Axillary breast tissue includes any combination of fat, nipple, areolae, and glandular tissue alongside breasts and affects 2%-6% of women and 1%-3% of men. Patients may experience functional and/or cosmetic concerns due to axillary breast tissue. There are nonsurgical options for its removal, such as CoolSculpting and Kybella, and surgical options such as liposuction, BodyTite liposuction, and excision. Determining which technique to use in each case is critical in achieving an excellent outcome. Currently, there are no established treatment algorithms for the removal of axillary breast tissue. A retrospective review between January 1, 2013, and June 20, 2022, was performed. Data that were extracted included age, BMI, date of procedure, procedure, fat suctioned, tissue excised, and follow-up period. The authors analyzed outcomes and formulated a treatment algorithm based on tissue type (fat versus glandular), amount of tissue excess, skin laxity, and accessory nipple presence. A total of 43 patients (83 axillae) met our inclusion criteria and were included in our analysis. All patients were female with a mean age of 35.5 ± 10.9 years, a mean BMI of 23.0 ± 3.1, and a mean follow-up period of 8.8 ± 11.1 months. For inclusion, patients had to have undergone CoolSculpting, liposuction, BodyTite liposuction, liposuction with excision, or excision alone. All patients tolerated the procedures well and reported no serious complications. Nonsurgical and surgical removal of axillary breast tissue is safe and effective. The algorithm presented can be utilized by plastic and reconstructive surgeons to ensure optimal results for axillary breast tissue removal.