Repeat Smear Research Articles

Clinical significance of atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance in postmenopausal women

Glandular atypia in Papanicolaou (Pap) smears from postmenopausal women is encountered frequently. This finding can be the result of artifactual alterations such as drying artifacts and inflammatory changes or may represent a squamous or glandular, preneoplastic or neoplastic process. Therefore, it is important to determine the clinical implication of a diagnosis of atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance (AGUS) in postmenopausal patients. A total of 30,036 Pap smears were obtained from postmenopausal women between 1995 and 1997. Among these smears, 154 (0.51%) had a diagnosis of AGUS. Follow-up was available for 133 patients (86.4%); 110 patients (82.7%) had histologic follow-up (including cervical biopsy, endocervical [EC] curettage, and/or endometrial [EM] biopsy) and 23 patients (17.3%) had repeat smears. Thirty-six of 110 patients (32.7%) were found to have a clinically significant lesion (defined as a preneoplastic or neoplastic, glandular or squamous lesion) on subsequent histologic follow-up. Nineteen patients (53%) had glandular lesions (15 EM adenocarcinoma [ACA] cases, 2 EC ACA cases, 1 EC adenocarcinoma is situ case, and 1 EM hyperplasia case). Seventeen patients (47%) had a squamous intraepithelial lesion (SIL) (6 cases of low-grade SIL, 9 cases of high-grade [HGIL], and 2 cases of squamous cell carcinoma). Among those patients with repeat Pap smears, five patients had persistent AGUS/atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance and one patient had an SIL. The incidence of AGUS among postmenopausal patients was similar to that of the general population (0.51% vs. 0.56%; P > 0.05). A significant percentage of these patients were found to have a clinically significant lesion on subsequent follow-up. Furthermore, a majority of these lesions were ACA (53%) or HGSIL (26%). The findings of the current study strongly suggest the need for the close follow-up of postmenopausal patients with a diagnosis of AGUS. Cancer (Cancer Cytopathol)

Management guidelines for women with normal colposcopy after low grade cervical abnormalities: population study

Objectives: To develop an evidence based protocol for the follow up of women with low grade cervical abnormalities for whom treatment is not immediately indicated.Design: Population outcome study.Setting: Colposcopy clinic...

Outcome of women referred to colposcopy for persistently inadequate smears.

The outcome of referral to colposcopy of 240 women who had persistently inadequate smears was investigated. Of 232 women who attended colposcopy, 214 (92.2%) had a normal outcome, 12 (5.2%) had low grade abnormalities, and six (2.6%) had high grade abnormalities. This group of women therefore has a negligibly increased risk of harbouring cervical neoplasia. Although not directly comparable, women with a history of previous abnormal cytology did not have a higher risk than those without such a history. Unnecessary colposcopy could have been avoided in the majority of cases if a good quality repeat smear had been taken. Improved smear taker training could decrease the number of referrals. A hospital cytology clinic is proposed as a cost-effective alternative to colposcopy at the first attendance.

Efficacy of Ki-67 antigen staining in Papanicolaou (Pap) smears in post-menopausal women with atypia--an audit.

In cervical smears from post-menopausal women with mucosal atrophy it can be difficult to distinguish atrophic epithelial cell groups from neoplastic cell groups on cytomorphological criteria only. The consequence of post-menopausal atypia is that the woman is referred for a repeat smear after local oestrogen treatment or for colposcopy. We investigated whether immunocytochemical expression of Ki-67 (MIB-1) on the primary Papanicolaou-stained smear could be of any diagnostic help. Our data showed that negative Ki-67 expression is a very reliable indicator of a normal atrophic cell pattern, and by using this method on the original smear we were able to reduce the false-positive cytologic diagnoses by 86%.

Improving cervical cytology screening in a remote, high risk population.

