Multiple Canadian jurisdictions have reported a pattern of chronic pain among people who died from substance-related acute toxicity. This study examined the prevalence and characteristics of those with chronic pain using data from a national study of people who died of accidental acute toxicity. A cross-sectional analysis of accidental substance-related acute toxicity deaths that occurred in Canada between 1 January 2016 and 31 December 2017 was conducted. The prevalence of pain and pain-related conditions were summarized as counts and percentages of the overall sample. Subgroups of people with and without a documented history of chronic pain were compared across sociodemographic characteristics, health history, contextual factors and substances involved. From the overall sample (n = 7902), 1056 (13%) people had a history of chronic pain while 6366 (81%) had no documented history. Those with chronic pain tended to be older (40 years and older), unemployed, retired and/or receiving disability supports around the time of death. History of mental health conditions, trauma and surgery or injury was significantly more prevalent among people with chronic pain. Of the substances that most frequently contributed to death, opioids typically prescribed for pain (hydromorphone and oxycodone) were detected in toxicology more often among those with chronic pain than those without. Findings underscore the cross-cutting role of multiple comorbidities and unmanaged pain, which could compound the risk of acute toxicity death. Continued prioritization of harm reduction and regular patient engagement to assess ongoing needs are among the various opportunities for intervention.