This work assessed the impact of methylparaben, ethylparaben, propylparaben, and butylparaben (200 μg L−1 each) on the granulation process as well as on the organic matter and nutrient removal of an aerobic granular sludge (AGS) system (6-h cycle). Additionally, some insights into the main paraben removal mechanisms were provided. In the presence of parabens, aerobic granules with good settleability, but with fragile and irregular structure, were grown. No significant effect of parabens on organic matter (>90%) and nitrogen (~70%) removal was evidenced. On the other hand, phosphorus removal was slightly impaired, although high removal efficiencies (~70%) were reached. High paraben removal efficiencies were achieved (>85%) in the AGS system, with methylparaben being the most recalcitrant compound. Concerning the removal mechanisms, biotransformation was the main mechanism in the removal of all parabens (85.5% for methylparaben and 100% for the others), whereas, apparently, adsorption played a role only in the removal of methylparaben. In addition, this compound was also suggested as a probable intermediate of the degradation of the larger alkyl-chain parabens. Lastly, regarding the microbial community, with the exception of Mycobacterium, the reactors shared the same genera, which may explain their comparable operational performances. Additionally, some genera that developed more in the presence of parabens may be related to their degradation. Therefore, although antimicrobial agents such as parabens compromised the granule structure, AGS system maintained a good operational performance and showed to be very efficient in paraben removal.
Read full abstract