To evaluate the use of the ThinPrep method to reduce rates of unsatisfactory Papanicolaou (Pap) smears in women in remote communities. Prospectively collected samples were split and screened conventionally and by ThinPrep at the Queensland Cytology Service. Three hundred women having cervical smears taken by a Mobile Women's Health Service nurse or at the antenatal and sexual health clinics of a remote north Queensland community. Number of Pap smears reported as unsatisfactory for evaluation and requiring a repeat smear request. 17.3% of conventionally prepared smears were technically unsatisfactory, compared with 6.3% prepared with ThinPrep. The overall rate of unsatisfactory smears was only 4.3% when both ThinPrep and conventional smears were assessed for a combined report. A significant reduction in the proportion of unsatisfactory Pap smears is possible with the ThinPrep method. Targeted use of ThinPrep in communities with high rates of unsatisfactory smears may prove cost-effective.

Fluid phase endocytosis within buccal mucosal cells of alcohol misusers.

The structure of the oral mucosa is now well characterised, although studies on oral epithelial cell function have received less attention. The aims of this study were to see whether endocytosis could be demonstrated in cells from oral smears and if so, to assess the effect of chronic high alcohol intake on such uptake. Buccal mucosal smears were collected from 135 patients (91 non- or social drinkers, and 44 patients with harmful alcohol use). Name, age, sex, and alcohol history (for alcohol problem patients) were recorded. Cell suspensions were incubated in a solution of bovine serum albumin (BSA)-coated fluorescently labelled latex microspheres (0.02 micron diameter) in Ham's F-10 culture medium for 1 h at 37 degrees C as a marker of fluid phase endocytosis. Uptake of microspheres was confirmed by confocal microscopy, and mean endocytosed fluorescence levels determined by flow cytometry. A repeat smear from 11 of the alcohol patients was taken 9-14 days later. Endocytosis was significantly reduced in both male (P < 0.01) and female (P < 0.01) alcohol problem patients compared to controls. Units of alcohol consumed and cigarettes smoked per day did not show a dose-response correlation with endocytosis in the alcohol problem patients. Apparent abstinence from alcohol had no further effect on endocytic uptake at days 9-14. This study shows that normal oral squamous cells removed as buccal smears readily endocytose fluorescent microspheres and that this capacity can be affected by alcohol. Chronic high alcohol intake would appear to down regulate endocytosis in buccal cells even up to 14 days of abstinence. This may have implications for the pathogenesis of oral mucosal disorders in long-term users.

Prognostic Implications of Cervical Intraepithelial Neoplasia in a Single Cervical Smear

Our aim was to investigate the prognostic implications of a single cervical smear showing cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) in a group of women with a previous series of negative smears, and to estimate their risk of developing histologically confirmed CIN 3. A retrospective case-control study was set up. It consisted of 171 cases and 513 age-matched controls, all with at least 3 negative and no positive smears between 1981 and 1988 inclusive. In all cases CIN had been diagnosed on cytology in 1989, while the controls had remained negative. The women were followed up to the end of 1995. The outcome was recorded in terms of regression, progression, persistence or surgical treatment. In women with a single smear showing CIN 1 or 2, the risk of developing histologically proven CIN 3 was 14 and 26 times that in women with negative smears. Negative control smears in the short term did not exclude subsequent progression. Thus women with a single cervical smear indicating CIN 1 had a greatly enhanced risk of producing a lesion that demanded intervention. Such cases should be observed closely with repeat smears over a period of at least 6 years.

Squamous atypia in the atrophic cervical vaginal smear: a new look at an old problem.

