The shear viscosity of 66 liquids in the systems CaO-Al 2O 3-SiO 2 (CAS) and MgO-Al 2O 3-SiO 2 (MAS) have been measured in the ranges 1–10 4 Pa s and 10 8–10 12 Pa s. Liquids belong to series, nominally at 50, 67, and 75 mol.% SiO 2, with atomic M 2+ /(M 2+ + 2Al) typically in the range 0.60 to 0.40 for each isopleth. In the system CAS at 1600°C, viscosity passes through a maximum at all silica contents. The maxima are clearly centered in the peraluminous field, but the exact composition at which viscosity is a maximum is poorly defined. Similar features are observed at 900°C. In contrast, data for the system MAS at 1600°C show that viscosity decreases with decreasing Mg/(Mg + 2Al) at all silica contents, but that a maximum in viscosity must occur in the field where Mg/2Al >1. On the other hand, the viscosity at 850°C increases with decreasing Mg/(Mg + 2Al) and shows no sign of reaching a maximum, even for the most peraluminous composition studied. The data from both systems at 1600°C have been analysed assuming that shear viscosity is proportional to average bond strength and considering the equilibrium: Al [ 4 ] - ( Mg , Ca ) 0.5 ⇔ ( Mg,Ca ) 0.5 -NBO + Al XS where Al [4]-(Mg,Ca) 0.5 represents a charge-balanced tetrahedrally coordinated Al; (Mg, Ca) 0.5–NBO represents a nonbridging oxygen (NBO) associated with Ca or Mg, and Al XS represents any structural role of Al that does not require a charge-balancing cation. The viscosity data were fitted using two adjustable variables: i) the equilibrium constant of the above reaction, and ii) the relative bond strength of Al XS. The values of these parameters in the system CAS suggest that Al XS remains in tetrahedral coordination, its charge deficit being satisfied by association with a three-coordinate oxygen in a structure called a tricluster. In contrast, fits to the MAS data at 1600°C infer the presence of high-coordinate Al. These interpretations are found to be consistent with independent spectroscopic and theoretical data. Furthermore, the fitted value of the equilibrium constant in the system MAS is close to zero, implying that Al has no thermodynamic preference to be charge-balanced by Mg. In light of these results, it is shown that values of the ratio ‘NBO/T’ (the ratio of NBO to tetrahedrally coordinated network formers) will not be a true reflection of the polymerisation state of the liquid if it is assumed that all Al is charge-balanced by metal cations. This will be important to take into account when considering the compositional dependence of physical and thermodynamic parameters and may have direct relevance to certain liquids produced during partial melting of the mantle.