Introduction: The 2015 Dietary Guidelines for Americans (DGA) recommends consuming low-fat or fat-free dairy foods due to concerns about excess intake of energy, which can lead to overweight or obesity, and saturated fat, a type of fat that can increase blood levels of low-density lipoprotein cholesterol, a blood biomarker used to predict cardiovascular disease risk. The 2015 DGA recommends limiting intake of saturated fats to less than 10% of calories per day and balancing energy intake. Hypothesis: The objective of this study was to assess the impact of replacing one serving of fat-free dairy foods provided in current models of the 2000-calorie Healthy U.S.-Style Eating Pattern (HUSEP) with one serving of whole- or reduced-fat dairy foods. We hypothesized that this replacement would still result in an eating pattern within calorie, saturated fat, and sodium limits. Methods: Utilizing the same food pattern modeling procedures used for the 2015 DGA, we assessed the energy and nutrient composition of six alternative models of the 2000-calorie HUSEP. In each pattern, we replaced 1 of the 3 servings of the USDA’s fat-free dairy food composite with whole- or reduced-fat dairy products or whole-/reduced-fat dairy composites. The 6 replacement models included replacements with: 1) a whole-fat dairy food composite, 2) a reduced-fat dairy food composite, 3) whole milk, 4) reduced-fat milk, 5) whole-fat cheese, and 6) reduced-fat cheese. Results: In all 6 models, the amount of saturated fat did not exceed 10% of total calories. In models 2, 3, and 4, saturated fat was 9% of total calories. The amount of energy increased slightly in all models. The original HUSEP provided 2003 calories, and the 6 models in this study provided an additional 45 (Model 4) to 94 (Model 5) additional calories. The amount of sodium also increased. The original HUSEP provides 1787 mg of sodium, and these models provided between 2082 and 2683 mg of sodium. While still lower than the current average sodium intake (3,440 mg/d), the amount of sodium in Models 1, 2, 5, and 6 exceeds 2,300 mg/d, the Chronic Disease Risk Reduction Intake level for sodium. Conclusions: Results of this study indicate that some reduced- and whole-fat dairy foods, especially milk, can fit into calorie-balanced healthy eating patterns that also align with saturated fat and sodium recommendations. Allowing some flexibility in fat level of dairy food servings aligns with the 2010 DGA recommendation that calories from solid fats and added sugars are best used to increase the palatability of nutrient-dense foods, which includes milk, cheese, and yogurt.