Squamous atypia in postmenopausal (PM) cervical vaginal smears (CVS) only rarely is associated with a biopsy-proven squamous intraepithelial lesion (SIL), and thus most commonly represents an atrophy-associated benign reactive change. To distinguish atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS) and SIL from atrophy-associated benign reactive changes, a review of atypical atrophic PM CVS was performed. Ninety CVS exhibiting an atrophic smear pattern were considered appropriate for study. Repeat smears and/or biopsy after local estrogen therapy were requested to distinguish atrophic/reactive from dysplastic changes. Generally, atrophic CVS exhibit uniform nuclear enlargement in the squamous cell population, which, using the criterion of nuclear enlargement alone, would qualify the majority of these cases to be classified as ASCUS. The nuclear enlargement associated with atrophy resolves with the local application of estrogen. Follow-up after local estrogen treatment was available for 84 of 90 patients and revealed 10 cases of SIL (12%) and 9 cases of ASCUS (11%), 6 of which were favored to be of a reactive etiology. Nuclear features most commonly noted in the cases considered to be ASCUS (nonreactive) and SIL were nuclear hyperchromasia and nuclear contour irregularities. Nuclear enlargement alone is not sufficient for diagnosing ASCUS or SIL in PM CVS. Nuclear enlargement in squamous cells is an expected normal reactive change present in PM CVS that resolves with the application of local estrogen. Nuclear hyperchromasia and irregular nuclear contours remain the most reliable cellular characteristics for diagnosing SIL in atrophic CVS.

A registry-based study of follow-up failures in the screening experience of cervical cancer patients

Amadori A, Gentilini P, Bucchi L, Innocenti MP, Falcini F, Martini F, Fabbri M, Liverani M, Danesi S, Piantini B, Milandri C, Saragoni L, Amadori D. A registry-based study of follow-up failures in the screening experience of cervical cancer patients. Int J Gynecol Cancer 1998; 8: 251–256. Although all components of cervical screening are at risk of error, most studies of the previous screening experience of cervical cancer patients addressed only the false negative cytology results. Other reports showed the importance of screening failures not attributable to the Pap smear. We studied the relative frequency of all types of error observed in the screening history of 115 cervical cancer cases (median age, 60; range, 23–89) registered with the population-based Romagna Cancer Registry in Forli (northern Italy) between 1986 and 1993. For each case, a search was made for all cytology, colposcopy, biopsy, and treatment reports issued prior to diagnosis. Eighty-one (70.4%) patients had never had a Pap smear. Eight (7.0%) were diagnosed at their first test. Twenty-six patients (22.6%) had had at least one previous smear. Among these, 10 were screened during the five years prior to diagnosis: three patients had false negative cytology results, one patient did not comply with the recommendation for an early repeat smear, two patients with positive cytology results underwent colposcopy with considerable delay (7 and 9 months), one patient had a negative colposcopy (without biopsy), and three patients had biopsies histologically reported as negative. An overview of the registry-based studies of screening histories reported so far from Italy (total number of cases 262) demonstrated that patients with serious shortcomings in follow-up after smear test, colposcopy, biopsy, clinical assessment, and treatment accounted for a substantial proportion of screening failures.

The Value of Repeat Pap Smear at the Time of Initial Colposcopy

Abstract Objective. The objective was to determine if repeating a Pap smear at the time of an initial colposcopy has sufficient clinical benefit to justify its clinical and financial costs. Methods. The records were reviewed of all patients who had an initial colposcopy at Queens Hospital Center between 1984 and 1995. Data were gathered regarding the referral cytology, the cytology done at the time of colposcopy, and the results of any biopsies which were taken. The terminology for cytology and histology done prior to 1989 was adjusted to the Bethesda classification system. A repeat Pap smear was defined as clinically valuable if it would have changed the patient's management, i.e., if it suggested more advanced disease than the referral Pap and that the disease was not identified on the colposcopically directed biopsy. Results. Two thousand nine hundred sixty-nine records were reviewed. In 139 cases, no Pap smear was repeated at the time of colposcopy. Of the remaining 2830 women, only 1347 (47.6%) showed exact correlation between their referral Pap smear and the Pap done at the time of colposcopy. In another 1016 (35.9%), the Pap at colposcopy was within one grade of the referral Pap. In 312 women, the Pap at the time of colposcopy was a higher grade than the referral Pap. However, in 236, the higher grade of disease was detected by the colposcopically directed biopsy. Of the remaining 76 women, 58 had a normal biopsy, but their Pap at the time of colposcopy showed low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (44) or high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HGSIL) (14). Seventeen others had a biopsy showing low-grade dysplasia while the Pap at the time of colposcopy showed HGSIL. In 1 patient, the repeat Pap showed malignant cells while the biopsy showed a high-grade lesion. Based on the triage protocols at our institution, this means that a repeat Pap at the time of colposcopy would have indicated a cone biopsy in 31 patients (1.1%) and more careful follow-up of another 44 patients (1.6%). Skipping the repeat Pap smear would not have resulted in any missed cancers. In our series of 2830 patients, the cost savings of skipping the repeat smear would have been $68,580 or $24.23 per patient. On a national level, skipping the repeat smear would save more than $24,000,000 annually. Conclusion. Using current triage protocols at our institution, repeating the Pap smear at the time of an initial colposcopy would have changed the management in 2.7% of patients and indicated a conization in only 1.1% of patients. It is doubtful that this justifies its cost and the potential detrimental effects on the colposcopic examination.

