAs, i.e., EPO) in urine presents a challenge to their detectability in doping control samples; however, this issue is not often seen in blood (serum) samples. With the anti-doping field beginning to transition into alternative blood collection technologies, it is important to understand recombinant EPO (rEPO) detectability in serum samples collected from one such capillary collection device, the Tasso+ SST. Twelve individuals were administered a single, 40 IU/kg dose of rEPO (epoetin alfa, EPOGEN®). Following administration, matched urine, venous serum, and capillary serum samples were concurrently collected. Urine aliquots were subject to various storage times and temperatures mimicking shipping conditions of doping control urine samples to assess EPO stability, while other urine aliquots, venous serum, and capillary serum aliquots were frozen until analysis to understand rEPO detectability across all three matrices. EPO and rEPO instability was identified in urine collected from 8 of 12 participants, especially in aliquots stored at room temperature and 37°C. In some of these unstable samples, rEPO was still detectable, while in others, no recombinant nor endogenous EPO was detectable and would have resulted in negative sample reports. Analyzing the concurrently collected urine, venous, and capillary serum samples, rEPO detectability was identical across the three matrices. In most cases, rEPO was detectable for at least 168 h post-administration. Noting greater stability in blood compared with urine, it is recommended that anti-doping authorities utilize this novel capillary serum collection technology to improve overall ERA detectability in doping control samples.