ObjectiveIn dialysis patients, cinacalcet could be an effective alternative to parathyroidectomy for treating hyperparathyroidism. In the present study, we aimed to determine the characteristics of subjects with persistent hyperparathyroidism who require parathyroidectomy despite the use of cinacalcet. MethodsNine kidney transplant patients (7 men, 2 women; mean age 53.2 [SD, 8.9] years) who had tertiary hyperparathyroidism were reviewed in a single center. Pre- and postcinacalcet levels of calcium, phosphorous, intact parathyroid hormone (iPTH), and renal function were analyzed to evaluate the effect of cinacalcet treatment in these patients. The baseline parameters before cinacalcet treatment were compared in patients who did and did not undergo parathyroidectomy. ResultsCinacalcet reduced serum calcium levels in all patients (11.48 [SD, 0.73] mg/dL to 10.20 [0.70] mg/dL; P = .008). Serum phosphorous levels significantly increased from 2.28 (SD, 0.77) mg/dL to 3.02 (SD, 0.65) mg/dL (P = .03). The iPTH levels in 7 patients decreased, while the mean level remained unchanged in total subjects. The iPTH levels increased even with cinacalcet treatment in 2 patients. In 3 patients, serum calcium levels abruptly increased after cinacalcet withdrawal. Five patients who showed persistent hypercalcemia due to hyperparathyroidism underwent parathyroidectomy. These 5 patients had significantly different characteristics compared with 4 patients who did not undergo parathyroidectomy: hypercalcemia (11.92 [SD, 0.68] mg/dL vs 10.93 [SD, 0.26] mg/dL; P = .02), hypophosphatemia (1.74 [SD, 0.36] mg/dL vs 2.95 [SD, 0.58] mg/dL; P = .03), and hyperparathyroidism (252.2 [SD, 131.4] pg/dL vs 101.5 [SD, 18.4] pg/dL; P = .02). ConclusionCinacalcet reduced hypercalcemia due to hyperparathyroidism in the transplant patients. However, patients who had pre-existing higher iPTH, hypercalcemia, and hypophosphatemia needed parathyroidectomy. Therefore, cinacalcet could be considered an alternative to parathyroidectomy in selected patients.