Neoplasia Associated with Atypical Glandular Cells of Undetermined Significance on Cervical Cytology

The clinical importance of atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance (AGUS) on cervicovaginal smear has not been well defined. Between January 1990 and April 1996, 127 smears were reported as showing AGUS changes by the cytopathology division at the University of Massachusetts Medical Center. The medical records of these women were reviewed: 17 women were excluded because of previous hysterectomy or gynecologic cancer, 85 were biopsied, 16 were followed by repeat smears, and 9 were lost to follow-up. Forty-four women had negative biopsies or cervicitis. There were 15 endometrial lesions: 10 hyperplasias (2 with atypia) and 5 adenocarcinomas. Twenty-five women had cervix lesions including 3 endocervical atypias, 12 low-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN), 6 high-grade CIN, one adenocarcinoma in situ, and 3 invasive adenocarcinomas. One patient had ovarian cancer. Two of the 16 women followed by repeat pap smear eventually had a cancer diagnosis: one with cervix cancer and one with colon cancer. We were unable to identify a subgroup of women with AGUS who were at increased risk for serious pathology when we compared multiple demographic variables, symptoms, or the presence of coexistent squamous abnormalities on cervical cytology. The mean age of the 15 women with endometrial lesions was 59.9 years, which was significantly older than those patients with cervix lesions who had a mean age of 38.9 years. The presence of AGUS on cervical cytology is a marker for significant gynecologic neoplasia and should be investigated with colposcopically directed biopsies, endocervical curettage, and, in older women, endometrial biopsy.

The Value of Repeat Pap Smear at the Time of Initial Colposcopy

Objective.The objective was to determine if repeating a Pap smear at the time of an initial colposcopy has sufficient clinical benefit to justify its clinical and financial costs.Methods.The records were reviewed of all patients who had an initial colposcopy at Queens Hospital Center between 1984 and 1995. Data were gathered regarding the referral cytology, the cytology done at the time of colposcopy, and the results of any biopsies which were taken. The terminology for cytology and histology done prior to 1989 was adjusted to the Bethesda classification system. A repeat Pap smear was defined as clinically valuable if it would have changed the patient's management, i.e., if it suggested more advanced disease than the referral Pap and that the disease was not identified on the colposcopically directed biopsy.Results.Two thousand nine hundred sixty-nine records were reviewed. In 139 cases, no Pap smear was repeated at the time of colposcopy. Of the remaining 2830 women, only 1347 (47.6%) showed exact correlation between their referral Pap smear and the Pap done at the time of colposcopy. In another 1016 (35.9%), the Pap at colposcopy was within one grade of the referral Pap. In 312 women, the Pap at the time of colposcopy was a higher grade than the referral Pap. However, in 236, the higher grade of disease was detected by the colposcopically directed biopsy. Of the remaining 76 women, 58 had a normal biopsy, but their Pap at the time of colposcopy showed low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (44) or high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HGSIL) (14). Seventeen others had a biopsy showing low-grade dysplasia while the Pap at the time of colposcopy showed HGSIL. In 1 patient, the repeat Pap showed malignant cells while the biopsy showed a high-grade lesion. Based on the triage protocols at our institution, this means that a repeat Pap at the time of colposcopy would have indicated a cone biopsy in 31 patients (1.1%) and more careful follow-up of another 44 patients (1.6%). Skipping the repeat Pap smear would not have resulted in any missed cancers. In our series of 2830 patients, the cost savings of skipping the repeat smear would have been $68,580 or $24.23 per patient. On a national level, skipping the repeat smear would save more than $24,000,000 annually.Conclusion.Using current triage protocols at our institution, repeating the Pap smear at the time of an initial colposcopy would have changed the management in 2.7% of patients and indicated a conization in only 1.1% of patients. It is doubtful that this justifies its cost and the potential detrimental effects on the colposcopic examination.

