We evaluated the pathologies of anterior capsular mechanism in older patients with recurrent anterior shoulder dislocation in the absence of full-thickness rotator cuff tears. Three hundred and ninety-five shoulders with recurrent anterior shoulder dislocation were assessed. The patients were divided into three groups by the age at the first dislocation and the surgical treatment: group A (onset and treatment were at an age over 40 years), group B (onset was at an age under 40 years and treatment was at an age over 40 years) and group C (onset and treatment were at an age under 40 years). Groups A, B and C involved nine, 31 and 355 shoulders, respectively. The prevalence of an isolated Bankart lesion was 81.7 % in group C, 33.3 % in group A and 64.5 % in group B, and each of A and B was significantly lower than group C. The prevalence of an isolated capsular tear was 3.1 % in group C, while it was 33.3 % in group A, which was significantly higher. The prevalence of an isolated Bankart lesion was low and the prevalence of a capsular tear was high in older patients. We should keep in mind the existence of a capsular tear in older patients and examine the whole anterior capsular mechanism meticulously.