Colposcopy as a primary screening test for cervical cancer.

To evaluate the cost effectiveness of screening by colposcopy compared to conventional cytology. A prospective study was performed in the Florence District screening center on 3,000 consecutive women, self referring, who were examined by cytology and colposcopy in a blind fashion. Further assessment was based on cytologic report or on colposcopy-directed punch biopsy. Actual costs of the whole screening process were known. The cost effectiveness of different possible simulated screening scenarios was then determined. Overall, 18 high-grade lesions (CIN3 = 9, CIN2 = 9) were detected. Four different screening scenarios were compared, namely a) cytology alone, b) cytology + repeat smear for ASCUS (atypical squamous cells of undeterminate significance) cases, c) colposcopy + cytology for cases of condyloma at punch biopsy, and d) colposcopy alone. Although they had a higher cost per examined woman (a) = 17.98, b) = 19.40, c) = 23.86, d) = 22.10 US$), scenarios c) and d) had a higher relative sensitivity (a = 44.4, b = 61.1, c = 100, d = 88.8%) and a lower cost per high-grade lesion detected (a = 6,743, b = 5,291, c = 3,977, d = 4,144 US$). Screening by colposcopy is a feasible procedure which is more sensitive and more cost effective than conventional cytology screening. At least in those settings where access to cytopathology may be difficult, screening by colposcopy should be considered as a possible alternative.

Inflammatory Pap Smears in Adolescents: When Should they be Repeated?

Background Papanicolaou (Pap) smears are a routine method of determining gynecological health in sexually active adolescents. Guidelines for management of Pap results of “inflammatory and/or reactive changes” (I/R) are not uniform for this age group. The purpose of this study is to assess the characteristics of teens who have inflammatory Pap smears and those who returned for follow-up in order to formulate recommendations. Methods A chart review was conducted on patients from an adolescent clinic who had at least one I/R Pap smear result in the past three years. An index visit was defined as any visit that yielded an I/R Pap. Data regarding the index visit and subsequent visit, if completed, were included in the analysis. Results There were 142 I/R Pap smears/index visits reviewed in 113 teens. At the index visit, 12% had gonorrhea, 19% had Chlamydia, and 40% had Trichomonas. 55% had no STDs. Of the index Paps, 95 returned for follow-up with a mean time of 5.3 months (range 1.4 – 27). Subsequent Paps were normal in 56% Abnormal results were: 23% I/R, 10% atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS), 10% low grade intraepithelial lesion (LGSIL), and 1% high grade intraepithelial lesion (HGSIL). Significant pathology (ASCUS or greater) was detected as early as 1.6 months after the index visit. Resolution of the inflammatory changes was not associated with a history of SIDs, or any specific SID at the index or follow-up visits. Length of time to follow-up Pap was not a predictor of that result being normal. Four teens had 3 sequential I/R Paps and 12 teens had 2 sequential I/R Paps. Persistence of inflammatory changes was associated with having a previous pregnancy (chi-square, p = .01) and having no STDs at the index visit (chi-square, p = .02). Conclusions Inflammatory and/or reactive Pap smear results should not be ignored in this adolescent population. These results may mask significant underlying pathology and cannot be attributed to STDs. Repeat smears may be done as early as 2 months

Neoplasia Associated with Atypical Glandular Cells of Undetermined Significance on Cervical Cytology

The clinical importance of atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance (AGUS) on cervicovaginal smear has not been well defined. Between January 1990 and April 1996, 127 smears were reported as showing AGUS changes by the cytopathology division at the University of Massachusetts Medical Center. The medical records of these women were reviewed: 17 women were excluded because of previous hysterectomy or gynecologic cancer, 85 were biopsied, 16 were followed by repeat smears, and 9 were lost to follow-up. Forty-four women had negative biopsies or cervicitis. There were 15 endometrial lesions: 10 hyperplasias (2 with atypia) and 5 adenocarcinomas. Twenty-five women had cervix lesions including 3 endocervical atypias, 12 low-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN), 6 high-grade CIN, one adenocarcinomain situ,and 3 invasive adenocarcinomas. One patient had ovarian cancer. Two of the 16 women followed by repeat pap smear eventually had a cancer diagnosis: one with cervix cancer and one with colon cancer. We were unable to identify a subgroup of women with AGUS who were at increased risk for serious pathology when we compared multiple demographic variables, symptoms, or the presence of coexistent squamous abnormalities on cervical cytology. The mean age of the 15 women with endometrial lesions was 59.9 years, which was significantly older than those patients with cervix lesions who had a mean age of 38.9 years. The presence of AGUS on cervical cytology is a marker for significant gynecologic neoplasia and should be investigated with colposcopically directed biopsies, endocervical curettage, and, in older women, endometrial biopsy.

Effects and sustainability of a cervical screening program in remote Aboriginal Australia

We assessed the effects of an organised cervical screening program, using a population-based cervical cytology register, for Aboriginal women in the Fitzroy Valley, a remote part of the Kimberley region of Western Australia. Comparison of age-specific screening rates in the area during 1987-88, 1990-92 and 1993-94 showed that establishing the program in late 1989 was accompanied by dramatic increases in cervical screening rates, ranging from two- to over fourfold, with the largest increases in women aged 50 years and over. Following the departure of the coordinator in early 1993, screening rates decreased to between 76 per cent and 29 per cent of their 1990-92 levels, with the largest decreases occurring in the 40-49 and 60-69 years age groups. Rates were still above 1987-88 levels for most age groups. Of 545 women screened during 1991-92, 65 per cent had undergone a second Pap smear within the follow-up period of two to four years. Among women recommended for a repeat smear in two years, the probability of having a second smear was negatively associated with age (log-rank statistic = 35.58, 4 df, P < 0.0001). Follow-up of smears recommended for repeat in 12 months or earlier was less adequate in 1993-94 (46 per cent) than in 1991-92 (75 per cent). The program was successful in recruiting a large proportion of eligible women within a relatively short time, but coverage, especially of older women, was not sustained after a decline in the functioning of the recall system owing to staffing and organisational changes.

Effects of the Bethesda System on the rate of unsatisfactory Pap smears in spontaneous cervical screening.

In 1990, The Bethesda System (TBS) was introduced into spontaneous cervical screening practice in Ravenna, Italy. Negative/benign reports with the recommendation for early repeat smears (RERS) due to some limitation in sample adequacy were considered no longer acceptable. A monitoring program for the rate of unsatisfactory smears (UNS) was implemented. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effects of such changes in the screening procedure. The frequency of UNS in 1990 was compared with that of UNS+RERS in 1988 (assumed as a baseline year) by the calculation of the standardized rate ratio with the 95% confidence interval (CI). The trend in the standardized rate of UNS from 1990 to 1994 was evaluated by the calculation of the average annual variation with the 95% CI. The immediate effect of TBS (1990; 1988 comparison) was a significant increase in the rate of UNS attributable to scant cellularity, poor fixation and thick areas (rate ratio, 2.35; 95% CI, 2.18 to 2.53) and to the absence of endocervical component (1.45; 95% CI, 1.30 to 1.60). The rate of UNS attributable to the presence of cytolysis, inflammation, blood and foreign material decreased by about 6 times (0.16; 95% CI, 0.13 to 0.19). The midterm effect of TBS (trend from 1990 to 1994) was a decrease in the total rate of UNS by an average of 2.3% per year. The downward trend was significant for smears showing scant cellularity, poor fixation and thick areas (-1.5% per year) and the absence of endocervical component (-0.7% per year). UNS attributable to the presence of cytolysis, inflammation, blood and foreign material stabilized. TBS led to a substantial change in the type of information provided by the cytology report (immediate effect). The monitoring program according to TBS led to a reduction in UNS attributable to sample taker (midterm effect).

Reporting of atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance on cervical smears: Is it significant?

A retrospective 7-mo study (June 1, 1993-December 31, 1993) was performed to evaluate the significance of reporting atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS) on cervical smears. During this period 114 (0.7%) of 17,330 smears were diagnosed as ASCUS, 62 of which resulted in either follow-up cervical biopsies and/or endocervical curettages (61%) or repeat smears (39%), and form the basis of this study. Tissue specimens (38 cases) were negative in 24 cases (63%) and were positive in 14 cases (37%). Of the positive specimens, there were 9 low grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (LSIL) and 5 high grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSIL). Repeat smears (24 cases) were negative in 19 cases (79%) and were persistent for a lesion in 5 cases (21%). The persistent lesions consisted of 2 ASCUS and 3 LSIL. Overall, of the 62 cases, 43 (69%) were negative and 19 (31%) showed a lesion on follow-up tissue specimens or smears. Of the 62 cases, ASCUS diagnoses included cellular changes suggestive of human papillomavirus infection in 17 (27%) cases, nondiagnostic cellular changes in 16 (26%) cases, atypical squamous metaplasia vs. a squamous intraepithelial lesion (SIL) in 15 (24%) cases, inflammatory cell changes vs. a LSIL in 5 (8%) cases, 2 of which contained candida, and atrophic cellular changes in 1 (2%) case. In the remaining 8 (13%) cases, proper cytologic analysis was hampered by partially obscuring acute inflammation (3 cases) and low cellularity (5 cases). The results of this study would indicate that the reporting of ASCUS on cervical smears does lead to the detection of SILs in a significant number of cases (31% in this study). Therefore, further evaluation of the patient is suggested.

The significance of mild squamous atypia on cytology.

Between January, 1991 and February, 1993 inclusive, 396 Papanicolaou smears were reported to show Mild Squamous Atypia with or without Human Papilloma Virus (MSA +/- HPV). All women with MSA +/- HPV smears were routinely recalled for colposcopy. To determine the significance of MSA +/- HPV on routine smear screening, the records of all patients were reviewed. Three hundred and thirty-seven women (85.1%) attended the colposcopy clinic and are the subjects analyzed for this report. The remaining 59 (14.9%) failed to attend. Intraepithelial neoplasia was found in 61 patients (18.1%), of whom 27 (8.0%) had a high grade lesion (CIN 2 or 3 or GIN 2). No patient had invasive cancer of the cervix. Only 1 of the 45 pregnant women had a significant lesion. It is concluded that all asymptomatic women with MSA +/- HPV on cervical smear may be managed in accordance with the current NH and MRC recommendations (1) and have a repeat smear in 6 months and colposcopy if the abnormality persists at 12 months.

Every woman with an abnormal cervical smear should be referred for treatment: debate.

No dispute exists regarding the optimal management of women with moderate or severe dyskaryosis (high grade SIL). These women should have a colposcopic assessment and biopsy. Women with borderline nuclear abnormalities should have a repeat smear and undergo colposcopy only if the abnormality persists. Low-grade abnormalities (low-grade SIL) are common, and their management is relevant. We suggest that these women be referred for an immediate colposcopic assessment for the following reasons: a. a policy of cytologic surveillance allows an opportunity for default, and these women are at an increased risk of invasive cancer. b. a significant proportion of these women will have underlying CIN grade III that should be treated. c. a minority of these women revert to cytologic normality without a recurrent dyskaryotic smear and, therefore, eventually will be referred to colposcopy. d. a policy of immediate referral to colposcopy may be financially less expensive and avoid unnecessary anxiety to the woman during the period of undergoing repeated smears.